This is not a book about Islamic terrorists. Rather, it focuses on the worldview and international impact of the rest of the world's Muslims. The work's major hypothesis is that Islam has emerged since the 1970s as a major influence on the international system. Its nine separately authored essays seek to explain the causes and impact of this phenomenon. The first two seek to politically characterize the nonterrorist Muslim majority. Three chapters analyze the origins and international implications of crosscutting issues such as Islamic banking and finance and Muslim attitudes on female human rights. The remaining essays are case studies of the global role of Muslims in South, Central, and Southeast Asia as well as in the Arab world.
Rejecting Huntington's assumption of a homogeneous Muslim population, Muslims are politically categorized into five groups. Secularists view religion as a personal matter within a secular state. Moderates expect the state and Islam to coexist if the state respects Islam's basic tenets in its laws and politics. Fundamentalists reject earthly politics for the greater goal of purifying Islam to ensure heavenly salvation. Finally, there are two other kinds of Islamists: those who reject and those who use violence. However, they both seek earthly liberation from secular statehood and Western domination by converting Islam into an activist political ideology.
The international system under study is dominated by Western powers and organized into Western secular, territorial nation states. Muslims voluntarily or involuntarily live in such nation states. The Muslim response to this alien system has made contemporary world politics more complex and unstable. One response is outrage over Western intervention into the Islamic world. For example, while Western powers use female gender issues to criticize Muslim values and behavior as repressive, they hypocritically support oppressive pro-Western Muslim regimes. There is also outrage over the negative socioeconomic impact of globalization and Western-style liberal democracy on the patriarchal foundation of much of the Muslim world.
A second type of Muslim response is defensive, but nonviolent. Muslims are taking counteractions to threaten the current Western-dominated global system. Muslim–Western confrontations have escalated from disjointed regional responses to a post September 11th global movement against Western control. Economic and political targets now include not only the United States, but also other great powers such as Russia, China, India, and smaller states that oppress Muslims minorities such as the Philippines and Burma. Western multinational corporations and pro-Western Muslim governments are also legitimate targets for coordinated nonviolent confrontation. Muslims are using growing oil revenues to create an Islamic banking and finance system to challenge Western economic control. Other manifestations include a more vigorous rejection of Western claims about universal human rights. Moreover, Pakistan's development of nuclear weapons has created Western fear of the geopolitical ramifications of a Pakistani–Indian nuclear war.
Although many of these themes are not new, this book presents them in a clear, concise, and often thought-provoking manner. It has excellent summaries of the contributions to the development of political Islam made by Hasan al-Banna, Sayyid Qutb, and by the often overlooked Pakistani ideologue Abuءl-Aءla Mawdudi. A concise post Cold War political history of Uzbekistan and an innovative comparison of the evolution of political Islam in Malaysia and Indonesia add to the reader's knowledge. The analytical arguments used to determine the political impact of Islam in Southeast Asia can be usefully applied elsewhere in the Muslim world.
One of the thought-provoking observations in this book is the suggestion that the radicalism of the Muslim Brotherhood and the Iranian Islamic Revolution has been undercut because of their concern for running a Muslim version of the reviled Western territorial nation state. However, the global al-Qaءida network is posited as a major organizational breakthrough in attacking the secular nation state system. Because it is stateless, it is immune from being coopted by the inherent utility and logic of the nation state institution. There is also the observation that the symbolic authenticity of enforcing veiling and other Islamic dress codes inadvertently has empowered Muslim women to legitimately pursue Western education and outside employment because they are now properly attired. Another author argues that not only does the Arab world still possess a vibrant secular social and political life, but that this secular model is also transferable to other Muslim societies as a functioning alternative to political Islam.
This valuable work is suitable for undergraduate and graduate students as well as useful for specialists in Middle Eastern politics and Islamic studies. It is technical enough that a recreational reader might find it difficult to understand. It is also a useful addition to academic libraries because of its concise but competent explanations of Islamic ideologues, Islamic banking, and the evolution of political Islam in Uzbekistan, Malaysia, and Indonesia.
