The Religious Life of Palmyra, published by Ted Kaizer in 2002, represented a ‘turning point’ in the study of religion in Palmyra (to quote Tommaso Gnoli, one of the contributors to this volume (161)). The volume under review, edited by Rubina Raja, is based on a conference held at the Royal Academy of Sciences and Letters in Copenhagen in 2017 to revisit that seminal volume, gathering key international scholars to ask why the study of ancient religious life within the context of a single site matters. The answer to that question is almost self-evident: first, because the evidence from Palmyra is so exceptional, and second, because there is still so much that we do not understand. From enigmatic iconography including hand gestures (discussed in chapters by Maura Heyn and Rubina Raja) to the character of Greek deities in Palmyra (the topic of a chapter by Maurice Sartre), many aspects of religious life in ancient Palmyra remain slippery despite much detailed study. The volume delves into that exceptional evidence through twelve contributions, including an introductory essay by Raja and one by Kaizer reflecting on historiographical developments since the publication of his 2002 volume. The ‘religious life’ of Palmyra (a formulation which deliberately shifts the focus away from deities and towards worshippers, as noted by Kaizer (8)) is known through epigraphy and sculpture, so it is those forms of evidence that the essays in the volume primarily utilise.
In addition to her introduction, Raja offers a second chapter on the ‘Curtain of Death’ which appears on Palmyrene funerary sculpture. It is accompanied by a catalogue, which takes up more than a third of the volume's pages and itemises 246 Palmyrene sculptures depicting the curtain, often known as the dorsalium, a term Raja convincingly argues should not be used in Palmyrene contexts. Raja's study illuminates the way the depiction of this textile, which usually appears behind figures on reliefs, probably relates to funerary ritual. More broadly, the chapter demonstrates the type of detailed analysis which is now possible thanks to the Palmyra Portrait Project, which has brought together Palmyrene sculptures which are globally dispersed. The problematic history which underpins the need for that project quietly haunts the historiography of Palmyrene sculpture and all that has been based on it (by way of an example: the thorough and useful indexes following the volume do not include ‘trafficking’ or ‘cultural property’, but the index of ‘Museums and Collections’ lists dozens of public and private institutions which hold Palmyrene material referenced in the volume, from Stanford to St Petersburg).
The way in which representations of Palmyrene deities in sculpture and inscriptions are related to religious life is the topic of a number of chapters, including that of Sartre on the meaning of the ‘Greek’ gods in Palmyra (Tyche, Nemesis, Isis and Heracles). Aleksandra Kubiak-Schneider focuses on the relationship the concept of mercy at Palmyra might have to Babylonian theology, based on twenty-two Palmyrene inscriptions on stone altars dated to the second and third centuries and dedicated to a god known simply as ‘the merciful’. These inscriptions, she argues, might fill the gap otherwise left by the lack of votive inscriptions solely to Bel, the divine patron of the city at the site itself (173–4). Maura Heyn gives a novel reading of an enigmatic gesture which appears in Palmyrene sculpture, the one-handed palm-forward gesture made by women in funerary contexts. Heyn suggests this relates to women's role in communicating with ancestral or other deities during visits to the tomb (158)—difficult to prove, as the author admits, but a useful hypothesis. Eleanora Cussini focuses on the evidence of altars as a means of considering the devotion of worshippers. A rich chapter by Lucinda Dirven considers the importance of divine images to a consideration of religious practice; among Dirven's conclusions is that the material shows a ‘strong sense of traditionalism’ (47). The importance of the past is also evident in the material explored by Jean-Baptiste Yon, in one of two chapters on the ancient Palmyrene diaspora, for whom devotion to ancestral gods were frequent (177). The topic of Palmyrenes far from home is also explored by Eivind Heldaas Seland, who considers the portability of their religious practices. Tommaso Gnoli studies the armed gods who are relatively rarely depicted in Palmyra itself, but more common in the villages of its hinterland. Nathanael Andrade looks not to Palmyrene epigraphy and visual evidence as do the other authors, but to the apocryphal Acts of Thomas, a fourth-century Latin text that described the apostle Thomas travelling to India. Andrade carefully unearths how this narrative preserved a name, that of King Gondophares, known through Palmyrene networks that had stretched to India centuries earlier. The volume is essential reading for anyone concerned with Palmyra and ancient religious life there. If not quite the ‘turning point’ of the original volume, it nonetheless provides a range of new insights into the oasis city in the first three centuries c.e.
