The WTO Agreement on Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property RightsFootnote 1 (TRIPS Agreement) provides for the “global system of governing the ownership and flow of intellectual properties”Footnote 2 from the perspective of trade-IPRs nexus.Footnote 3 In essence, the TRIPS Agreement speaks in favour of establishing a universal, comprehensive, and legally binding set of substantive intellectual property rights (IPRs) standards in seven selected areas, and the regulation of trademarks is one of them.Footnote 4 To meet these standards, the TRIPS Agreement further obliges all the WTO members to take action within their borders by giving effect to a “set of basic minimum principles and rules” embodied in this accord.Footnote 5 The recent enactment of the Trademarks Act of 2009Footnote 6 in Bangladesh has come as a response to comply with this obligation as entailed by the TRIPS Agreement.
By enacting this Act, Bangladesh has tried to bring its laws relating to the regulation of trademarks into conformity with the standards imposed by the TRIPS Agreement. In fact, the present Act has been enacted with two purposes in view: first and foremost, to give effect to the principles and rule of the TRIPS Agreement; and second, to pave the way for Bangladesh to consolidate the revised and amended provisions of the Paris Convention for the Protection of Industrial PropertyFootnote 7 (Paris Convention), which had not been covered in the previous Act of 1940.Footnote 8 As such, the Act of 2009 may be found to represent a milestone in trademark law, for it has substantially changed the pre-existing laws covering the protection of trademarks in Bangladesh.Footnote 9
Under the TRIPS Agreement, the developed country oriented uniform and strict protection standard has been made obligatory for developing and least-developed countries (LDCs), thereby creating a concern for the attainment of developmental needs by the latter.Footnote 10 Although the TRIPS negotiation leading to the trademark provisions was not as controversial as for other IPR sections,Footnote 11 it has also followed “the overall North-South dynamic, with the wealthier northern countries pushing obligation on their poorer southern colleagues”.Footnote 12 To resolve this tension, the TRIPS Agreement, however, includes some flexibilities and options that WTO members can exploit in their way of implementing the Agreement. With relation to the protection of trademarks, these flexibilities can be found in the several ambiguous and broadly defined elements of the TRIPS Agreement, as well as in the places where the Agreement is silent. Bangladesh, as a member of the LDCs, has an ample opportunity to exploit the flexibilities offered by the TRIPS Agreement in order to interpret and tailor its laws and administrative procedures covering the issues of trademarks.
It is against this backdrop that the present work is designed to explore the issue of how far the provisions of the Act of 2009 are compatible with standards and requirements as imposed by the TRIPS Agreement, as well as the Paris Convention, keeping in view its success in exploiting the TRIPS flexibilities from the perspective of policy implications. This compatibility assessment will be based on the analysis as well as identification of “TRIPS-plus” and “TRIPS-minus features” of the Trademarks Act of 2009. As such, this project will begin with examining the core provisions in the Trademarks Act with reference to the principles of the TRIPS Agreement and its harmonization with the rule of the Paris Convention.Footnote 13 In so doing, the discussion will, however, focus mainly on two aspects of trademark protection, namely, the acquisition and cancellation of trademark rights and the nature and scope of these rights.
I. THE PROTECTABILITY OF TRADEMARKS: ACQUISITION AND CANCELLATION OF TRADEMARKS RIGHTS IN BANGLADESH
The Trademarks Act of 2009 recognizes the registration-based system of protecting trademarks in Bangladesh.Footnote 14 Under this Act, registration of marks has been made a precondition to the acquisition of exclusive trademark rights within the territory of Bangladesh.Footnote 15 As such, this Act can be described roughly as a law of registered trademarks, albeit it recognizes the common-law “doctrine of passing off” that relates to the protection of unregistered marks.Footnote 16 In essence, this Act provides for a national system of registration of trademarks, prescribing the requirements and criteria of registrability in greater detail.Footnote 17 The present part of this study will largely encompass the discussion of how far the provisions of the Trademarks Act relating to such requirements and characteristics of registrable marks are compatible with the internationally agreed standards as envisioned by the TRIPS.
Under Article 15, the TRIPS Agreement contains the standards relating to the registrability of trademarks that members are required to accommodate in their domestic legislation. However, this Article of the TRIPS does not precisely provide for a list of signs that may be considered as registrable trademarks. By offering a broad definition of the expression “trademark”, it has rather set a universal criterion of determining the characteristics of registrable marks.Footnote 18 The definition given under Article 15(1) reads as follows:
Any sign, or any combination of signs, capable of distinguishing the goods or services of one undertaking from those of other undertakings, shall be capable of constituting a trademark. Such signs, in particular words including personal names, letters, numerals, figurative elements and combinations of colours as well as any combination of such signs, shall be eligible for registration as trademarks. Where signs are not inherently capable of distinguishing the relevant goods or services, Members may make registrability depend on distinctiveness acquired through use. Members may require, as a condition of registration, that signs be visually perceptible. Footnote 19
It appears that Article 15(1) of the TRIPS Agreement sets out the criteria of protectability of trademarks with reference to distinctiveness and visual perceptibility. The first and foremost obligation under this Article is that the granting of registration under domestic legislation must primarily be built upon the doctrine of distinctiveness.Footnote 20 In responding to this obligation, the members are, however, permitted to require the “use-based acquisition of distinctiveness” for determining the registrability in cases where the signs are not inherently capable of being distinctive.Footnote 21 To put it another way, the TRIPS Agreement has given members the leeway of locating “descriptive marks” to acquire the status of trademarks on their having achieved some level of distinctiveness in the course of their use.Footnote 22 Apart from this, the last sentence of Article 15(1) further bestows the members with an option of requiring visual perceptibility as a condition of registration of trademarks. From the combined reading of the components of Article 15(1), it can be found that the TRIPS has permitted members to narrow down the scope of registrable marks by requiring prior use or visual perceptibility in order for it to qualify for registration. Thus, if a WTO member exploited the leeway of recognizing the additional requirements permitted under this Article, the particular member may not therefore be obliged to register a sign that is distinctive, yet non-visual.Footnote 23
In Bangladesh, Section 6 of the Trademarks Act 2009 provides for the requisite of distinctiveness in details. According to Section 6, any distinctive mark shall be registered as a trademark subject to the limitations as provided in the Act. It also clarifies that a mark that does not fall within the description in Clauses (a) to (d) shall not be registered except upon the evidence of its distinctiveness. However, Section 6 does not directly provide for the requirement of visual perceptibility. Interestingly, the use of the words “visible sign” in the definition of the term “collective marks” in Section 2(25) may signify that the omission of these words in other definitions is deliberate, and calculated. Moreover, the definition of the term “marks” in Section 2(23) also signifies the fact that visual perceptibility is not a requirement for registration. Seen in this light, the Trademarks Act of 2009 can be found to comply with both the mandatory and directory parts of Article 15(1), which provides for the requirement of distinctiveness as well as visual perceptibility. Thus, it can be argued that the Act of 2009 has introduced a TRIPS-plus feature by expanding the protection to the “non-visually perceptible matters” as trademarks. In effect, this expansion of the scope of registrable trademarks to include non-visually perceptible subject matter can, however, be taken as an unwise exploitation of the flexibilities offered by the TRIPS.Footnote 24
Apart from this, the wider spectrum of distinctiveness has not been qualified with reference to the “requirement of prior use” as envisioned by the TRIPS. Unlike in some jurisdictions such as the US, “prior use” is thus not a precondition to registration in Bangladesh.Footnote 25 It is, however, important to note that the definition of “trademark” given in Section 2(8) of the Trademarks Act has maintained the prior use criterion only for determining the remedy for trademark infringements, and not as a requirement of trademark registration.Footnote 26 As such, the law of Bangladesh is found once again to exercise the leeway of locating the requirement of registrable marks as offered under Article 15(1) of the TRIPS.Footnote 27
A. Refusal of Trademark Registration in Bangladesh: Absolute and Relative Grounds
Under the pretext of the general principles of protectability, Article 15(1) of the TRIPS Agreement grants WTO members some flexibility or discretion to refuse the registration of trademarks.Footnote 28 In addition, the regime of trademark protection under the TRIPS Agreement provides for a number of situations in which the “[m]embers must refuse or invalidate the registration of trademarks”.Footnote 29 Apart from this, the TRIPS Agreement further recognizes in Article 15(2) that the members may refuse the registration of a trademark in their territory on grounds other than those addressed in Article 15(1), provided that they do not derogate from the provisions of the Paris Convention.Footnote 30 In this respect, the WTO’s Appellate Body, by citing the Panel in the dispute settlement case of the US—section 211 Omnibus Appropriations Act 1998 (DS176)—established that the “other grounds” for refusal of registration must be consistent with the provisions of the Paris Convention and the TRIPS Agreement. In establishing this, it has, however, observed that such options for members to set the ground for rejection are not limited to the grounds as expressly set forth in the TRIPS Agreement or the Paris Convention, such as those listed in Article 6quinquies and Article 7 of the Paris Convention.Footnote 31 According to this view, WTO members are thus permitted to go beyond the periphery of the TRIPS Agreement as well as the Paris Convention in locating the grounds that may justify the refusal of registration of a trademark.Footnote 32
In addition to granting this flexibility, the TRIPS Agreement, however, outlaws any derogation from the obligation set under the provisions of the Paris Convention. At this point, Article 6quinquies of the Paris Convention is found to oblige WTO members to recognize marks for registration in the “same form” (“as is” or tellequelle) as registered in the country of origin.Footnote 33 Under Article 15(2) of the TRIPS, a member must comply with the “as is” obligation as entailed by the Paris Convention. According to this obligation, except for the specific grounds provided as an exception under Article 6quinquies B, a tellequelle mark must not be refused registration.Footnote 34 To put it another way, when a tellequelle mark is submitted for registration in Bangladesh by invoking the priority provisions of the Paris Convention, the grounds of denial cannot go beyond the scope of those specified in Article 6quinquies B of the Paris Convention. Similarly, Article 7 of the Paris Convention provides that “[t]he nature of the goods to which a trademark is to be applied shall in no case form an obstacle to the registration of the mark”. This restriction is also re-enacted in Article 15(4) of TRIPS, and thus found to establish that a sign already registered in a Paris Union country cannot be denied registration on grounds that relate to the nature of the goods.Footnote 35 To put it another way, the registration of a trademark may not be refused merely because the mark identifies products that could be considered immoral, dangerous, or otherwise undesirable.Footnote 36
In Bangladesh, Sections 6–10 of the Trademarks Act 2009 list certain grounds on which an application to register a sign can be rejected. The grounds of refusal set under these sections can be found as an “absolute ground”, since they refer to an obstacle inherent in the trademark itself.Footnote 37 On the other hand, the Trademarks Act also contains the “relative grounds” for refusal of registration of a mark which arise from conflicts with an earlier right in relation to an earlier trademark. In this respect, it is important to note that the Trademarks Act of Bangladesh does not contain any special provision relating to the protection of tellequelle marks. However, the provisions of Sections 119 and 121 of the Act can be found to have implications for justifying the denial of the protection of tellequelle marks within the territory of Bangladesh.Footnote 38 In the recent case of Major General Amjad Khan Chowdhury (Retd.) v. Parle Agro Products Ltd & another (2012) Footnote 39 the court held that:
Those provisions will only be applicable if reciprocal arrangements exist in between two countries. The argument as to the use of the trade mark within the union countries shall have implication if reciprocal agreement with Bangladesh exists.
It appears from the above observation of the court that the Trademarks Act of Bangladesh permits the possibility of derogation from the obligation set under the provisions of the Paris Convention, particularly in relation to the protection of tellequelle marks. Given this, it is, however, necessary to assess each of the grounds for denial found in the provisions of the Trademarks Act with reference to the scope of Article 6quinquies (B)(i)–(iii) or any other provisions of the Paris Convention. If any ground runs foul of any provision of the Paris Convention, it would also be found, by virtue of the TRIPS Agreement Article 15(2) read with Article 2(2), to be contrary to the TRIPS Agreement.
In general, the absolute grounds of refusal are enumerated under clauses (a) to (e) of Section 6(1) of the present Act that create “five pigeonholes” into one of which a mark must fit in order to be registrable. With regard to this feature, Stephen Pericles Ladas observes (in relation to a similar provision of an earlier English Act) that this enumeration is resolved into one, that is, a mark must be distinctive.Footnote 40 To put it another way, the grounds of refusal set under Section 6(1) signify in effect that the marks devoid of any distinctive character shall not be registered in Bangladesh since these marks cannot distinguish the goods or services of one enterprise from that of others. The compatibility assessment of the Trademarks Act thus seems to suggest that the provisions of this section preventing the registration of non-distinctive marks, be it for ordinary marks or tellequelle marks, fall within the scope of Article 6quinquies (B)(i)–(iii) of the Paris Convention, and therefore the TRIPS Agreement. Given this, some absolute grounds of denying the registration of trademarks under the law of Bangladesh seem, however, to raise some compatibility issues. In what follows, the issues regarding the compatibility of these absolute grounds are thus discussed in greater detail.
The first ground of refusal that raises compatibility issues relates to the “ownership requirement” for the registration of trademarks in Bangladesh.Footnote 41 The ownership requirement is embodied, albeit ambiguously, under Clause (a) of Section 6(1) of the Trademarks Act, which provides that a trademark shall not be registered unless it contains “the name of a company, individual, or firm, represented in a special or particular manner”.Footnote 42 It seems that by inserting this ground the legislature intended to restrict the registration of trademarks to only those that represent any commercial linkage to an individual or enterprise engaging in business.Footnote 43 From the perspective of policy implications, this ground can at the outset be found to form a valid basis for denying the registration of a trademark in Bangladesh.Footnote 44 In terms of compatibility, the provision restricting the registration of marks on the above ground may, however, give rise to controversy: it animates the argument that this provision of the Trademarks Act implicates the denial of registration of tellequelle marks on the basis of ownership requirement, and thus fails to pass the test of compatibility.Footnote 45 To put it another way, ground (a) of Section 6(1) of the Trademarks Act constitutes a TRIPS-minus feature in relation to the requirement of registration of trademarks in the sense that this requirement does not form the grounds for denying registration under Article 6quinquies (B) of the Paris Convention. In this respect, it is, however, important to note that a perusal of the WTO’s Appellate Body decision is found to establish that the requirement of ownership does not relate to the form of the mark to be registered, and thus the lack of proper ownership even as regards tellequelle marks can form the valid basis of a ground for denying registration in the country concerned.Footnote 46 Seen in this light, it can thus be argued that the law of Bangladesh preventing the registration of marks that lack proper ownership does not contravene the Paris Convention, and therefore the TRIPS. Similarly, Clause (b) of Section 6(1), that concerns the signature of the applicant, can be found as TRIPS-compliant, because it is ordinarily regarded as prima facie distinctive.Footnote 47
Clause (c) of Section 6(1), that regards an invented word or words as a requirement of registration, constitutes another absolute ground of refusal. According to this ground, a mark to be registrable must be composed of a new and freshly coined word, being clearly and substantially different from any ordinary or common word or words.Footnote 48 The compatibility of this ground raises an important point: if this ground of refusal is found to speak of invention or novelty as requirement for registrable marks, as in the case of patent protection, the provision preventing registration under this ground will then clearly fall short of the standards as envisioned by the TRIPS.Footnote 49 The major argument in favour of this view can be found from the fact that a trademark is not an invention, and no new idea or device is necessarily involved in it. To put it another way, “a trademark need not be novel, in the sense that a novelty has in the case of inventions”.Footnote 50 In effect, the legislative intention in enumerating the above ground of refusal is, however, found to project a different feature for speaking in favour of an invented word(s). This point can be substantiated with reference to the fact that such a ground of refusal is not intended to include the requirement of invention or novelty as in the case of a patent. This ground merely constitutes one of the five pigeonholes into one of which the mark must fit in order to be distinctive. And, as such, it does not result in a contravention of the provisions of Paris Convention, as well as the TRIPS.
Some other absolute grounds of refusal are enumerated under Clause (d) of Section 6(1) of the Trademarks Act, that gives rise to most objections to registration. Under these grounds, the Act excludes descriptive and generic marks, and also geographical names and surnames, from the scheme of registration. The first part of Clause (d) contains a ground of refusal that prevents the registration of descriptive and generic marks resulting from the nature and characteristics of goods and services themselves.Footnote 51 This ground of refusal is founded upon the proposition that a mark that is descriptive is, in general, not distinctive.Footnote 52 The scope and application of this ground is thus determined with reference to the correlation between the degree of descriptiveness of a mark and its lack of distinctiveness. In various judgments of the European Court of Justice (ECJ), the wider application of this ground of refusal has, however, been confirmed. The rulings in Doublemint and Biomild suggest that the ECJ has slightly shifted the parameters of this test by setting a lower threshold for refusal to register a descriptive composite mark.Footnote 53 Apart from being linked to the general requirement of distinctiveness, this ground is also found to maintain two underlying policies associated with the principles of fair competition: first, it prevents applicants from monopolizing descriptive words to stop competitors from using those words to describe their products, and second, it prevents the public from being misled by the use of deceptively described marks.Footnote 54 The relevance of such a principle of fair policy in denying the registration of a descriptive mark has also been reflected in Doublemint, where the ECJ observed that such prohibition “pursues an aim which is in the public interest, namely that descriptive signs or indications relating to the characteristics of goods or services in respect of which registration is sought may be freely used by all”.Footnote 55 In relation to the law of Bangladesh, this issue of fair policy can thus be taken to substantiate the argument that the ground preventing the registration of marks that consist of signs essentially forming the natural character of a product does not contravene Article 6quinquies (B) of the Paris Convention, and therefore the TRIPS Agreement.Footnote 56
The second part of Clause (d) contains different possibilities for preventing the registration of signs which are associated with the name of person, region, sect, or tribe. The permitted ground for refusal or invalidation of a trademark covered under this clause thus implies that any sign which in its ordinary signification indicates a geographical name or a surname or the name of a person, sect, or tribe cannot be registered. The underlying purpose of this provision relates to the promotion of fair competition, because it is intended to preserve the possibility for traders to utilize geographical names and surnames freely to indicate the origin of their products or services, or the affiliation of an individual to the provision of goods or services. Seen in this light, it can be argued that the provision precluding the registration of marks under this ground complies with the requirements as contemplated by the Paris Convention, as well as the TRIPS Agreement.
With regard to geographical names, the test of compatibility seems, however, crucial in the sense that geographical names do not always imply the origin of the product concerned: they may be used as trademarks as indicating trade origin at times. In practice, this fact informs the principle that a trademark should not always be refused registration, merely because it amounts to a geographical name. In this respect, the joint case of Windsurfing ChiemseeProduktions—und Vertriebs GmbH (WSC) v. Boots—und Segelzubehör Walter Huber is worth mentioning, where the ECJ observed that a geographical name may be registered as a trade mark
[if] following the use which has been made of it, it has come to identify the product in respect of which registration is applied for as originating from a particular undertaking and thus to distinguish that product from goods of other undertakings. Where that is the case, the geographical designation has gained a new significance and its connotation, no longer purely descriptive, justifies its registration as a trade mark.Footnote 57
It thus appears that the restriction on the registration of geographical names as trademarks should not be taken as an absolute prohibition.Footnote 58 Given this, if ground (d) of Section 6(1) is interpreted as an absolute restriction on the registration of geographical names, this would surely fall short of the accepted norms pertaining to geographical names and distinctiveness in other jurisdictions. In such a case, the provision of the Trademarks Act would be found to run contrary to Bangladesh’s obligation under the provisions of the Paris Convention, which permits the ground for denying registration of a geographical name only when it denotes the place of origin of that type of goods.Footnote 59
The similar argument can also be raised in relation to prohibition on the registration of surnames as a trademark. The major argument is this respect is that surnames may at times form distinctive trademarks capable of performing the function of trade origin.Footnote 60 As such, an absolute denial of a mark from being registered on the ground that it forms a surname cannot be found to withstand the test of compatibility.Footnote 61 To put it another way, if registration of a surname as a trademark is sought in Bangladesh by invoking the priority provisions of Article 6quinquies of the Paris Convention, the “blanket prohibition”Footnote 62 as found in Section 6(1)(d) in the Trademarks Act may be found to contravene the provisions of the Paris Convention, and hence the TRIPS.
In addition to the grounds set out under Section 6(1), some other absolute grounds of refusal are enumerated under Section 8 of the Trademark Act. In general, this section prohibits the registration of certain marks which comprise or consist of any scandalous or obscene matter; or the use of which would be contrary to any law for the time being in force; or the use of which would be likely to deceive or cause confusion;Footnote 63 or which contains any matter likely to hurt the religious susceptibilities of any class of the citizens of Bangladesh. Given that the grounds set under this section could be easily couched within the third ground of denial in Article 6quinquies (B), it could be said that the provision containing these grounds is compatible with the Paris Convention, and therefore the TRIPS Agreement.Footnote 64 In addition, Clause (e) of this section prohibits the registration of specially protected emblems and the like, which includes armorial bearings, flags, the name and other emblems of the state or an international organization, and hallmark and other official signs, unless authorised by the competent authority. It appears that this provision is enacted clearly in line with Article 6ter of the Paris Convention, and therefore discharges Bangladesh’s obligation pursuant to the TRIPS Agreement.Footnote 65
In respect of the relative grounds of refusal, the Trademarks Act of Bangladesh is also found to pass the test of compatibility. As mentioned earlier, apart from the aforesaid absolute grounds for denying trademark registration, the Trademarks Act of Bangladesh accommodates accepted practice to deny registration when an application for registration conflicts with existing rights of third parties as envisioned by the TRIPS Agreement. To this effect, Section 10 of the Act thus prevents the registration of a mark which is identical with or deceptively similar to a trademark which is already registered in the name of a different proprietor in respect of the same goods or description of goods or in respect of the same services or description of services, as the case may be. The rationale of preventing the registration of identical or deceptively similar marks has been addressed in the case of Nabisco Biscuit and Bread Factory Ltd. v. Baby Food Products Ltd and Another (2006), where the court held that a deceptively similar trademark cannot get any protection, as consumers may get confused with that mark against a duly registered mark.Footnote 66 According to this ground, the issue of perception of identity of the sign and trademark is thus crucial in prohibiting the registration of a conflicting mark, the criterion of which must be strictly interpreted.Footnote 67 In order to enforce this prohibition, the Act is thus found to comply with the requirement of the TRIPS Agreement that obliges parties to provide for a mechanism to oppose a trademark registration on the basis of the assessment of perception of identity.Footnote 68 In the case of Bangladesh, the mechanism to oppose the registration is specified in Section 18 of the Trademarks Act, which clearly enables a registered trademark owner to prevent a conflicting mark from being entered in the trademarks register.Footnote 69 As such, it appears that the law of Bangladesh has exploited the optional benefits that Article 15(5) of the TRIPS Agreement contemplates in favour of trademark owners.Footnote 70
Similarly, Section 51 of the Trademarks Act contains a provision for the annulment or cancellation of registration, and thus comes to comply with the requirements as envisioned by the Paris Convention, as well as the TRIPS Agreement.Footnote 71 This provision of cancellation can, however, be found to differ from the provision relating to the opposition of registration on an important point: unlike the system of opposition, where any person is entitled to oppose the registration of a mark, only a person “aggrieved” is entitled to apply to the court to have a registered mark cancelled. In other words, the scope of the provision relating to cancellation is limited compared to the scope of opposition. In this respect, it is, however, important to note that this limitation cannot be said to detract from the requirement envisioned by Article 15(5) of the TRIPS Agreement that compels WTO members to provide a “reasonable opportunity” for petitions to cancel the registration of conflicting marks. As such, the provisions in the Trademarks Act 2009 pertaining to the cancellation of a registered trademark are found to conform to the standards as envisaged by the Paris Convention, as well as the TRIPS Agreement.Footnote 72
II. NATURE AND SCOPE OF TRADEMARK RIGHTS IN BANGLADESH
Typically, the trademarks law is designed to provide some “exclusive rights” that are capable of being enjoyed by the holder of the trademark. However, contemporary trademark law is found to encounter a common criticism regarding the degree of such right granted to the holder of the mark. Very often, it is argued that the legislatures are tending to extend the rights of the trademark owner too far by limiting the situations in which the trademark’s rights are capable of being invalidated or revoked, and by too narrowly formulating the grounds on which the defendant can escape the liability of infringing the trademark.Footnote 73 More importantly, this argument goes further to claim that the “positive law affords trade marks owners broader and stronger rights than can be justified by the principle of policy”.Footnote 74 To overcome this criticism, commentators attempt to explain the “dynamics of trade-IPRs nexus” that cause the metamorphosis of trademarks into strong, unfettered property rights. According to them, the reality of such an expansion of trademark rights has therefore been rightly addressed by the TRIPS Agreement. In this part of the paper, the nature and extent of trademark rights in Bangladesh will be assessed with reference to this “transformed regimes of trademarks rights”. As such, it will focus on the issue of whether the rights granted under the law of Bangladesh correspond to the nature and extent of trademark rights as envisioned by the TRIPS Agreement.
Under Article 16, the TRIPS Agreement speaks of the minimum standards of rights that must be made available by members to the owners of the trademarks.Footnote 75 This Article is a good illustration of what the TRIPS Agreement has added to the existing framework of intellectual property rights.Footnote 76 In fact, this Article provides for an “enhanced applicability” of the trademark’s right, and implies a significant departure from the previous regime.Footnote 77 This broader measure undertaken by the TRIPS requires two important obligations to be fulfilled. First, it obliges members to ensure that trademark owners are entitled to prevent third parties not being owners of the mark, or a person authorized thereof, from using an identical or similar mark in relation to identical or similar goods in circumstances that leads to consumer confusion. Second, and most importantly, it requires that in cases where an identical mark is used in relation to identical goods or services, confusion shall be presumed.Footnote 78 In essence, this obligation relates to the requirement of adopting a lesser degree of the burden of proof of the infringement of a trademark under the domestic legislation.
It appears that the internationally agreed obligations as set out in Article 16 of the TRIPS Agreement envisage the recognition of negative rights: that is, the trademark owner’s right to prevent third parties from using an identical or similar mark. In Bangladesh, Section 25 of the Trademarks Act provides for the recognition of such rights, and thus discharges its obligation pursuant to Article 16(1) of the TRIPS Agreement. This feature of compliance can be found with reference to the wording of Section 25(2), which provides that “[n]o person other than the registered owner of a trademark in relation to any goods or services, as the case may be, shall use that trademark without the consent of the registered owner”. In addition to granting the right to prevent the confusing use of a similar mark by a third party,Footnote 79 this section also grants express rights to use the mark by the owner of the trademark.Footnote 80 This fact may often give rise to the proposition that the law of Bangladesh has set the TRIPS-plus feature in discharging its obligation under Article 16(1), which does not directly require members to recognize such a right to use the mark by the owner.Footnote 81 In this respect, it is important to note that the use of the words “exclusive rights” in the text of Article 16(3) must be understood to signify more than the fact that it is only a right to “exclude” others.Footnote 82 It rather indicates that this right belongs to the owner of the trademark alone, who exercises this right by using the mark in the course of trade. The right to use the mark is thus incidental to the recognition of the right to prevent its use. Seen in this light, it can therefore be argued that the provision recognizing the right to use the mark does not constitute a TRIP-plus feature for Bangladesh.
Apart from this, the provision of the Trademarks Act relating to protection from unauthorized use is based on the doctrine of likelihood of confusion that relates to the requirement of a lesser burden of proof in proving the infringement of a trademark.Footnote 83 As such, it can be found that the second obligation as envisioned under Article 16(1) of the TRIPS that requires presumption in favour of “likelihood of confusion” is also met by Bangladesh. In so doing, Section 26(2) of the Act has, however, contemplated a broader contour of “likelihood of confusion” by providing that the existence of likelihood of confusion shall include “the likelihood of association”. It is thus arguable that if such inclusion results in reducing the degree of burden of proof to demonstrate infringement than that which is understood by the likelihood of confusion, then the provision of the Trademarks Act of Bangladesh would clearly be found to provide a TRIPS-plus feature in addressing the issue of infringement.Footnote 84 In this respect, it is, however, important to consider the observation of the ECJ in Puma v. Sabel,Footnote 85 in clarifying the implication of the addition which includes likelihood of association under EU Trade Mark law, that:
The criterion of “likelihood of confusion which includes the likelihood of association with the earlier mark” … is to be interpreted as meaning that the mere association which the public might make between two trade marks as a result of their analogous semantic content is not in itself a sufficient ground for concluding that there is a likelihood of confusion within the meaning of that provision.Footnote 86
According to this observation of the ECJ, the likelihood of confusion must therefore be appreciated globally, taking into account all factors relevant to the circumstances of the case. Such global appreciation of the visual, aural, or conceptual similarity of the marks in question must be based on the overall impression given by the marks, bearing in mind, in particular, their distinctive and dominant components.Footnote 87 It appears that this principle of determining the likelihood of confusion has been widely followed in the various decisions given by the court of Bangladesh. In the case of Singer Company v. Amjad Ali, the Deputy Registrar of TrademarksFootnote 88 denied the possibility of the likelihood of confusion between the words Sagar and Singer, and thus held that these two words were dissimilar and would create no confusion if registered as a trademark. On the other hand, in the case of Bombay Sweets and Company Limited v. Liberty Food Company (2008),Footnote 89 the court presumed the likelihood of confusion between two trade marks by taking into account the global appreciation of the visual, aural, or conceptual similarity of the marks in question. In this case, the court held that “if the name of the case companies manufacturing potato chips i.e. ‘Liberty’ and ‘Bombay’ are read in isolation, there would indeed be two different marks. But in the present case the names cannot be dissected from the overall design and get up.”Footnote 90 At this point, it thus appears that the law and practice of Bangladesh relating to the recognition and protection of the rights of the trademark holder are not at loggerheads with the obligations entailed by the TRIPS. In terms of the nature and extent of such rights, the trademarks regime of Bangladesh has rather accommodated a slightly higher standard than required or envisioned by the TRIPS.
III. THE PROTECTION OF WELL-KNOWN MARKS
The law relating to well-known marks is based on a concept under which a trademark is protected within a nation if it is well known and recognized even though the mark is not actually used or registered in that nation.Footnote 91 Article 6bis of the Paris Convention is the primary source of the protection of well-known marks, which has been further endorsed by the TRIPS Agreement, with the mandate that the obligation under Article 6bis shall apply to the TRIPS Agreement signatories.Footnote 92 In respect of well-known marks, Article 16 of the TRIPS Agreement read with Article 6bis of the Paris Convention offers a three-fold obligation for the members: first, it obliges members to provide a mechanism to prevent the registration of conflicting marks, and to cancel a conflicting registered mark; second, it requires them to prevent the use of marks that conflict with well-known marks; and finally, it obliges members to grant protection against damage that may be caused to the interest of the well-known mark’s owners. The first and second obligations are limited to the protection of well-known marks in relation to identical or similar goods or services, and the third obligation as entailed by Article 16(3) of the TRIPS Agreement is extended to situations that involve “cross-class protection”, that is, protection from the use of conflicting marks even in relation to non-identical or dissimilar goods.Footnote 93 In this respect, it is, however, important to note that the cross-class protection of well-known marks under Article 16(3) depends on registration as envisioned by the TRIPS Agreement.Footnote 94
Turning to the law of Bangladesh, it can be found that Sections 10(4) and 10(5), and also Section 26(7) of the Trademarks Act 2009, refer to well-known marks. The provisions of Section 10 relate to the grounds for refusing the registration of trademarks in relation to the well-known marks,Footnote 95 while Section 26(7) concerns the infringement of such well-known marks as registered in Bangladesh.Footnote 96 As regards the protection of well-known marks, the provision of Section 10(4), which permits the denial of registration of a mark on the ground of being “identical with or confusingly similar to” both the registered and unregistered well-known marks, fulfils Bangladesh’s obligation pursuant to Articles 15(5) and 16(2) of the TRIPS Agreement. Similarly, the provision of Section 10(5) can also be found as TRIPS-compliant because of the fact that it provides cross-class protection for the interests of the holder of a registered well-known mark in relation to non-identical or dissimilar goods or services.Footnote 97
Apart from this, the law relating to the infringement of trademarks in Bangladesh as embodied in Section 26(7) of the Trademarks Act can also be found to pass the test of TRIPS compatibility. At the outset, the content of this section may, however, give rise to controversy: it may be found that the application of Section 26(7) to only registered trademarks contravenes Article 16(3) of the TRIPS Agreement read with Article 6bis of the Paris Convention. In this respect, it may be argued that, as the provision of Section 26(7) applies only to registered trademarks, the owner of a well-known mark cannot avail himself of the benefit of this section unless the well-known mark is registered in Bangladesh. By requiring marks to be registered in order to get the protection of this section, the law of Bangladesh thus seems to fall short of the obligation pursuant to Article 16(3) of the TRIPS Agreement.
The argument that the precondition of registration under Section 26(7) precludes the provision of the Act from being TRIPS-compliant does not, however, hold. The wording of Article 16(3) suggests that such argument is based on a misreading of the exact obligations under the TRIPS Agreement. It must be noted that Article 16(3) of the TRIPS Agreement makes reference to the “owner of the registered trademark”.Footnote 98 This reference is clear enough to imply that the TRIPS Agreement contemplates the benefit of Article 16(3) to be conferred on the owner of a well-known mark only when such a mark is registered in the country concerned. Carlos Correa stands in favour of this view and argues equally that the well-known mark concerned must be registered to be entitled to protection under Article 16(3).Footnote 99 According to him, the requirement of registration cannot be treated as a drafting mistake,Footnote 100 though it signifies a departure from Article 16(2) of the TRIPS Agreement as well as Article 6bis of the Paris Convention, both of which do not require well-known marks to be registered.Footnote 101 For Bangladesh, it is thus apparent that the provision in Section 27(b) of the Trademarks Act that relates to the protection of the interests of well-known mark owners against the likelihood of damage discharges Bangladesh’s obligation as entailed by the TRIPS Agreement.Footnote 102
IV. CONCLUSION
In the foregoing discussion, the TRIPS compatibility of certain aspects of the Trademarks Act of 2009 has been assessed in great detail with a focus in particular on the acquisition and denial of trademark rights in Bangladesh. In general, it has also focused on the nature and scope of such rights under the existing regime of protecting trademarks in Bangladesh. The discussion has been made with reference to the relevant provisions of the Paris Convention and the TRIPS Agreement. In so doing, it has identified that Article 6 of the Paris Convention read with Article 16(2) of the TRIPS Agreement permits countries to refuse trademark protection on almost any ground. However, it is also found that the marks that are validly registered in a Paris Union country, when seeking registration under the priority provisions of the Paris Convention, cannot be denied registration except under a ground stipulated in Article 6quinquies (B) of the Paris Convention.Footnote 103
In Bangladesh, the regime of trademark protection is based upon the requirement of distinctiveness as dictated by the TRIPS. The Trademarks Act of 2009 does not, however, provide for the requirement of visual perceptibility. As such, the law of Bangladesh has been found to constitute a TRIPS-plus feature that includes “non-visually perceptible subject matter” as registrable under the regime of trademarks. In the context of Bangladesh, this expansion of the scope of registrable trademarks to include non-visually perceptible subject matter has, however, been projected as an unwise exploitation of the flexibility offered by the TRIPS Agreement.
The analysis of the absolute grounds of refusing the registration of trademarks under Sections 6 of the Trademarks Act has revealed that such grounds are set to create “five pigeonholes” into one of which a mark must fit in order to be distinctive. At the outset, the compatibility assessment of the present Act is thus found to suggest that the provisions preventing the registration of non-distinctive marks, be it for ordinary or tellequelle marks, fall within the scope of the Paris Convention, as well as the TRIPS Agreement. In this respect, it is, however, important to note that Clause (d) of Section 6 should not be taken to put an absolute restriction on the registration of geographical names or surnames as a trademark. Because, in such a case, the practice of rejecting the registration of geographical names or surnames that form trademarks capable of performing the function of trade origin may be found to stand contrary to the said instruments, especially the provisions pertaining to the protection of tellequelle marks. Apart from this, the provision of Section 8 which contains some other absolute ground of refusal is enacted clearly in line with Article 6ter of the Paris Convention, and therefore found to discharge Bangladesh’s obligation pursuant to the TRIPS. In respect of the relative grounds of refusal, the Trademarks Act of Bangladesh is also found to pass the test of compatibility.
An investigation turned to the nature and scope of trademark rights in Bangladesh shows that the trademarks regime has accommodated a slightly higher standard than required or envisioned by the TRIPS Agreement. In providing protection from unauthorized use, Section 26(2) of the Act has contemplated a broader contour of “likelihood of confusion” that leads the provision of the Trademarks Act of Bangladesh to provide a TRIPS-plus feature in addressing the issue of infringement. As regards the protection of well-known marks, the provision of Section 10(4) which permits the denial of registration of a mark on the ground of being “identical with or confusingly similar to” both the registered and unregistered well-known marks discharges Bangladesh’s obligation pursuant to Articles 15(5) and 16(2) of the TRIPS Agreement. Similarly, the provision of Section 10(5) can also be found as TRIPS-compliant because of the fact that it provides cross-class protection for the interests of the holder of a registered well-known mark in relation to non-identical or dissimilar goods or services.
To conclude, it can accordingly be argued that the present regime of trademark protection under the Trademarks Act of Bangladesh is not at loggerheads with the TRIPS Agreement.Footnote 104 By accommodating some TRIPS-plus features, the Act is rather found to offer a slightly stronger regime of protecting trademarks in Bangladesh than envisioned by the TRIPS Agreement.Footnote 105 From the perspective of policy implications, this fact has thus led to the concern that the trademarks law of Bangladesh has failed to accommodate the bursting benefits of TRIPS-flexibilities that it could otherwise exploit as a member of the LDCs. Given this, it is thus understandable that some provisions of the Trademarks Act of Bangladesh should be revised yet again in order to bring them into conformity with the developmental and trade-promotional prospects of Bangladesh.Footnote 106 In so doing, the scheme of reform should, however, be considered in the light of advancements in technology and changes in consumer perception and behaviour in Bangladesh and beyond.
