Alexandra Cuffel's Gendering Disgust in Medieval Religious Polemic focuses on the relationship between accusations of corporeal filth and how such claims illustrate the shifting paradigms of Jewish, Christian, and Muslim views of the body, in particular the female body, from late antiquity to the middle of the 14th century. Relying on a vast array of sources, including midrash, bestiaries, piyuṭim, and medical texts, Cuffel demonstrates how categories of filth and ritual pollution were powerful labels employed to define the religious “other.” Cuffel maintains that somatic polemic occurred in the ancient world among Pagans, Christians, and Jews, but polemic involving dirt and pollution became an integral part of the accusations during the 12th through the 14th centuries.
Building on the work of Ivan Marcus, Cuffel claims that Muslims, Jews, and Christians drew from a common set of social beliefs concerning somatic filth when engaging in religious polemic, which illustrates the shared system of language and symbolism of bodily polemic that spanned from the Islamic and Christian regions of the Mediterranean to northern Europe. Also in keeping with structural anthropologist Mary Douglas, who claimed that each society uses the body as a physical metaphor to reflect the overall social structure, including the community's social anxieties, Cuffel demonstrates how the body additionally served as a trope for late antique and medieval communities, discouraging assimilation.
The book is divided into two parts. The first portion of the text, comprising Chapters 1 and 2, establishes the tradition of bodily polemic used by Christians, Jews, and pagans in late antiquity. Cuffel demonstrates that, despite inherent variations, pagans, Jews, and Christians shared a common set of beliefs and values concerning both human nature and the divine, which allowed them to use polemic against one another. Perhaps the best example is the set of shared beliefs that were centered on the female body. Pagans, Christians, and Jews all viewed the female body, particularly menstrual blood, as foul smelling and a source of disgust. The writings of both Aristotle and Pliny illustrate the classical medical view that equated vaginal filth with fecal matter and putrefaction. The shared belief that menstrual blood was the emission of decaying matter created a dilemma for Christian writers, such as Tertullian, who emphasized Jesus' human nature and placed him in Mary's “filthy” womb. Because women were more closely associated with decay, foul odors, and filth than men, they embodied the very things that repulsed the divine and were, therefore, further removed from the divine realm than men. As a consequence, the Christian acceptance of God as Jesus left Christians open to attack from both pagans and Jews who mocked the idea that the Christian deity was born of a woman and was, ultimately, the product of menstrual blood.
Cuffel concludes that by the 5th century, the focus on God as Jesus began to be viewed in eastern Christendom as the inviolability of God rather than the pollution of God because of an increasing disinterest in bodily imagery relative to theological and philosophical issues. She also attributes the shift in eastern Mediterranean Christian internal polemics from the 5th to the 9th century to the expansion of Christianity, the growth of the church hierarchy, and a widespread familiarity of the issues concerning incarnation among Christians, making the details of bodily functions involved unnecessary. By the 8th and 9th centuries, eastern Christians found a new focus for their polemics, which they began launching at the new “heresy” of Islam. In turn, Muslims adopted the anti-Christian Jewish polemics, such as those regarding the incarnation, in their own writings against Christianity. Because Muslims revered Mary, however, rather than using her as the primary target of insults, they turned to the Christian holy spaces. Like Jews, Muslims mocked the belief that the filthy spaces Christians deemed sacred were worthy of housing God.
The second and most substantial portion of the book addresses the increase in corporeal polemic during the 12th through 14th centuries. As in late antiquity, there was controversy in the medieval period that centered on the Christian deity taking the form of human flesh, but the focus shifted from Jesus to Mary and the Eucharist in the 12th century, because they were the media through which God as Jesus became possible. Cuffel maintains that the translation of Greek and Arabic polemics and medical texts heightened curiosity about women's bodily functions among both Jews and Christians who largely shared the same medical texts and traditions. Medieval medical texts expanded on previous notions of feminine pollution by linking them to leprosy and other forms of decay that were believed to be external signs of internal sinfulness. Cuffel concludes that the prevalent sharing of such ideas also increased anti-Christian polemics and the Christian desire to remove Mary from the realm of human impurities, particularly of those most closely associated with the female body.
Jewish attacks against Christians focused on Mary's womb as a vessel for blood, excrement, urine, and semen and often claimed that Jesus was a product of her whoredom or her physical relationship with Joseph, which would have constituted adultery. Jews had long claimed that Christians were especially susceptible to leprosy, because they had intercourse with their menstruating wives, connecting them to the founder of their faith, Jesus, who also was a product of menstrual blood. Thus, drawing from a long tradition that linked leprosy to the female body and sin, anti-Christian polemics emphasized such Christian bodily practices in an effort to discourage Jewish interaction with Christians whose somatic behaviors were directly linked to their moral degeneracy.
Christians responded with claims that Mary was cleaner than the filthy Jews who were particularly prone to disease, black, and effeminate. Christians also feminized Muslims, claiming they were cowards in battle, lustful, and performed feminine religious rituals. Cuffel notes that although Christians and Muslims portrayed one another as dirty and ridiculous to their fellow believers, they did not make the extreme claims that were reserved for Jews, such as oozing sores. Cuffel concludes that the differences in polemical tactics were the result of European Jews and Christians believing that the other posed a greater threat to their own communities. Because they lived within such close proximity with one another, they shared many of the same resources and cultural mores, which created a much greater possibility of assimilation.
Cuffel has undertaken a highly ambitious task, attempting to address the role of gender, impurity, and filth as a form of interfaith polemic used among Christians, Jews, pagans, and Muslims from the eastern Mediterranean to northern Europe and from the ancient world to the middle of the 14th century. Although such a vast project has led to holes, such as lumping all those who were not Christians or Jews in antiquity into the category of pagans, and the treatment of Muslims almost seems to be an afterthought at times, it is a well-organized book based on an impressive array of sources. Furthermore, it is a highly accessible text suitable for individuals at all stages of scholarship and a success at demonstrating how a shared set of views concerning the body allowed somatic polemic to serve as a medium for expressing the anxieties that different groups felt about maintaining their social hierarchies while discouraging assimilation with rival religious communities.
