The Movimento dos Trabalhadores Rurais Sem Terra (Landless Workers' Movement, MST), founded in 1984, has been studied extensively, both in Brazil and abroad, by manifold disciplines and from many different viewpoints, ranging from sympathy to hostility towards the movement's main method of using land occupations/invasions to push for a pro-poor agrarian reform. Wendy Wolford's book on rural mobilisation in Brazil is a delightfully interdisciplinary, broad and mixed piece in the set. Lucidly and smoothly written, and relying on vivid and well-contextualised interviews as its main data, the book makes an easy and fascinating read.
The author has spent substantial time in the field with the families of two land reform settlements. She is able to provide good ethnography through personally observed accounts of key events explaining entry and exit from the movement. Two small sub-areas of the vastly complex Brazilian rural world are the focus of the book: a settlement in southern Pernambuco state on the fertile soils of the sugar-cane region of north-eastern Brazil, on which most emphasis is laid, and a settlement in Santa Catarina state in southern Brazil. The latter is dealt with more cursorily, mostly to acquaint the reader with the origins of the movement and to accentuate how different contexts of ‘moral economy’ influence mobilisation, activism, land reform and, more broadly, political economy.
The decision to focus on the north-east was a good one: the region, one of the poorest in Latin America, with persistent and complex practices of inequality but a rich cultural history, has been for many authors a site to find excellent stories and form theories. Wolford's book is no exception in this regard. The events described are very well situated in the history of places and land–labour relations, emphasising the importance of context and the pitfalls of trying to diffuse ideas born in other cultural contexts within people accustomed to a different moral economy – that is, whose customs and understandings of what constitutes a just type of leadership and appropriation of land are poles apart.
The book is actually not a systematic analysis of the MST, nor is it a book on agrarian reform in Brazil, the political economy of sugar cane, or peasant activism in Brazil, even though it provides good insights on these subjects. Rather, as the author points out at the beginning, hooking the reader and keeping the tension until the end, this is a different type of book on the MST, explaining the splintering of the movement in the sugar-cane region of Pernambuco in the early 2000s. The renegades within a revolutionary movement, and their reasons for counter-mobilisation, are the theme. Activists and scholars interested in understanding the role of context in the failure of rural movements to attain their goals and the failure of agrarian change will find many worthwhile lessons here.
The theoretical section is very broad and a multitude of scholars from Jacques Derrida to authors of the Indian subaltern studies school are used. A dream of the postmodern cultural relativism approach is fulfilled, as the author explains (and finds) subversion where even the majority of scholars and activists connected with and interested in social movements would not have dared to look: within a vanguard movement. The findings illustrate how moral economies influence the interplay between those who imagine belonging to a movement, or are influenced by it, and the actions of the leaders.
The chapters can be read separately: information is presented on a wide spectrum of noteworthy issues. This is both a weakness and strength of the book, which in this sense resembles a collection of articles. The second chapter provides one of the best accounts of the MST's rise I have seen. Here, as throughout the book, heavy emphasis is laid on peasant studies, whose main paradigms are well presented.
Many methods and data are used: the third chapter, for example, offers a detailed and systematic discourse analysis of changes in an internal newspaper of the movement in the 1990s. The chapter also discusses a failed collective cooperative in a Santa Catarina settlement. Chapter 4 is a good and clear depiction of land–labour relationships in the north-east, a stepping stone to the rest of the book. Chapters 5 and 6 are the juiciest and best part of the book, excellent in understanding political economy on a very deep cultural level. The analysis here answers well to the promises made in the theoretical part, demonstrating how theories of moral economy can be used in practice.
Many explanations for the decision to leave the movement are given, perhaps in too short a space, including differences in property, family, gender and work relations between the sugar-cane workers and the movement leaders. The greatest explanatory power is conferred on the understanding of settlement land as offering ‘privacy’ to the former sugar-cane cutters, which, according to Wolford, was violated by the MST leaders' southern understanding of land as a ‘social good’. The theorised difference is supposedly illustrated by a messy and not particularly well-depicted episode where the leaders were promised the right to build a regional headquarters on a piece of communal settlement land, but were driven out by the settlers after the building was renovated and before they could move in. The way in which the settlers reacted to a schism drew on the local moral economy, the plantations' land–labour relations where workers' skills and ideas of livelihood possibilities were limited to sugar-cane cutting: ‘the settlers utilized a strategy that had been common on the plantations when a conflict with the owner occurred: they left’ (p. 210), and became small-scale sugar-cane providers for nearby mills.
As a caveat, the book perhaps focuses too narrowly on two settlements, of which the one in the north-east was not even primarily an MST settlement per se (in the sense that it was established by a united occupation group), but founded by an unusual path where many would-be settlers were already residing on the land: even the plantation renter and administrators got pieces (the best ones) in the settlement. Due to this limitation in data, the conclusions are not as strong as they could be, and analysis of, for example, the MST's efficiency and responsibility in the story remains limited. The events leading to the exit from the settlement could have been discussed more broadly: the MST's side of the story is not quoted in equal length to that of the renegades, for example.
In spite of the weaknesses in coverage, this is an important book. Through an interdisciplinary discussion of movement members' multiplicity, Wolford manages to show that if agrarian change is not put into effect by the volition of local people, the envisioned process of liberation from misery will not gain enduring followers.
