In the introduction to Gestures of Music Theater: The Performativity of Song and Dance, editors Dominic Symonds and Millie Taylor set up the scope of this collection of essays as an exploration of song and dance as performative gestures or the use of the body in expression of musicality. The editors open up the categories of song and dance, investigating any form of musicality, including the spoken word, that breaks beyond the traditional barriers of “music theater” parlance. From here, the editors posit two general constructs that are carried throughout the book. The first of these is the notion that song and dance are corporeal gestures. The second is that these gestures relate harmoniously with performativity. Within this collection of essays featuring seventeen various scholars, Symonds and Taylor, for the most part, weave together strong essays that speak to these common theses.
Dominic Symonds opens the collection in Part I, “Singing the Dance, Dancing the Song,” with a discussion about how society's conception of song as oral performance has been altered by technology, arguing that the transitory term “song” is replaced with “sung,” thereby becoming an object ripe for commodification. In the next chapter, Carlo Zuccarini explores opera through the lens of neuroscience as well as the psychology behind one's reception of operatic music. Part II, “Performativity as Dramaturgy,” begins with George Rodosthenous's performative and political look at Julie Taymor's film Across the Universe, exploring the gendered and geographical relocations of the Beatles' songs within the film's plot and song lyrics. Following that is Ben Macpherson's dramaturgical study regarding the energy and affect created by singing and dancing bodies in the musical Cats. Mary Jo Lodge begins Part III, “Performativity as Transition,” with an essay on dance that addresses the challenges of liminal moments in musical theatre, arguing for a diegetic approach to choreography. In the second chapter of this part, Matthew Lockitt thoroughly explores whether songs work as moments of animation or suspension in terms of liminal encounters in Michael John LaChiusa's Bernarda Alba. Part IV, “Performativity as Identity,” explores performance within the contexts of race, character identity, and masculinity through Kathyrn Edney's essay on Jelly's Last Jam, Jessica Sternfield's discussion on the television show Glee, and Judith A. Sebesta's reflection on male dancers in musical theatre, respectively. Identity and presence are explored in Part V, “Performativity as Context.” Ainhoa Kaiero Claver deconstructs the singer/performance artist Laurie Anderson; Zeynep Bulut considers the immediacy of presence in Susan Philipsz's Lowlands; Marianne Sharp assesses Fiona Shaw's performance in Beckett's Happy Days, examining how the musicality of the play's language and vocal score threaten individual identity. Part VI, “Performativity as Practice,” examines the disparate practical approaches to performance. Caroline Wilkins provides a personal exploration of how live and mediated vocal energies work with her own body and voice in performance to articulate the performative gesture; Sabine Wilden looks at how choreographers listen and respond to music in order to create a performative, physicalized expression; and Konstantinos Thomaidis uses Poland's Gardzienice Theatre as a vehicle to discuss expressive gestures of vocality and physicality in order to understand the performative gesture in practice. The collection concludes with Part VII, “Performativity as Community,” in which Bethany Hughes deliberates on how the chorus in musical theatre functions as a community and considers whether the physical and material gestures of song and dance are dimensions and subsets of the work itself. Millie Taylor finishes the collection by examining the musical A Chorus Line's engagement with the politics of the ensemble and exploring the identities of its characters, performers, and audience.
One bit of clarification should be offered to the potential reader of Gestures of Music Theater. The title of this edited volume as well as the picture of the musical A Chorus Line on the front cover may lead one to believe it is a study of conventional musical theatre, but the book's scope is far more varied. As a collection, this book explores music as theatre, which includes concert performance, opera, film, television, dance, performance art, as well as musical theatre in the traditional sense of the term.
Gestures of Music Theater offers wide-ranging scholarship on the many ways in which performance can be explored through music as theatre. The book is meticulously researched, sports impressive bibliographies, and most of the essays are rigorously theorized. Symonds and Taylor have assembled a group of scholars from the fields of music, musicology, psychology, musical theatre, and theatre who generally provide innovative theories that speak to the book's overall scope. The book's interdisciplinary nature is both a strength and vulnerability, however, in that by including so many diverse fields—including neurology, musicology, psychology, cultural studies, theatre, and musical theatre—the book's target audience is hard to distinguish. The editors proclaim this to be a deliberate choice, but the pieces in the book still feel a bit disassociated from one another.
Although several theory-based historiographical studies have been published on musical theatre—for example John Bush Jones's Our Musicals, Ourselves and Changed for Good by Stacy Wolf—there are few musical theatre theory-based books beyond Symonds and Taylor's own Studying Musical Theatre: Theory and Practice. As musical theatre continues its uphill climb toward serious scholarly consideration in academia, the editors and scholars in Gestures of Music Theater deserve praise for opening up new theoretical approaches to music as theatre.
