“The fate of private collections is that they are often sold by the next generation, which no longer shares the interests and passion of the collector, and get scattered in every direction, usually inaccessible for archaeologists” (20). M., however, one of the most renowned specialists in the field of African tableware, definitely shares the collector's interests and passion, which he aims to pass on to generations of researchers to come. He has now demonstrated this by presenting a typo-chronological evolution of 2nd–6th-CE decorated African Red Slip Ware (ARS) based on the private collection of K. Wilhelm (Munich). The study, reviewed here, offers an impressive synthesis of M.'s extensive research, continuously published in many articles since the 1980s.Footnote 1 It reflects his experience in the field of pottery studies and his vast knowledge of tableware.
The core of the work comprises over 200 examples of appliqué-, relief-, and stamp-decorated African tableware usually only found in museums. The outstanding pieces were collected between the 1970s and 1990s by the German K. Wilhelm, who developed a special interest in decorated ARS after seeing it exhibited at Carthage and Sousse (17). Wilhelm has collaborated with M., other archaeologists, and museums on various occasions (18), and his willingness to make the collection accessible for research is much appreciated by M. (11, 20). Nevertheless, the publication of a private collection of uncertain provenance raises some ethical issues, to which the review will turn at the end.
It is M.'s explicit wish to present profiles and views of selected pieces and, above all, to illustrate the decorative elements. This goal stems from the lack of proper documentation of decorated ARS that M. has detected in many previous publications. In several sections of the book, he laments that they often only exhibit one or two pictures of varying quality and a short description, but rarely drawings, leading to incomplete documentation and thus to a fragmented picture of typological repertoire and chronology (14, 80, 115, 117, 159). Nevertheless, he recognizes that such shortcomings are not due to lack of expertise, but rather to the time-consuming process of drawing and digitizing the specimens.
M.'s two-volume book shows that he himself did not shy away from this intense process, which ultimately took him more than a decade to finish. The second volume is entirely devoted to the presentation of meticulous drawings and high-quality pictures in grayscale as well as color that are one of the highlights of the work. There are 220 plates illustrating the 240 cataloged fragments, along with a very detailed, object-related description, bibliographical references, and comparanda.
The first volume (260 pages) begins with an extensive introduction to the history of the collection and, especially, the state of the art of ARS research, summarizing what is known on the manufacture, typo-chronology, location, structure, and organization of all workshops, as well as geographical distribution. Beyond addressing general aspects of African tableware, the chapters that follow are specifically intended to contribute to the typo-chronological evaluation of a large number of selected fragments that are part of the Wilhelm collection. The material is presented according to the traditional division, with the majority of pieces assignable to ARS A1, A2, A1/2, C1–C5, and a small portion to ARS D2.
Much recent research on ARS has focused increasingly on provenance studies and on-site investigations of production centers. Although the African origin of the objects in the Wilhelm collection is not in doubt, the findspot and circumstances of discovery are unknown. The intact state of many of the pieces, however, suggests that they were deposited in tombs (19). Their excellent preservation may have been the reason that sampling them for WD-XRF analyses to specify provenance was restricted to only 33 specimens. Another 11 pieces were analyzed with non-destructive portable XRF. The results are presented in an additional table in vol. 2 (358–59). Since the pieces in the collection lack contextual information and only a few were archaeometrically analyzed, M. takes a stylistic approach based on comparanda from secure contexts across the Mediterranean and beyond, but also with other, often decontextualized, pieces from collections and museums. He is primarily concerned with the stylistic analysis of appliqués and stamps as chronological indicators to trace the evolution of the decorated wares and improve the classification of ARS A and C, as well as the characterization of their production phases.
The earliest production of ARS A is divided into A1 and A2, of late 1st- and 2nd-c. date, and the transitional fabric A1/2, made until the first third of the 3rd c. (35–40), when production was taken over by the Central Tunisian plain and decorated ARS C1–C5 (3rd–6th c.) appeared, with its most important known production center being Sidi Marzouk Tounsi. A large part of the book deals with the so-called El Aouja Ware (also known as A/C) – a term created by J. W. Salomonson that includes the 3rd-c. subgroups C1/2, C2, and, according to new evidence, C/E (121, 125, 146). The collection's rare ARS D2 fragments of 4th–6th-c. date stem from North Tunisian production sites.
Throughout the book, M. strongly emphasizes the need for a revision of ARS A and C, in particular A1/2, C1/2, and C3, and also for the creation of a comprehensive catalog of all known appliqué decoration (80–81, 91–92, 187, 213, 251). With previous publications in mind, he takes the lead himself, by unifying all known typologies (mainly based on Salomonson and Hayes) of A1/2 (figs. 55–56), C1/2, C/E, and C2 (figs. 61–63) vessel types, adding new forms and/or variants. By numbering the most characteristic representatives, dominated by appliqué-decorated jugs and flagons with one or two handles, he renders them quotable (124) for future studies.
M. distinguishes an earlier and a later phase of A1/2 by analyzing the arrangements and patterns of appliqué decoration, especially palmette-bands and floral arcades (80–108), although the number of A1/2 pieces in Wilhelm's collection is small. However, based on 53 samples, he also reevaluates the El Aouja appliqué decoration and for the first time creates four different decor schemes according to horizontal and vertical subsidiary appliqué motifs and main scenes (130–45). The mold-made decorated handles of the El Aouja Ware that M. divides into seven types are also chronologically relevant (121–23). By systematically studying the decoration in every detail, he presents sufficient evidence to modify the dating of the El Aouja Ware by defining its late phase (= ARS C2) and to trace the fluid stylistic transition to the earliest phase (late 3rd c./early 4th c.) of appliqué-decorated C3, based on single “transition pieces” (120, 147, 185–86 fig. 89, 214) with characteristics of both ARS C2 and C3.
M. believes that this stylistic continuity developed in the workshops of Sidi Marzouk Tounsi. Although the site was discovered in 1984 during the British-Tunisian survey project conducted by D. P. S. Peacock, F. Bejaoui, and N. Ben Lazreg, and has been prospected several times since, a comprehensive study is still lacking.Footnote 2 This book, combined with M.'s previous papers, thus delivers the most detailed study so far, especially of its decorated ware. This also includes ARS C3, characterized by a rich repertoire of (figural) appliqués and the emergence of the first scenes with Christian connotations around the mid-4th c. (213). The usage of exterior appliqués, however, ended in the early 5th c. and was replaced by stamp- and incised decoration on the interior bottom. This gradual change is evinced by some late 3rd- and early 4th-c. pieces emulating silverware and assigned to an “experimental” phase (151–55), probably also connected to Sidi Marzouk Tounsi, preceding the stamp styles B, C, and D. Based on the Wilhelm collection with its vast repertoire of ARS C5 with style D stamps, M. has for the first time managed to document the transition from style C to the earliest phase of style D around 430–50 (162–64, 177). From simple Chi-Rho stamps characteristic of the earliest style D, he concludes that Sidi Marzouk Tounsi was the workshop introducing this change too.
Among the newly documented stamp motifs in the collection (161–79) is also that of a bust of the Vandal kind Gaiseric, showing that Sidi Marzouk Tounsi's activity continued until the 6th c., and included mold-made, relief-decorated forms, especially large rectangular and round plates, as well as various jugs and flagons. A hitherto neglected group of round plates with so-called “pseudo-stamp decoration” (233–37), i.e., a mold-made stamp look, is also discussed. With another unique hybrid piece, the combination of stamp decoration and rectangular plates is shown (171). Its origin from Sidi Marzouk Tounsi was confirmed by chemical analyses.
The majority of all the other analyzed samples also match the chemical signature of Sidi Marzouk Tounsi. Except for ARS A, with still unknown or debated origin(s), most of the 207 remaining pieces were assigned to Sidi Marzouk Tounsi based on morphological and stylistic arguments. The effectiveness of chemical analyses, already amply demonstrated,Footnote 3 as well as M.'s proven ability to macroscopically and typologically distinguish ARS productions, is not questioned. There still is, however, an ongoing discourse on the traditional division and nomenclature of ARS productions for categories A–E (recently extended to G) and their validity for differentiating individual production sites.Footnote 4 The fact that a workshop could have produced several categories (e.g., Djilma) and that a given category (e.g., D1) could have been manufactured by many workshops signals the complexity, and M.'s suggested creation of another category, namely A/D/E (55), is open for discussion.
However, while the importance of the scholarly work is easily recognized, the unprovenanced status of most of the objects in the K. Wilhelm collection, as in many other (private) collections, must be discussed.Footnote 5 One may assume that the lack of information on findspots is the result of unrecorded excavations or pillage and illicit export. M. does not provide detailed information on how the collection came to be. He only states that, e.g., in 1982 Wilhelm acquired parts from the German-Czech collector R. Kreissl and, in the following years, from other German, British, and Swiss private collections (e.g., L. Budde; 18).Footnote 6 Thus, reconstructing the trail between the first seller and Wilhelm as the last buyer is tricky. Illegal activities and legal acquisitions – knowingly and unknowingly (bona fide) – may have morphed together.
As a common archaeological consensus, it is needless to elaborate on the amorality of pillage and the devastating business with antiquities. International legislation for combating the worldwide trade with antiquities by establishing binding rules has, however, only been put into motion since 1970.Footnote 7 Additionally, differing national laws of individual countries have to be taken into account.Footnote 8 Within this legal framework, the changing momentum of a morally incorrect act becoming also illegal is hard to pinpoint. Nevertheless, it leaves us with a moral quandary of balancing ethical concerns and the potential impact that the study of objects despite their unknown circumstances of discovery can have on research. Moreover, it should be pointed out again that the intentions to share the collection with researchers and thus to serve research have been frequently demonstrated by Wilhelm (18–19). By condemning the collection for its unknown background, we would take the moral high ground but at the same time ignore its importance.
M.'s remarkable overview of the Wilhelm collection cannot be denied. It covers a wide range of decorated ARS A, C, and D, giving new insights on appliqué and stamp decoration that can be typo-chronologically framed, often linking different production phases. He has created a compendium that does not need to be read from cover to cover but can be used as a handbook, providing not only descriptions of individual pieces but also plentiful background information essential for anyone studying decorated ARS. The book is a prime example of showcasing the wealth of information enclosed in collections generally burdened by negative connotations. By maximizing the scientific output of the K. Wilhelm collection over its negative connotations, M. is also defying the otherwise common fate of collections being hidden, unseen, and forgotten.
