We are fortunate to have two monographs on Robert Bellarmine (1542–1621), the Jesuit cardinal and polemicist, published in the same year. Each is focused on Bellarmine's thought on Christian society, especially his argument that the pope had indirect, but not direct, power in temporal affairs (potestas indirecta). Tutino's book provides an overview of Bellarmine's polemical exchanges on this topic, beginning with his published volumes of controversiae. No one of his foes is treated in depth, but several are treated insofar as they were involved in one exchange of pamphlets or another. Bourdin focuses on one of these controversies, that between James I of England and Bellarmine over the oath of allegiance the king imposed on his subjects in 1606 after the failure of the Gunpowder Plot to kill him, the queen, and Parliament during the previous year.
Tutino's book is an extensive study of one concept as it played out not just in Rome but across Western Europe. Bellarmine developed his theory of indirect power while teaching in Rome. He tried to ground his teaching and his students' studies not just in casuistry but in Scholastic theology. Bellarmine rejected any idea that the pope had direct power from Christ in temporal affairs. Christ's kingdom was not of this world, and so his vicar could not claim temporal power except over the Papal States in Italy. Papal power was supposed to promote the salvation of souls, not direct intervention in purely temporal matters. The pontiff could, however, intervene when salvation was at stake, including by excommunicating the ruler. In such a case, subjects might rise up against an unjust ruler. Bellarmine also was not a strong defender of clerical immunities as divinely ordained, a matter that would plague him in later controversies. As a cardinal, promoted in 1599, Bellarmine played an active role in the Congregation of the Inquisition and the Congregation of the Index, dealing with issues of faith, including the censorship of books on sensitive topics such as faith and morals.
The controversy that revealed this weakness was triggered by the interdict Pope Paul V imposed on Venice in 1606. The Republic had imposed restrictions on the clergy and ordered trials for two clerics by a lay judge for crimes they had committed. The pope imposed an interdict on the Republic, and a pamphlet war ensued. The resulting exchange of published polemics, circulated far outside Italy, pitted the Servite friar Paolo Sarpi against Bellarmine. Sarpi, the Venetian apologist, pointed to Bellarmine's soft stand on clerical immunity as a flaw in his theory, arguing that it left clerics guilty of criminal offenses open to trial by the lay authorities. Criticism of Bellarmine also came from within the Roman curia, where some prelates, like Francisco Peña, thought the Jesuit too weak on the divine origin of papal temporal power and on the immunities of the clergy. Bellarmine stoutly defended indirect power against both critiques, although his argument against Sarpi occasionally seems strained.
A different aspect of Bellarmine's theory was central to the controversy over the oath of allegiance. Bellarmine opposed tyrannicide, unlike the Spanish Jesuits Francisco Suarez and Juan de Marianna. He still argued, however, that a pope could excommunicate rulers whose actions endangered the salvation of souls. Bellarmine also regarded the oath as an effort to promote royal supremacy in the English church at the expense of papal spiritual authority. The result was an exchange of pamphlets between Rome and England, but there also were follow-up exchanges on the Continent. Arguments that helped French Catholics against Gallicans and Huguenots did not play out well in Germany with its confessional divisions, and vice versa. Thus Martin Becanus, who tried to defend Bellarmine's doctrine in Germany to uphold Catholic interests against Protestant princes, was badly received by French Catholic supporters of Rome, who did not want to fight the Gallicans during the minority of King Louis XIII.
Bourdin deals with the controversy over the oath, but he focuses more on James I than on Bellarmine. His sketch of the English background to the debate shows the crown dealing with both Catholic and Protestant opposition. James was willing to tolerate either opinion as long as his own power over the visible church was acknowledged and the English episcopate was retained. This theory was too Episcopal for the Presbyterians; and it was too much like Caesaropapism for many Catholics, especially for English Jesuits such as Robert Persons. Bourdin gives us much of the king's thought, beginning with his reaction against George Buchanan, his tutor, who was an advocate of limited monarchy. The king saw himself as possessing a divine right to rule, and he regarded obedience as required of all his subjects without any right to protest. The ruler was answerable to God alone. Bellarmine was unwilling to grant the king so much power in matters affecting souls. The pope could not encourage disobedience in purely temporal matters, but he could impose spiritual censures on erring monarchs. Bourdin points out, in conclusion, that the crown would win in the long term. Bellarmine tried to preserve a papal role in temporalities, but political developments would favor lay rulers. The papacy and clergy in general lost almost any claim to temporal power in the strong states of modern Europe.
Bourdin gives us little of Bellarmine's thought, which should be sought in Tutino's book. However, he gives us excerpts from relevant texts, including from some of the English official acts at the heart of the controversy. The conclusion allows that the triumph of the lay authority was not inevitable, but both James and the cardinal were writing when claims by the clergy to temporal authority were being abandoned by many intellectuals on either side of the Reformation divide in order to win lay support and the internal peace of territorial states.
