Drop Dead is an incisive and illuminating study of the impact of austerity on 1970s New York theatre. Drama seems inherent to the era—growing fiscal crises, escalating demands for racial and ethnic justice—all further heightened by the refusal of President Ford to bail out New York City as it faced bankruptcy, succinctly summarized as “Ford to City: Drop Dead” (2) by the Daily News. Hillary Miller examines this drama from many sides: the charged discourse about the arts and their worth, the debate over public resources, the spatial inequities in the wake of urban renewal and then divestment, and the impact on community and neighborhood identities. The book masterfully overlaps fields (even as it is weighed down by the multiple arenas of scholarly jargon and name-dropping): it adds historical, institutional, and urban context to theatre studies; theatre and cultural studies to urban history; and a much-needed historical perspective on contemporary debates about cultural policy. Miller's primary aims are to upend the myths that artists flourish in crisis and that government support of cultural organizations leads to their economic self-sufficiency. Scarcity is neither so inspiring nor so instructive. Instead, it is damaging. Miller shows not only how damage played out unevenly across the city but how often it deepened inequities.
The first of the book's three parts takes on “Ideologies of Austerity” by looking at the case studies of Ellen Stewart, La Mama, and Julie Bovasso in the Lower East Side in one chapter and the emergence of TKTS and its impact on Broadway and Times Square in another. The entrenchment of La Mama in the East Village contrasted sharply with “planned shrinkage” (33), the noxious broader city strategy to divest from already precarious areas experiencing abandonment and neglect. Stewart's determination to stay in place was laudable as an act of resistance to that disregard, but it was not smooth. Battle lines drawn between housing activists and artists—would-be allies—fighting over buildings, Miller shows, were a sign of the distortions caused by scarcity. Miller marks Stewart's persistence and dogged success as based on her constant building of relationships—between artists but also with neighbors, funders, and government officials.
TKTS in Times Square presents a process of institutionalization very different from that of La Mama. Formed as a temporary response to a panic over the suburbanization of Broadway theatregoers, this discounted ticket scheme consolidated the intertwining of tourism and commercialism in the Midtown district. The idea arose in response to fears of a declining audience base in the rapidly changing demographics of the city—a barely masked racialized argument to keep white people going to the theatre, rather than extending access to and building on the increasing numbers of African American and Latinx attendees. Miller notes the longstanding impact of TKTS in containing Broadway's audience demographics to largely white, well-off visitors and restricting aesthetic choices to ones that serve, rather than challenge, that audience. By not even selling tickets outside of Times Square, TKTS reinscribed the centrality of Broadway and commercial theatre there.
In “Affective Inequalities,” Part 2 of the book, Miller moves beyond Broadway and its offshoots to look at smaller organizations outside of central Manhattan. This section details the way that community, participation, grassroots, and engagement became slippery, loaded words populating the mission of the city's Department of Cultural Affairs and philanthropic organizations. Vinnette Carroll's Urban Arts Corps exemplified the push of many smaller arts organizations in demanding better infrastructure, resources, and attention, which such rhetoric promised but rarely delivered. These values and practices spread from the Everyman Street Theatre company in Coney Island to Peter Brook at the Brooklyn Academy of Music and the launch of the Out of Doors Festival at Lincoln Center. By 1979, the city had produced a guide to buskers, an embrace of this performance of the oft-lauded theatre of the streets. These practices had moved from focusing on community relations to the use of arts as urban uplift and tourist lure.
The final part of the book, “The Performance of Neighborhood,” explores the rise of the Public Theater and the Brooklyn Academy of Music (BAM). Miller charts how Joseph Papp utilized and performed different ideas of “public,” markedly able to transform Shakespeare from noble edification to a basic service, such as garbage removal, depending on audience and purpose. But his failure to vivify the Vivian Beaumont Theater at Lincoln Center exposed the conflicts at the root of any idea of theatre for some generally assigned “public.” In contrast, the local network of cultural organizations in Brooklyn buffeted the transformation of BAM at the same time as it received large subsidies from public and private coffers, often because it was seen “as a cultural center meeting community needs” (186). Miller points to BAM as a successful example of institutional investment at a time of austerity, paying off returns to the immediate neighborhood, the borough, and the city arts scene overall. What is often overlooked in the shining example of BAM, however, is its interdependence in a network of cultural organizations that nourished its growth even as many of those organizations did not receive similar recognition or support.
Theatre is neither New York's villain nor savior during the 1970s, Miller shows. It both produces and mitigates inequities; it is lobbed around as public good, public service, commercial transaction, and exclusive luxury. Fiscal austerity helps produce “the dollar approach to culture,” the now-common argument that the arts bolster the economy (96). Art for the public then becomes defined as art paid by public coffers and then pitted against other city services. Miller ends this ambitious book with a plea to dismantle “the myth of self-sufficiency” in the arts that austerity has set up and from which inequalities have dramatically widened (191). There is little nostalgia in Miller's recounting of this era, but a chance to undo that framework would be welcome.
