Steve Reich's career has included a number of encounters with overt technology. In the late 1960s he was preoccupied with the creation of the Phase Shifting Pulse Gate, a device designed by Reich, Larry Owens and David Flooke at Bell Labs as “both an instrument in itself, and also [as] a sort of phase variable metronome enabling several performers to play together.”Footnote 1 After more than a year of experimenting, Reich relegated the electronic instrument to the back of his closet, deciding that the device was “musically uninteresting in performance.”Footnote 2 Nonetheless, one of Reich's most omnipresent compositions, Clapping Music (1972), also sprang from his engagement with technology. Inspired by a flamenco performance in Brussels and fed up with hauling thousands of pounds of electronic equipment around Europe to perform with his fledgling ensemble, Reich envisioned a work requiring only the performer's hands acting as the instrument.Footnote 3 Now, Clapping Music, a low-tech work if ever there was one, has been reimagined as an iPhone app for the twenty-first century.
In 2015 the London Sinfonietta partnered with Queen Mary University of London and developer Amphio to create the app Steve Reich's Clapping Music. Footnote 4 The London Sinfonietta imagined the app as a way of engaging users “to learn about contemporary music,” while Queen Mary University of London's Music Cognition Lab saw the potential of the app to contribute to a series of studies using minimalist music to investigate auditory perception and cognition. An instructor of music history or musicology might consider it as part of their curriculum as well. Rather than simply listening to a recording of Clapping Music, students could be engaged in some of the intricacies of the rhythmically rich work. However, there are costs to the integrity of the composition in using this app as an introduction to Reich's music.
The Clapping Music app is replete with visual and auditory cues that would not be unfamiliar to a twenty-first century video gamer. Entering the app (available for free on the Apple App Store) the user is confronted with four options: “About the Music,” “About the App,” “Research Project,” and “Tap to Play.” “About the App” explains that the app is designed to improve the user's rhythm by measuring the accuracy of the user's tapping through each variation of the musical work. In “About the Music” users are provided with information on Clapping Music and how it marks the shift from phasing to simple canonic entries of a musical pattern in Reich's oeuvre. The London Sinfonietta also includes a section on Reich's biography and Electric Counterpoint (1987). Using examples drawn from Electric Counterpoint, Mats Bergström highlights musical elements that Reich is known for exploiting. These include pulsing, ostinato, additive note patterns, resultant patterns, canons, and counterpoint. While techniques such as additive note patterns (rhythmic construction by another name) and pulsing are not present in Clapping Music, their inclusion in the Clapping Music app's “About the Music” provides users with a broader understanding of Reich's more recent musical output.
“Tap to Play,” the last and most centrally located option on the opening screen, prompts the user to enter a nickname that allows multiple players on the same device to keep track of their “game” stats. Moving through the start-up screens, the user is further asked to select a setting against which they will tap the shifting rhythmic positions of player 2 (from the notated score), while the app plays the unmoving rhythm of player 1.Footnote 5 The setting choices range from “Easy,” which guides the user with a slow underlying metronome pulse, through to “Hard,” which takes the work at speed without a metronome guide. The option also features a “Practice Mode.” Offering the most versatility in terms of settings, “Practice Mode” allows the user to focus their practice on particular patterns (multiple patterns can only be selected if they are adjacent to one another). Through the settings menu in “Practice Mode,” the volumes of the static pattern, the guide sound, and the player's own clap can be adjusted. Additionally, the user can set the number of repetitions before transition between one and twelve, adjust the volume of the metronome, and set the tempo between 75 and 180. All of these settings are designed to allow the user to explore one of Reich's seminal works with ease.
One of Reich's most serious complaints about the Phase Shifting Pulse Gate was the rhythmic perfection it achieved.Footnote 6 This perfection is something that is found again in the Clapping Music app's erasure of player 1’s micro-variations. Likewise, the tension of performers working simultaneously together and independently simply does not exist for the app user tapping away on their phone. Russell Hartenberger, the original player 2, describes some of those tensions in a typical performance with Reich as “we never play a set number of repeats and Steve leaves it up to me to determine when to move to the next bar. He likes to be aware of the changes when they occur, so I nod to him on the beginning of the last repetition of a bar before moving to the next.”Footnote 7 In the scenario related by Hartenberger, player 2 is making decisions and relating them to player 1. The communication occurring between the players is inherent to the music's essence and cannot occur in the rigid video game world of the app. The app is, as Reich notes in his introduction to it, a form of preparation for performing Clapping Music, but not a substitute for a live performance.Footnote 8
Taking a different tack to exploring Reich's music through a free mobile app is the Third Coast Percussion: The Music of Steve Reich app, currently available for iOS with an Android version forthcoming.Footnote 9 Third Coast Percussion, following on from previous apps, created the Reich app as a way “to give audiences a new way to engage with this amazing music.”Footnote 10 Unlike the Clapping Music app, which requires the user to tap the pattern in the bottom quadrant of the screen, the Third Coast Percussion app is based on sonic experiences.
The investigation of Reich's music curated by Third Coast Percussion has three sections: “Phasing,” “Additive,” and “Canons.” Each allows the user to explore some of the compositional parameters for which Reich is best known. A link to additional information can be accessed through the top right corner's “i,” which explains where the technique exists in Reich's oeuvre and then dictates how to interact with the highly geometric and textually sparse main screen. In the “Phasing” screen the user can record their own musical pattern, gradually shifting the speed of a copy of it against the original. “Additive” considers the concept of rhythmic construction, beginning with Clapping Music’s basic pattern and its seventh iteration. The user can select the order in which the second pattern enters and exists against the basic one. This allows the compositional technique of rhythmic construction to be tested through different entry points and speeds of unveiling. The user in “Additive” is not limited to the Clapping Music pattern and can manipulate the twelve eighth-note rhythms by double tapping along it. In “Canons,” the user can drag a copy of the melodic pattern into various canonic points, and shift the notes of the melodic pattern by pausing the playback and pulling a pitch up or down along the screen. In all parts of the Third Coast Percussion app, the user can manipulate the tempo and customize the sounds used in order to produce audio recordings to share via Instagram or email, and/or to save to their phone.
The Third Coast Percussion app deals with compositional techniques rather than specific musical works, but it could be used in a musicology or music history class in a similar manner to the Clapping Music app. It must however be pointed out that, while both apps simulate the mechanics of Reich's musical style, they do not replace the sensation of performing the music, a task that could be easily accomplished without either app by encouraging a class to attempt (either individually or as a group) a performance of a work such as Clapping Music. The apps do, however, allow individuals to independently discover some of Reich's musical techniques in a hands-on fashion and might reach students whose primary focus sometimes seems to be their phones.
