Olle Törnquist's Assessing Dynamics of Democratisation and Joakim Öjendal and Mona Lilja's Beyond Democracy in Cambodia present alternatives to the liberal approach to understanding democracy and transition. The two books under review focus on Indonesia and Cambodia, both of which held critical elections in the last year that presented key turning points toward democracy despite a turbulent year for Southeast Asian politics beyond these two cases. Törnquist proposes an alternative measurement of democracy based on political egalitarianism to understand Indonesia's transformation from the New Order. Öjendal and Lilja's edited volume breaks down the process of building a democracy during Cambodia's reconstruction period. While the approaches of the two volumes diverge, both suggest that we need to revisit the ways in which democracy and transitions are understood in Southeast Asia.
Törnquist sets out to survey Indonesian democracy from below to assess what he calls “substantive democracy” based on four key dimensions: the institutional means, key actors’ relationships to institutions, key actors' capacity, and the dynamics of democratic politics. The frame of substantive democracy thus allows scholars to assess a system characterized by “popular control of public affairs on the basis of political equality” (p. 4). He claims that this approach is a way to overcome the liberal, elite, and institutional biases of more mainstream measures of democracy like Polity or Freedom House scores that are used in both academic and NGO communities. In doing so, he discusses thirteen sets of institutions that underpin democracy, centering on citizenship, the rule of law, equal justice, human rights, citizen participation, and representation. While many of these institutions are similar to those accounted for in other measures, his emphasis on political equality, decentralization, issue-based representation, and the inclusion of international law in the rule of law differentiates his approach from its alternatives. In the Indonesian context, political equality requires a break with the dominant networks of power left over from the Suharto period. For Törnquist's picture of democracy, that would necessitate that political networks be fully rebuilt. Instead, Törnquist finds that the development of democracy in Indonesia has created a disconnect between political power and mass politics. Quite simply, he claims that there is a lack of popular representation. Paradoxically, he finds that there is agreement that democracy and its accompanying sets of institutions are the “only game in town” (p. 53); but in practice ordinary people are disenfranchised by institutions that favor the existing political elite and expanding intra-elite networks. While his findings suggest some changes in how the political elite function since the fall of the New Order, they do not show a significant break with the past.
Beyond Indonesian democracy, Törnquist's concern in this volume is to move beyond the institutional focus on democracy assessments towards substantive and dynamic processes of democratization. Despite his emphasis on the experiences and expectations of ordinary citizens, the way in which he approaches his survey still maintains the national level and institutional biases against which he himself argues. His survey findings fit with those of the indices upon which he is seeking to improve. The extent of ordinary citizen involvement in the 2014 elections (e.g., crowdsourcing election monitoring) shows that Törnquist's claim of a fundamental lack of popular representation may be overstated.
Öjendal and Lilja's edited volume also breaks down the components of democratization. Instead of rethinking standard measures of democracy, they seek to understand the elements of building a democratic state in Cambodia. Like Törnquist, they want to move beyond a static image of democracy toward an understanding of the processes and behaviors that make up the transition. They emphasize the role of legitimacy in the state (re)building process as the key determinant of success. They too find that any discussion of power is missing from previous assessments of intervention-led democratization. Ultimately, the editors of this volume find that although the institutions of state reform and rebuilding appear to be nominally democratic, they are instead means to build support for political elites. These reforms have created some external legitimacy but ultimately undermine participatory democracy.
The volume assesses both internal and external dynamics of reconstruction. The internal dynamics include the judicial system, civil society, the resurgence of Khmer Buddhism, and the role of women. Kheang Un's chapter on the judiciary as well as Kim Sedara and Joakim Öjendal's chapter on decentralization take on the issue of constructing legitimacy within political institutions. Un finds that the ruling Cambodian People's Party (CPP) has stalled and implemented partial reforms that have left inefficient and corrupt judicial practices that support the CPP's rule. In contrast, Sedara and Öjendal view the decentralization process as having had some success in encouraging greater citizen participation at the local level while faltering at the national level. John Marston argues that the revival of Khmer Buddhism has enabled religion to play a paradoxical role of being used by politicians to build their personal legitimacy while at the same time presenting an alternative social order that can subvert the state. Lilja's chapter on women's participation bridges the internal/external divide and creates hybrid political identities based on traditional and Western roles of women. The external factors are the UN intervention, foreign aid, and the Extraordinary Chambers in the Courts of Cambodia (the Khmer Rouge tribunal). Caroline Hughes's chapter takes on the use of externally supported elections as a means toward legitimacy in her political history of Cambodian elections. She points to the CPP's projection of power through organizational capacity and the threat of violence, not a basis in electoral legitimacy. Martin Hasselkog, Laura McGrew, and Sophal Ear deal with the issue of legitimacy building via foreign intervention through governance, international tribunals, and foreign aid, respectively.
Öjendal and Lilja's approach to disaggregating democracy and reconstruction in Cambodia presents a fragmented picture: different elements of the state have their own unique logics of legitimacy, which do not necessarily cohere around a core concept of political legitimacy. In areas like the judiciary and electoral institutions where reforms have been implemented—and only partially so—by foreign actors, there remains a gap between local legitimacy and an appeal to international norms. This balancing act came to the fore in the 2013 elections; despite projecting itself as indestructible, the CPP did not have the support that it claimed—nearly half of voters voted for the opposition, and many continued to protest for nearly a year.
Both volumes present persuasive alternatives to measuring democratic transitions and understanding the components of the reform process. Törnquist argues a compelling case to rethink democratization as a dynamic process in Indonesia; however, his discussion emphasizes the more static ends more than the mechanisms driving those outcomes. Öjendal and Lilja's volume is useful for understanding the cracks in Cambodian political institutions that allowed for the CPP's misreading of the election and the ensuing protests by opposition supporters, as a result of competing political incentives for reforms and lasting partial reform.
