On his accession to the Spanish throne in 1700, Philip V, the first Bourbon monarch of Spain, appointed as his first non-interim viceroy of New Spain the tenth Duke of Alburquerque, Francisco Férnandez de la Cueva Enríquez. Alburquerque's viceregency (1702–10) and the political culture of court society are the focus of Christoph Rosenmüller's significant and insightful study. The author scrutinises the workings of viceregal patronage at the Mexican court, the alliances and networks the duke forged, the conflicts within which he became embroiled and his ultimate downfall. As Rosenmüller observes correctly, viceroys and their courts in the Spanish empire remain understudied in the historical literature. The choice of this particular viceroy is especially interesting given that he functioned as a transitional figure in the change from Habsburg to Bourbon rule and the early efforts (albeit frustrated) to expand Spanish imperial control. Rosenmüller draws on wide-ranging sources including viceregal correspondence and diaries, listings of the viceroy's retainers who travelled with him to New Spain, the juicio de residencia or inquiry into the viceroy's term of office, and records of the media anata.
Following a brief introductory chapter, Rosenmüller provides a solid overview of the economic and political culture of the Spanish empire in the early eighteenth century. Chap. 3 explores the problem of corruption and the spatial politics of the viceregal palace. Chap. 4 analyses the duke's ‘clients and creatures’ and his construction of patronage. Chaps. 5 to 7 address alliances and enmities (contraband trade, the power of the Mexican consulado, the conflict with the powerful Sánchez de Tagle family), the ‘faux’ Habsburg conspiracy against the new Bourbon dynasty and the deflection of royal reform policies (focused on the alcabala in Puebla and the secularisation of Dominican parishes in Oaxaca). Chap. 8 traces the duke's downfall after his return to Spain, where he was subjected to a number of charges but eventually absolved by the king of all of them (including toleration of contraband trade). Such absolution was dispensed after payment of an indemnity of a massive 700,000 pesos by the duke, although as Rosenmüller observes, ‘one has to see the trial of the duke as a part of a general cleanup’ (p. 158).
Two main arguments stand out in this study. Firstly, the viceroy ‘retained vast patronage privileges and used them to secure his hold over the colony’ (p. 78). The author provides a wealth of information on the viceroy's ‘clients’ and networks, and this constitutes the core and contribution of the study. When Alburquerque travelled from Spain to Mexico to take up his position, about 100 criados (retainers) accompanied him officially; others would join him surreptitiously in New Spain. We also learn, for example, that the duke appointed about 281 alcaldes mayores, corregidores and governors (more than half of all vacant district posts in New Spain); 11 of the appointments to the wealthiest districts went to his criados. Rosenmüller provides revealing compilations of the duke's other appointments of his ‘clients’ to positions in the treasury, the military, and the Church, as well as detailing relationships with Audiencia ministers and the duration of appointments.
A second argument emphasises that Philip V's choice of the duke owed less to the desire to appoint a loyal and efficient administrator than it did to the need to ‘appease the aristocratic party at home that opposed the new dynasty and its French counselors’ (p. 163). When the king attempted to increase control over the treasury, trade and the Church, much of the opposition to such attempts came from his own viceroy. Rosenmüller builds an interesting case here. He challenges Alejandro Cañeque's recent arguments about the ahistorical usage of the term ‘corruption’ (The King's Living Image, 2004). Rosenmüller agrees that patron–client relationships pervaded the early modern state. He cautions, however, that such clientelism had its limits, and that contemporaries understood when those limits had been transgressed, as demonstrated by the viceroy's temporary exile and trial. At the same time, there is something ultimately dissatisfying, at least for this reader, about the author's somewhat one-dimensional portrayal of Alburquerque. He is careful to point out that a complete discussion of all of Alburquerque's activities is beyond the book's scope, but one is still left wondering if the corrupt figure that emerges is really all there was to the duke. The most extensive comment about the viceroy's political views is that: ‘Policies designed to heighten monarchic authority affected his estate's privileges too. The duke followed the argumentation of those defending their privileges by emphasising the legitimacy of tradition’ (p. 128). This is probably so, but a bit more digging into the viceroy's political philosophy, given his family background and service to the crown (which would continue with his descendants), would have provided a more nuanced analysis. Without a better understanding of this it seems that if, as Rosenmüller asserts, the duke's politics ‘helped to keep the colony loyal to the Bourbons’ (p. 163), they did so as an accidental by-product of his opportunities for graft. There are also some beguiling but brief insights into the vicereine's role – when she appears, it is because of references to disagreements with her husband – which leave one longing for a more substantive discussion or at least greater curiosity about her influence in the shaping of viceregal power and patronage.
Despite Rosenmüller's perceptive analysis of the viceregal palace and court in chap. 3, he appears oddly reticent to engage with some of the most recent and sophisticated literature on the topic. He confines his engagement with Alejandro Cañeque's recent study to the issue of corruption as discussed earlier, yet Cañeque has much to say about the construction of viceregal power through image and ritual. Spanish scholars such as Victor Mínguez Cornelles and Inmaculada Rodríguez Moya who have addressed this topic are surprisingly absent from his bibliography. Readers will also want to consult Michael Schreffler's perceptive analysis of the Royal Palace and viceregal display of power in The Art of Allegiance (this probably appeared too late in 2007 to be integrated into Rosenmüller's study). Finally, in his discussion of pleasure and patronage building in the gardens and haciendas of Mexico's elites, Rosenmüller makes reference to Alburquerque's boat ride (with small entourage) to Ixtalcalco sponsored by Francisco de Medina Picazo, the treasurer of the tribunal of accounts. It is worth noting that this trip was captured in a charming painting by Pedro de Villegas (active c. 1706–23). Rosenmüller has written an important study that advances our understanding of the networks that shaped imperial rule. It is also a reminder of how much and how little we know about viceroys, their courts and their exercise of power.
