During the Renaissance and baroque eras, courts across Europe staged spectacular festivals to celebrate royal marriages, formal entries into cities, and international congresses. These events, although ephemeral, were astonishingly elaborate. Renowned artists, architects, musicians, and poets collaborated to stage multiday entertainments that included ballets, jousts, mock water battles, masquerades, and lavish feasts. Alongside members of the royal family and powerful nobles, foreign dignitaries and diplomats were invited to participate as performers and spectators. A Theater of Diplomacy: International Relations and the Performing Arts in Early Modern France brings to life this vibrant, lost world of courtly performance. Building on Roy Strong's Art and Power: Renaissance Festivals, 1450–1650 (University of California Press, 1984), which drew attention to the political symbolism of these fetes and their importance for state building, Ellen Welch's monograph deepens our understanding of the politics of court performances by approaching them from the perspective of international relations. “[W]hat kind of diplomatic work,” Welch asks, “did these entertainments perform?” (2).
A Theater of Diplomacy focuses primarily on the court spectacles during the centuries when France emerged as militarily and culturally dominant on the Continent and when French became the language of European diplomacy. The book includes eight chronological chapters, each examining a different set of performances. It traces the monarchy's use of cultural diplomacy from the 1560s, with Catherine de’ Medici's efforts to shore up royal authority in the context of religious and civil war, to the renowned fetes staged at Versailles by Louis XIV. By the end of the Sun King's reign, the Paris Opera and print culture offered competing arenas in which the theatre of diplomacy was conducted.
Welch draws on a wealth of sources and images to reconstruct the immersive performances that celebrated French leadership while also imagining an ideal of unity and harmony for a divided Europe. The royal government generated publicity by publishing official accounts that included libretti and detailed descriptions of sets and costumes. Eyewitness accounts written by diplomats from various European kingdoms and city-states relay their impressions and experiences. These dual perspectives undergird the close textual readings that form the heart of this monograph.
Thick description of performances is woven with a discussion of changing norms in diplomacy, which long remained an aristocratic profession. A successful ambassador was expected to be eloquent, attractive, and skilled in singing, dancing, and horseback riding. The ability to dissimulate was crucial. Already during the early modern era, Welch observes, contemporaries used theatre metaphors when discussing diplomacy, describing ambassadors as “actor[s]” and their work as “‘art’” (2).
As dance and performance became staples of aristocratic entertainment throughout Europe, visiting diplomats and resident ambassadors came to expect such diversions, which presented the host country with an opportunity to display its sophistication, grandeur, and wealth. A Theater of Diplomacy begins with a discussion of sixteenth- and early seventeenth-century spectacles that featured aspirational celebrations of harmony, concord, and festive unity before international audiences drawn from a Europe that was religiously and politically divided. Later, during the Thirty Years’ War, court festivals celebrated advantageous wartime alliances or sought to persuade audiences to follow a French-led peace. Ballets featuring ethnically dressed characters in a parade of nations allegorically represented France's vision of an idealized European order.
Although scholars frequently approach courtly entertainments as royal propaganda, Welch argues for a more nuanced approach. Allegory, she writes, staged “potentialities and aspirations as well as historical events and predetermined political ideologies,” allowing ballets to become “imaginative aid[s] for an international community in crisis” (83). Moreover, one of the book's main contributions is to document the ways in which, whatever their intended messages, these events were open to interpretation, misunderstanding, and contestation. Welch skillfully uses diplomats’ letters to demonstrate that even as performances provided entertainment, they were also occasions to jockey for position. Invitation lists and seating charts sparked jealousy; social slights became matters of state. Allegories of unity notwithstanding, these celebrations regularly generated some degree of discord.
Welch argues that under an increasingly absolutist regime, the tone of spectacles shifted from one of persuasion and even collaboration to coercion. At Versailles, the king himself took on the starring role. Diplomats were less likely to be featured as actual actors, and as the court ballooned in size, events became less intimate. Ambassadors were relegated to a more passive role that some resented. Meanwhile, diplomacy itself grew increasingly routinized and impersonal.
One fascinating chapter examines the cross-cultural conflicts that arose as emissaries from Moscow, Morocco, the Ottoman Empire, Persia, and several other states beyond Europe's borders visited the French court. Feted with visits to palace gardens, concerts, and operas, they fascinated Parisian society. These dignitaries, unfamiliar with European ceremonial norms, also behaved in ways that appeared unappreciative and even boorish to their hosts. Meanwhile, comic theatrical representations of Turks and Russians performed at this time—most famously Molière and Lully's Le Bourgeois gentilhomme—were colored by irony and ridicule. Whereas spectatorship within the European diplomatic context served to highlight shared customs, manners, and political expectations, with these visitors it worked “to measure the distance between cultures” (159).
Focused on diplomats, this book says relatively little about the artists who wrote and staged these spectacles. Interestingly, A Theater of Diplomacy is equivocal about whether these festivals shaped policy outcomes. Rather, it frames the diplomatic influence of court theatre as a form of “soft power” (4), a concept also drawn on by Rahul Markovits in Civiliser l'Europe: Politiques du théâtre français au XVIIIe siècle (Fayard, 2014), a study of French-language theatre troupes performing in European courts in the eighteenth century. If French courtly festivals and ballets certainly dazzled diplomats and royal guests, the exercise of soft power, Welch notes, required willing partners to embrace French political leadership. As early modern statesmen gathered to negotiate over war and peace, religious conflict, or economic competition, diplomatic entertainments did not always catalyze such partnerships. Yet they did reshape the protocols and practices of European diplomacy into the nineteenth century and beyond. For scholars of early modern performance, allegory, international relations, and court culture, this deeply researched work has much to offer.
