Elizabeth Digeser has already put students of Late Antiquity in her debt with a series of studies in the interaction between Christians and Hellenes in the first centuries a.d., not least her book The Making of a Christian Empire (1999), and her contributory historical chapters to The Cambridge History of Philosophy in Late Antiquity (2010). Here she returns to these themes with a penetrating study of the forces operating behind the so-called ‘Great Persecution’ initiated by Diocletian and his junior eastern colleague Galerius in February 303. The book consists of an introduction, five chapters, and a conclusion. In the introduction, D. sets out the main theme of the book, which is the genesis of the ‘Great Persecution’ of the Christians in a.d. 303, and the rôle played in that by the Platonist philosopher Porphyry in particular, and the school of the rather mysterious Alexandrian guru Ammonius Saccas — what she sees as ‘the Ammonian community’ — on the broader front.
The first chapter is devoted to Ammonius himself, and all that can be gleaned about him from Porphyry on the one hand and Eusebius on the other. We must always bear in mind that we know virtually nothing about Ammonius or what he taught, though from observation of his pupil Plotinus, we can form some impression of how he taught. D. presents all the evidence very fully, even entertaining (40–1) the interesting suggestion of Cardinal Jean Daniélou that his name may be a sort of corruption or adaptation (perhaps by the man himself) of Muni Sakya, a variant of Sakyamuni, a favourite epithet of the Buddha! The only fault I would find with her account of him is what seems to me a too ready acceptance (43–4) of Eusebius’ attribution to him of various Christian works, which seem far more likely to belong to some other Ammonius. This, however, serves to buttress her view of the ‘Ammonian community’ as forming something of a bridge between Christian and Hellenic cultures.
This idea is developed further in the next chapter, ‘Origen as a Student of Ammonius’, where she rashly proposes to revive the notion that ‘Origen the Christian’ and ‘Origen the Platonist’, fellow-student of Plotinus in the School of Ammonius, are one and the same person — and indeed dismisses contemptuously those who presume that they are distinct! But this is surely a non-starter: the chronology will not work, and the reports of Porphyry (who knew both of them) that the Platonist composed nothing but a treatise on daemons and another entitled ‘That the King is the only Creator’ (V.Plot. 3), and that when Origen once turned up in Plotinus’ seminar, Plotinus was filled with confusion and declined to continue, saying that his enthusiasm evaporated when he was faced with lecturing to those who knew it all already (ibid., 14). This was already in the middle 260s, when Porphyry was with him, and the Christian Origen was dead.
Origen the Christian did, of course, sit in on the lectures of Ammonius, at a period considerably earlier than did Plotinus or the other Origen, so D. can reasonably claim him as a figure who bridges the divide between the cultures. It is also quite possible that Porphyry, in his teens, studied with him briefly in Caesarea in the 250s, which would help to explain his extensive knowledge of both Old and New Testament texts and of the Christian tradition. It is certainly the case that Porphyry, in his later attacks on the Christians, denounces the Hellenic-style allegorizing of biblical texts practised by Origen, on the ground that such texts are not suitable subjects for allegorical treatment, and he seems to have accused him, erroneously, of having abandoned Hellenism for Christianity.
In ch. 3 D. turns to ‘Plotinus, Porphyry and Philosophy in the Public Realm’. Here she gives a good account of the careers and views of both philosophers, but there creeps in here, it seems to me, an illegitimate assumption that is rather important for her overall theme, to wit, that each of these philosophers developed a concern for the salvation of the great majority of ordinary people. Plotinus’ project for the founding of Platonopolis, for a start, has nothing to do with outreach to the great unwashed; it was designed to be a rather exclusive Platonist monastic establishment. Porphyry was indeed, at a later period, in connection with Diocletian's effort at a ‘final solution’ to the Christian problem, more concerned with a plurality of ‘ways of salvation’; but for a Platonist, there is really no urgency about the salvation of the human race in general, in the way that there is for a committed Christian, because there is not much from which the human race in general needs to be saved. Even for Iamblichus, whose controversy with his teacher Porphyry is the subject of the next chapter, universal salvation is not a concern, although his advocacy of theurgic ritual as a necessary means of attracting divine attention could appeal to a rather wider audience. However, the procedures followed by the accomplished theurgist are highly esoteric, and not for the general public. Overall, in a battle for the hearts and minds of the many, Platonism was simply not in contention.
Ch. 5, ‘Schism in the Ammonian Community’, concerning the responses to Porphyry composed by Methodius of Olympus, I found most interesting, Methodius being a figure who had hitherto eluded my attention. D. gives a good account of his chief works, a Symposium (a dialogue conducted by a group of ladies about virginity), the De Cibis (concerning allegorical explanations of Jewish dietary laws), and the Aglaophon, which is both a response to Porphyry's attacks on the doctrine of the resurrection of the body, and a critique of Origen's position on the same subject. Methodius would be a figure particularly repugnant to Porphyry, as representing someone who, though well schooled in Hellenic culture, nonetheless opts for Christian irrationality. The concluding chapter, ‘The Ammonian Community and the Great Persecution’, covers both what we can learn about the range and contents of Porphyry's work or works ‘Against the Christians’, and the reactions of such figures as Lactantius, Eusebius and Arnobius to Porphyry's rôle in the Great Persecution.
Overall, much in this book is enlightening and persuasive, but there are, as I say, a few aspects that I find problematic. D. hails Ammonius Saccas as promulgating a ‘philosophy without conflicts’, by which she seems to mean a philosophical system that seeks to reconcile sectarian positions, as between Aristotelians and Platonists, and also apparent contradictions within sacred texts, by the employment of allegorical (or what she prefers to call ‘figural’) exegesis. This combines two rather different tendencies, though Ammonius does seem to have promoted them both. However, the idea of an ‘Ammonian community’ of philosophers and exegetes of both Hellenic and Christian persuasions, the conflicts between whom generate first the Diocletianic persecution and then the triumph of Christianity under Constantine, seems to me to go rather beyond the evidence. When all is said and done, we really do not know very much about Ammonius. I only wish we knew more.
