That laboring men could earn $1 a day seemed “incredible” to some foreign observers who were hard pressed to understand how this might lead to anything but universal prosperity. Yet it was not uncommon for other observers to take note of dirty children in tattered clothing collecting bits of wood and rags or poor families waiting in line for free bread. These two very different portraits of American's urban working classes were interpreted similarly. Prosperity followed ambition and morality; poverty followed laziness and degeneracy. In the land of the prosperous, only those of moral failing would not—could not—succeed. Poverty was the consequence of “idleness, intemperance, and improvidence” (p. 159).
As all economic historians know, a dollar-a-day wages did not translate into $365 in annual earnings; it did not even translate into $300. It was difficult for most working folk to string together a month of uninterrupted employment. A year of continuous employment was as unimaginable to urban working class men and women as a dollar a day was to some foreign observers.
The reality of urban working life, Seth Rockman reminds us, was privation, worry, and trouble. Food alone demanded half a laboring man's weekly wage, assuming he could keep himself employed the entire week. Bread cost 12½ cents a loaf and fruit and vegetables were expensive even in season, so that most of the remaining food budget was spend on meat and stimulants (coffee, tea, and tobacco). Diets heavy in bread and meat were spartan and so deficient in dietary fiber that constipation was a common complaint among the working poor (p. 178). For many of those who could not find six day's work a week, “scavenging, bartering, and a host of other informal exchanges” filled the void (p. 185). Still others stole, begged, or prostituted themselves. A dollar a day was not enough.
Rockman's eight substantive chapters utilize archival and secondary sources to paint a rich and balanced portrait of early-nineteenth-century common laborers. The book progresses logically, with chapters on the lure of the city, the jobs and working conditions facing men, and women, wages paid, the nonmarket labors involved in “scraping by,” and the consequences of failure, which were the almshouse and private benevolence. The most interesting chapter is the third, titled “Dredging and Drudgery,” in which Rockman documents the conditions of the men who worked the city's “mud machine.” So much silt flowed into Baltimore's harbor each year that ships regularly ran aground and only constant dredging kept the channel clear and the dredger was familiarly called the “mud machine” by the men who worked it.
Most of the early republic's laboring men left no documentary record of their labors. Fortunately, for Rockman and for his readers, the city kept and circumstances preserved detailed payroll records of the mud machine's operators. The work was grueling and filthy and “unsuited to the habits of republican artisans” (p. 76). Thus, the work fell to the working poor—immigrants, blacks, and unskilled native-born whites. Men with likely Irish surnames represented more than 30 percent of those recorded in the payrolls (p. 89). Despite the compensating differential for the dangerous and disgusting work and the constancy of employment, few men lasted more than month on the machine. This chapter would be a terrific assignment for an undergraduate economic history course. The wide-ranging nature of the chapter opens several avenues for fruitful discussions about the condition of early American workers.
This book is, perhaps, best read as a history of the tumultuous period labeled the “market revolution.” Market forces were breaking down traditional, familial exchange relationships and replacing them with impersonal arm's-length transactions. In the first half of the nineteenth century, everyone seemingly had cause for complaint with the market. Planters lamented rising slave and uncertain cotton prices; farmers and merchants complained of the penuriousness of bankers; journeymen tailors complained of wages driven down by seamstresses, and seamstresses of the high prices of food and fuel. For all its advantages, the market is an unforgiving and relentless taskmaster. Although Rockman provides a rich portrait—with an occasionally excessive Dickensian flourish—of early-nineteenth-century urban common laborers, it is not clear that their experiences or their reactions to the creeping influence of the market were unique. Everyone was trying to reconcile the acknowledged benefits of the market with its costs. Because both were diffuse, few contemporaries viewed the change as unmitigated good. It is good to be reminded on occasion that economic growth, rising rates of total factor productivity growth, and market integration had a human face, and it was not always a happy one.
