Introduction
There has been much criticism of the way that Western ontologies in general, and International Environmental Law (IEL) in particular, draw a hard line between nature and culture, viewing them as two distinct spheres.Footnote 1 Critical theorists hold that this chasm between nature and culture has been driven by a commitment to dominate, subjugate, and (ab)use the non-human, and to this day, this separation inhibits alternative conceptions of human-nature interconnectedness. This essay examines how two recent resolutions by the African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights are charting a path that escapes this colonial nature-culture divide.Footnote 2 The nature-culture divide spread and eventually ossified via colonialism, leaving an indelible mark on post-colonial states, including those in Africa.Footnote 3 Twentieth century IEL instruments on the continent replicated this colonial logic, treating nature either as an object to be loved and fostered (biophilia) or feared and eliminated (biophobia), but always to be defined by its value to humans. The African Commission, however, is beginning to find a path that avoids the biophilia-biophobia and nature-culture dialectics, opening the way for alternative understandings of environmental law.
A Conceptual Scaffolding of the Environment
Many scholars in recent years have tried to redress the conceptual split between nature and culture as a way of addressing the environmental problems we face. For instance, Alexander Wilson argues that “[h]umans and nature construct one another. Ignoring that fact obscures the one way out of the current environmental crisis—a living within and alongside of nature without dominating it.”Footnote 4 The resolution of this conceptual split emphasizes the harmonious connectedness of nature and culture as reflecting a biocultural understanding of the relationship between the human and the non-human worlds. It focuses on “ways in which nature, composed of the biological and material, organic and inorganic systems that sustain life, incites and produces culture, that is, the ways in which the biological enables rather than limits and directs social and cultural life.”Footnote 5 A tangible example of this biocultural approach is the emerging field of rights of nature, where flora and fauna, in and of themselves, are rights-bearing entities.Footnote 6 Accordingly, the reconstruction of nature and culture through a re-imagined biocultural approach pivots away from a “binarized distinction between nature and culture” to a renewed perspective of harmony and relationality.Footnote 7
However, attempts at reclaiming nature as integrative of culture have made little progress because of two foundational theories—biophilia and biophobia—that have long informed the normative content of IEL. On one hand, biophilia asserts a positive, innate association between humans and nature.Footnote 8 It views humans as separate from nature yet remaining firmly connected to it by a love-mediated affiliation.Footnote 9 For instance, biophilic laws across the United States, including states like Oregon, support conserving “urban wildlife habitat” as an object of adoration.Footnote 10 On the other hand, biophobia demonstrates “strong negative emotional attitudes towards nature.”Footnote 11 This heightened anxiety (or dislike and even fear) explains how humans identify and avoid nature-based threats as part of evolutionary adaptation. However, biophobia elevates human choice-making, which is inconsistent with nature’s own well-being. For example, several jurisdictions, from Australia to the United States, have enacted laws permitting wanton destruction of nature under the guise of control and disposition of feral animals.Footnote 12
The biophilia-biophobia framework is an organizing principle that shapes human constructions of the environment. This framework, which is written into IEL, causes us humans to see ourselves as apart from the environment—either as a love-object or a threat—rather than seeing ourselves as simply another part of it. If humans treat the environment as external to them, it is because the biophilia-biophilia framework endures.
Nature-Culture Divide in Action
The cultural constructions of nature provide insights into identifying the place of the environment in IEL.Footnote 13 This is demonstrated through the latent character of the biophilia-biophobia framework and its longstanding connections to the project of international environmental lawmaking.Footnote 14 The enduring influence of this framework has led critical IEL scholars to admonish that “an unmaking is required for international lawyers to adequately respond to ecological crises.”Footnote 15 In this respect, it is “evident that certain harmful understandings of nature were foundational to shaping the discipline [of international law].”Footnote 16 Below, I briefly discuss three IEL treaties and how they epitomize this broader international law problem; and accordingly, how the African Commission’s recent resolutions offer a reconstructive perspective.
To begin, the 1900 Convention for the Preservation of Wild Animals, Birds and Fish in Africa was negotiated by European imperial powers to regulate nature in Africa.Footnote 17 This treaty reconstituted the pre-existing harmonious coexistence and cosmologies of African societies and nature by rechristening nature as the environment, a process that underlined the human-nature separation, to permit its manipulation.Footnote 18 Following this development, colonial approaches to the making of the environment redesignated nature along distinct lines of usefulness (biophilia) and harmfulness (biphobia).Footnote 19 The 1900 treaty’s “prime purpose was to protect the interests of humans [that is, Europeans] rather than safeguard the well-being of the animals.”Footnote 20 The treaty dichotomized good animals worthy of protection, labeled as game or service animals, and bad animals, described as pests, which were marked for destruction.Footnote 21 While the 1900 treaty never entered into force, it still encouraged a choice between protecting some animals supported by a biophilic framework and a corresponding extinction of other animals inspired by a biophobic outlook.Footnote 22
In 1933, European imperial powers repackaged the principles in the 1900 treaty into a new international agreement, the Convention Relative to the Preservation of Fauna and Flora in their Natural State.Footnote 23 The 1933 treaty reinforced this nature-culture divide. While the term vermin which had been integral to the 1900 treaty text was expunged, the 1933 treaty retained the previous treaty’s discriminatory categorizations and expanded them beyond animals to include plants.Footnote 24 It also maintained the legacy of this expunged vocabulary by continuing to divide animals into those “deemed worthy of protection” and those undeserving of protection.Footnote 25 The 1933 treaty required governments to promote this separation, literally, by aggressively removing Indigenous communities from newly established national parks and other designated protected areas.Footnote 26 The exclusion of Indigenous peoples resulted in an elimination of their non-dichotomous view of nature. The dispossession of Africans who did not share this distinction ultimately led to European colonialists effectively superimposing their own vision of what society-nature interrelations ought to be.
Altogether, the 1900 and 1933 treaties directed the creation of protected areas like nature parks that excluded Indigenous communities for the benefit of the colonialists who could hunt game in these parks and areas, as well as exploit cheap labor flowing from such human displacement.Footnote 27 This exclusionary approach continued beyond the formal end of colonialism in Africa. To this end, latter IEL treaties underlined the biophilia-biophobia separation by advancing dichotomized classifications of helpful, useful, worthy, or worthless nature. The 1992 Convention on Biological Diversity is a contemporary manifestation of this phenomenon.Footnote 28 The Convention dismisses the sacrosanctity of nature by expressly calling on state parties to “eradicate invasive alien species,” a process that invokes deliberate human choice-making over what aspect of nature counts as useful or not.Footnote 29 The pedigree and profound influence of this biophilia-biophobia framework in IEL poses a rather difficult question within IEL: what new approaches can address the Eurocentrism of the nature-culture divide?
Nature and Culture as an Integrative Field
Recent decolonial efforts by the African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights offer a promising response.Footnote 30 The African Commission adopted two resolutions in 2017 and 2018 pursuant to its mandate under the 1981 African Charter on Human and Peoples’ Rights.Footnote 31 The African Charter mandates that the Commission to undertake studies to advance the progressive realization of the Charter.Footnote 32 In this respect, Resolution 372 adopted in 2017 could potentially transform prevailing approaches to the nature-culture divide. It shifts attention away from the divide by recognizing the relationality and reciprocity between nature and culture without emphasizing human choice-making styled as either biophilia or biophobia.Footnote 33 Resolution 372 also highlights a biocultural approach, one that integrates sacred natural sites and territories into environmental imaginaries at state and substate levels in Africa.Footnote 34 It recognizes sacred natural sites and territories as integral to society.Footnote 35 It also emphasizes the responsibility of state parties under international law to protect these sites and territories and their customary legal systems together with the Indigenous communities that are custodians and stewards of these sacralized spaces.Footnote 36 Finally, it “recognize[s] and respect[s] the intrinsic value” of these sites and territories.Footnote 37
Resolution 403 adopted in 2018 reinforces the Commission’s efforts under Resolution 372. Its preamble recognizes sacred natural spaces as “one of the oldest forms of culture-based conservation, contributing to connectivity, resilience and adaptability.”Footnote 38 It emphasizes “reciprocal relations” as the foundation for rethinking society and nature interrelations by encouraging a return to African pre-colonial conceptions of society-nature relations.Footnote 39 Additionally, Resolution 403 tasks the African Commission’s Working Group on Indigenous Peoples/Communities and Minorities in Africa to undertake a study into the biocultural significance of these sites and territories. The anticipated report is intended to inform regional, state, and substate lawmaking to engender a new consciousness premised upon culture-informed nature conservation.Footnote 40
This renewing of pre-colonial African approaches underway in Africa turns away from the binarized choices of IEL’s colonial legacy. Resolutions 372 and 403 redirect attention to the underlying cultural values that define African Indigenous environmentalism.Footnote 41 These resolutions call for a significant shift from an overreliance on Western legal prescriptions that do not resonate with pre-existing sociocultural impulses that inspire compliance with Indigenous environmental norms. In doing so, the integrative character of nature and culture are highlighted through the interplay of human rights, nature, and environment. The intermingling of these seemingly discrete aspects of international law spotlights international conservation law, human rights, and Indigenous peoples’ rights as constituent elements of the environment. Consequently, these elements “affirm the bond between [I]ndigenous, tribal and other communities with their land, together with the floral, faunal and other resources in and on the land.”Footnote 42
A return to a renewed society-nature reciprocity in these present times accords with the global interest in finding durable solutions to the current ecological crises. In this respect, the African Commission’s work has long supported a society-nature interconnectedness jurisprudence even long before it adopted Resolutions 372 and 403.Footnote 43 The Commission’s quasi-adjudicative jurisprudence emphasizes the connection between environmental obligations and Indigenous values, norms, and cultural practices.Footnote 44 The Commission continues to deepen and expand this jurisprudence with its recent decisions stressing indigeneity and Indigenous connections across society and nature.Footnote 45 The Commission has also brought cases to the African Court of Human and Peoples’ Rights that emphasize the link between nature and culture.Footnote 46 Additionally, the Commission has taken steps to galvanize global interest in integrating nature and culture by demanding strategic action at the international level, engaging with the World Heritage Committee, the implementing body of the World Heritage Convention, by calling for the recognition of cultural heritage sites as relevant to Indigenous environmentalism and reciprocal relations between society and nature.Footnote 47 Finally, the Commission’s effort is notable for how it bridges the nature-culture divide in contradistinction to the World Heritage Committee’s practice of recognizing only sites of cultural significance or sites of natural significance but not both.
Conclusion
As I conclude, I return to the theme of this symposium, and query whether the appropriate question to pose is, can the environment be a subject of international law? Admittedly, the prodigious and pioneering work of the African Commission is still a long way from achieving durable results, even though it is giving rise to a globally relevant jurisprudence on the reciprocal relationship between society and nature. On this subject, Resolutions 372 and 403 have sparked a renewed interest in examining biocultural values guided by a refreshing vision of sacralized spaces as a basis for re-locating nature in international law.Footnote 48 These are significant efforts premised on a culture-informed IEL framework that transcends the biophilia-biophobia problem. The African Commission’s work thus serves as a reminder that attentiveness to the interconnection between culture and nature is a necessary starting point to re-centering the environment in IEL.
