This carefully researched book is the first to provide detailed information on Hizbullah's political action by focusing on the area where its headquarters and major institutions are located: Beirut's tattered and crowded southern suburb of al-Dahiyeh. Harb's work explains how and why Hizbullah established and maintains a network of professionally managed public and urban services within a space where it has encouraged Islamization. The author finds that through an array of public actions Hizbullah has generated legitimacy, providing it additional support for its resistance activities. While this finding is hardly unique, the thoroughness of the author's investigation of selected Hizbullah institutions, her analysis of their management, and her discussion of instances in which Hizbullah successfully challenged government projects on behalf of its constituents provides new insights into the party's information management, strategies, tactics, and level of operational expertise off the battlefield.
The book is organized around the following questions: How is Hizbullah structured, and how does it manage public services al-Dahiyeh? How is this type of public action transformed and maintained within the context of ongoing changes occurring in the Lebanese political system? Explanations of the nature of that system, the beginning of Shiʿi political groups’ participation in post civil war reconstruction, local and national elections, and the southern suburbs’ social and geopolitical configuration provide the necessary context of the discussion.
The book's argument is laid out in the first three chapters, which contain previously unpublished information that not only brings Hizbullah's sociopolitical actions up to date but also demonstrates the way in which institutions are evolving and how their missions are interpreted, managed, and interrelated by Hizbullah leaders and functionaries.
Analyses of public policy are usually carried out in industrialized societies that have little concern with social groups structured on confessional and territorial bases like those of Lebanon. By elucidating the nature of contemporary intermediation between the state and an interest group in the production of public action in Lebanon, Harb thus makes an original and important contribution to public policy theory. The works of B. Jobert (“L'etat en action: L'apport des politiques publiques,” Revue francaise de sciences politiques 35 [1985]: 654–82), J.-P. Gaudin (L'action publique: Sociologie et politique [Paris: Presses de Sciences Po et Dalloz, 2004]), and P. Muller and Y. Surel (L'analyse des politiques publiques [Paris: Montchrestien, 1998]) in particular guide the more general inquiry, while references to works on the social and political importance and meaning of space sheds light on daily life and sociopolitical dynamics in the observed area, a locale with which the author is thoroughly familiar.
The author's fieldwork consisted of interviews with directors of institutions; individuals who implement Hizbullah directives, policies, and programs; al-Dahiyeh mayors; and public action beneficiaries. A close look at the mission, organization, management, and daily operations of three of Hizbullah's social service divisions—education, health, and urban development—provides information about how and why the men in these divisions pursue their social action work from ideological as well as practical points of view. This discussion represents a particularly valuable contribution to the literature on Hizbullah that has stressed the expertise and loyalty of cadres but has not fully explored its roots and development. For instance, interviews with Abu Saʿid al-Khansa, mayor of the Municipal Council of Ghobeyri district and a founding member of Hizbullah (pp. 124–29), reveal the reforms and projects that he has carried out in the community at the grassroots level, leading the author to conclude that “his legitimacy rests on the accumulation of experiences from his social and political itinerary” (p. 128). In contrast, ʿAli Fayyad, also one of Hizbullah's founders and director of Hizbullah's think tank, the Consultative Centre for Documentation and Research, from 1996 to 2009, acquires his legitimacy by other means. A member of the Lebanese Union of Muslim Students as a youth, he then received a doctorate at Lebanese University in political sociology. Under his direction, the Centre—structurally independent from Hizbullah but linked by Fayyad—was transformed into what the author considers to be “the impressive research center and forum that it is today” (p. 120).
Thorough investigation of the topic covered in each of the book's sections and chapters has resulted in a clearer picture of how Hizbullah maintains its legitimacy and power in the Shiʿi community and why its constituents adhere to the organization after having suffered time and again the consequences of its military activities against Israel. Examples drawn from Chapters 2 and 4, respectively, illustrate the scale, scope, and evolution of these services and, interestingly, how various resources are integrated to achieve positive and sustainable results.
Hizbullah's dominance of the delivery of medical and health care to residents in its areas of influence is acknowledged by the author to be very impressive. In addition to managing a string of clinics, as well as the Raʾsul al-ʿAzzam Hospital, a modern, efficiently run, and low-cost facility located in al-Dahiyeh, the organization sends mobile clinics to areas where no dispensaries exist. However, according to Harb, the political keystone of the Islamic society being shaped by Hizbullah is the preventive-medicine program. The provision of medical education to some 850 volunteers a year “to promote medical literacy” (p. 104) is an important feature of this undertaking. The author provides fresh information through examples of how Hizbullah collaborates with nongovernmental organizations and ministries to advance this program. For instance, in 1998 Hizbullah vaccinated more than 250,000 children in partnership with UNICEF and sent out teams that conducted house to house visits to make sure that no child was missed. Students in local schools also receive regular checkups by Hizbullah-associated doctors cooperating with the Ministry of Education. These activities and many others designed and carried out by cooperating medical and educational experts are heavily promoted on al-Manar TV talk shows, in forums at the Consultative Centre enlisting doctors and health directors, and at local gatherings. Acknowledging Hizbullah's work in this field as “scientific and professional,” the American University of Beirut's Department of Public Health has initiated a research project on al-Dahiyeh in cooperation with the directors of Hizbullah's Islamic Health Society. Harb's research reveals the extent to which Hizbullah is deeply integrated into mainstream political life and how no stone is left unturned in the pursuit of a healthier community.
Another example of Hizbullah's impact on what Harb refers to as the “Hizbullah Society” it has created in the southern suburb relates to a political squabble between the Party of God and former prime minister Rafik Hariri's cohorts in the Lebanese government. The quarrel concerned the means of indemnifying some 50,000 residents (many squatters) of the coastal area of al-Dahiyeh whose homes would be destroyed by the Elyssar Project's proposed highway and plans for renovation of the derelict area (pp. 205–22). Calling on the Consultative Centre for demographic statistics and an alternative plan, Hizbullah made sure that residents were kept abreast of the ongoing negotiations with government officials. In this way the residents could make their views apparent in public interviews or through demonstrations at the appropriate time in the discussions so as to advance Hizbullah's position that new housing be made available rather than cash payments. Hizbullah prevailed.
Hizbullah also succeeded in defeating the government's plan to leave empty the sector of al-Dahiyeh, which had been destroyed by the Israeli Air Force during the 2006 war, and to direct and manage necessary construction through its slow bureaucratic machinery. Here, too, Hizbullah's plans carried the day. With help from a university-educated architect, many professionals working pro bono, and Hizbullah's vaunted Jihad al-Binaʾ (Reconstruction Campaign), the Waʿd (Promise) Project erected 230 identical, modernized buildings that are now occupied by their former owners or renters. According to the author, these projects emphasize the rational, managerial, scientific type of legitimacy earned by Hizbullah. Its capacity to field and integrate teams of professionals and volunteers for a given task while mobilizing stakeholders’ political and social involvement through TV, from the pulpit, and by the obvious commitment of the local and higher echelon leaders has produced important achievements for the Shiʿi community.
The second type of legitimacy derived from Hizbullah's public action is qualified by the author as traditional and bears on the organization's efforts to entertain, instruct, and above all mobilize individuals through socioreligious practices and events based on Shiʿi Islam (p. 247). Chapter 3, “The Hezbollah Society,” points out the many ways in which this party pursues these goals and the reaction of residents living in al-Dahiyah—some very pious and others who merely prefer an alternative to the Western lifestyle adopted by other Lebanese. For instance, Hizbullah provides full television coverage of the ten days of ʿAshuraʾ that commemorate the death of the Prophet's son-in-law Hussein from an enormous hall that can seat hundreds. Community members can attend the parades and exhibitions that are held regularly or participate in leisure activities and organized trips to historic places or saints’ tombs. Images of Jerusalem, martyrs, Iranian spiritual leaders, and Hasan Nasrallah produced by Hizbullah appear again and again in these events as well as on al-Manar TV's programming on socioreligious topics. The posters and banners of Hizbullah martyrs and leaders, as well as of Iranian notables, that mark the territory finally leave no doubt that many residents, if not most, are carrying out distinctive lives in this slice of Beirut.
The author points out, however, that Hizbullah confronts a challenge common to many organizations wishing to maintain control: how to deal with internal dissent and especially with the expression of alternatives within the Shiʿi community. If Hizbullah opens to dialogue and allows other actors to participate in public action, then its authority could be weakened. If it does not, then it risks alienating those who might find the political and social atmosphere of al-Dahiyeh stifling.
Moving to her general findings, Harb observes that in developing countries the state's incapacity to regulate political action and to set mechanisms of social control is often pronounced. This is because various groups (e.g., ethnic or confessional) are often fragmented and live by diverse and self-applied rules. If a group is particularly strong, then the state is caught up in the dilemma of not being able to override those rules and thereby reinforcing them through inaction. In Lebanon's case, the government's difficulty in establishing public action within the context of pluralism and social heterogeneity has been amply proven. Faced with Hizbullah's pursuit of a resistance mission and the political strength and legitimacy it has created as a result of political action, one can comprehend why efforts to undercut its power have failed in the past and are likely to continue to do so in the future.
Harb's impressive book suffers from lack of an index and references to earlier works that also emphasize the scientific side of Hizbullah and the differences between the latter and its Shiʿi rival, the Amal Movement. The author should have included surveyed sources of Hizbullah's popularity and excluded assertions that are not backed up with any evidence. These omissions are minor, however, in light of the richness of the theory, information, and analyses that are provided.
