The intense sports rivalry between the University of Missouri “Tigers” and the University of Kansas “Jayhawks” that animated fans for more than two decades ended in 2012 when the former school changed conferences. During that time, supporters cited the “Bleeding Kansas” period of the 1850s and the Civil War as the genesis of the competition. Indeed, libraries in the counties along the Kansas–Missouri border preserve numerous stories of devastation and loss that occurred in that region during that period. Murder, arson, physical abuse, intimidation, and the theft and destruction of property occurred on an almost unimaginable scale as pro-slavery Missouri “Border Ruffians”-turned-wartime-guerrillas ruthlessly battled Kansas “Jayhawkers” and their allies and preyed on the civilian population.
This is not a detailed history of that armed conflict, however. Instead, in fifteen concise and enlightening essays, prominent Kansas and Missouri Civil War scholars wrestle with the question why surprisingly similar people on both sides of the border created an atmosphere in which, as the late Michael Fellman states in the introduction, Christian “blood sacrifice” became the norm and mere killing “insufficient” (14–15).
The roots of the border bloodletting began several years before Fort Sumter during the Kansas territorial period. Six essays detail various aspects of this formative time. The first examines the movement of slaveholders and their proponents into the region in the 1820s, 1830s and 1840s. After the passage of the Kansas–Nebraska Act and the advent of “popular sovereignty” in 1854, slaveholders saw themselves as the law-abiding, legitimate victors of popular elections arrayed against anti-law-and-order “Free Staters.” Both sides freely and harshly likened their opponents to uncivilized savages. A fourth essay explores the important role of President James Buchanan and Governor James Denver in territorial politics, particularly relating to the Lecompton Constitution.
Two chapters round out the pre-Civil War period. One examines the efforts of the US Army and the Missouri State Militia to thwart Jayhawker raids into Missouri in 1860. The other highlights both Abraham Lincoln's visit to Kansas in 1859 and the territory's role in guiding his “personal antislavery journey” (120).
Once the war began, Union authorities in Missouri struggled with definitions of loyalty and disloyalty and the curtailment of civil liberties. The determined efforts of both loyal and disloyal slave-owners to maintain that institution made the lives of Missourian civilians and Union soldiers even more problematic.
Only one essay deals in depth with the Missouri guerrillas, a group that came to define the war on the border in the popular imagination. Using the sometimes elaborate, homemade “guerrilla shirt” worn by these partisans, this essay links their “distinctive form of masculinity” with their female supporters at home (170).
A utopian society did not emerge on either side of the border at war's end. The Lexington (MO) Weekly Caucasian newspaper was an early and vitriolic advocate of Democratic resistance to the Radical Republicans and a proponent of white supremacy. Black men in Missouri struggled “for and over the vote” as the Republican Party split and Democrats returned to power (206). Racial violence flared in Kansas even as residents there molded the state's identity into a “free-state narrative” in which settlers had rushed to the territory to halt slavery's expansion, then had fought and died to end that institution (227).
The final two essays highlight the role of the border in popular memory. In the 1890s, at a time when the rhetoric of reconciliation was at its height, the veterans of William Quantrill's guerrilla band began to hold reunions. Their “Lost Cause” supporters depicted them as honorable and moral defenders of hearth and home, while the bitter survivors of the Confederate raid on Lawrence, Kansas could never forgive the aging guerrillas for the August 1863 sacking of their town. The final essay highlights the sports rivalry between the leading state universities in Topeka and Columbia. The schools began their athletic battles in the 1890s, leading to the development of a standard college rivalry that endured for decades. Surprisingly, the Civil War context of the border war did not “seep into the popular imagination” and escalate to mutual hatred until the 1990s (266).
Historical anthologies often vary in quality. A certain amount of redundancy and the inclusion of relatively weak essays are usually to be expected. Such is not the case with Bleeding Kansas, Bleeding Missouri. All fifteen essays are well argued and engagingly written. Anyone hoping to understand the true nature of the Kansas–Missouri border conflict should consider this fine collection as required reading.
