Riexinger's and Hartung's books are two recent German doctoral studies on key thinkers in 19th and 20th century South Asian Islam. The Ahl-i Hadis were a loose community of taqlīd-critical scholars whose members played an important role in Urdu publishing, political agitation, and religious controversy throughout the late colonial period. Although they were never united enough to constitute a strong organizational structure or movement, the reverberations of their ways of thinking can be traced all the way down to contemporary Islamic radicalism in Pakistan. Abul Hasan

Ali Nadwi was in many ways the personification—if such a thing is possible—of the ulama experience of Indian Islam. Always attempting to bridge differences between opposing strands of South Asian Sunni Muslim “orthodoxy” and to tie it firmly to a Pan-Islamic ideal, Nadwi was a figure who participated or remained in contact with almost all religious formations of his time, from various Sufic orders to the Muslim Brotherhood and the Tablighi Jama

at.
Both books advance our understanding of South Asian Islam and will be a gold mine of information for any German-reading scholar. Their purchase for any research library with a strong South Asia interest should be essential. This said, the specific format that both books seek to satisfy imposes certain limitations on their effectiveness. It is compulsory in Germany to publish doctoral dissertations in an unrevised—or as is the case here, minorly revised—form, which somewhat impedes the focused and streamlined articulation arguments. Particularly in a discipline like Islamwissenschaft— from which the two titles originate—doctoral candidates are first and foremost expected to demonstrate complete familiarity with the wider secondary literature, as well as their ability to deal thoroughly and exhaustively with texts in original languages. In consequence, Hartung and Riexinger have made a conscious effort to include much of the general development of Islamic Indian thought from the late 18th century onward, and both appear to have tried to present all information gathered in field research, often in a relatively raw form. This accounts for the excessive length of both books and explains why neither is able to come up with a truly memorable conclusion in the end.
In Hartung's case, there is strong evidence that he seeks to go beyond the formal restrictions of the German doctoral dissertation, however. He elaborates a useful theoretical roadmap, based on a combination of network and discourse analysis, that helps him to present Nadwi's life and thought within a larger narrative framework. He begins by positing three key questions as the reference points of Islamic debate in South Asia: the role of reason in religious knowledge between the traditions of ma

qulat and manqulat, the interpretation of Sufism between wahdat al-wujūd and wahdat al-shuhūd, and finally the question of religious activism (iqamat al-din) between what he calls a “conformist activist paradigm” and a “nonconformist activist paradigm.” Nadwi's concerns within these parameters were twofold: he sought to develop modes of thought and action that would enable the community of Indian Muslims to defend a strong sense of religious identity that was independent of access to political power, and he firmly believed in the ideal of a united world community of believers bound together by a common cultural and religious ideal. The overall aim in Nadwi's life was da

wa, the peaceful propagation of personal religious rectitude on a global scale. This led him to adopt orthodox but conciliatory positions on many matters of doctrine, but also necessitated an increasingly sharp demarcation against state-centered forms of religious radicalism, for instance Abul A

la Mawdudi's Jama

at-i-Islami (which Nadwi nevertheless chose to join for a couple of years in the 1940s). Nadwi's role in several South Asian and worldwide umbrella organizations was the practical side of his life project. He served as the head of the Indian Nadwat ul-

Ulama (conceived as a federation of all strands of the Sunni religious establishment) for much of the 20th century; later he also became involved in the Saudi-sponsored Islamic World League, as well as with the Moroccan-supported World League of Islamic Universities. He gave guest lectures all over the world, took a leading role in the Oxford Centre for Islamic Studies, and was closely associated with leading contemporary scholars such as Yusuf al-Qaradawi.
The great strength and special contribution of Hartung's book lies in its detailed analysis of the personal relationships that bound Nadwi to a great number of important individuals who often disagreed with his own views. Following the veritable tradition of

ilm al-rijāl, Hartung traces the biographies of Nadwi's family of scholars, his teachers, Sufi masters, disciples, friends, and political companions. The appendix lists impressive tables of cross-connections that demonstrate that there was considerable overlap in the various forms of personal loyalties that dominated Nadwi's life. Hartung's great insight is that personal obligations to men were of an equal if not greater importance for the formulation of religious positions than the autonomous logic of discourse. Although it is not always clearly elaborated how the distinction between “open,” “half-open,” “transparent,” and “closed” fields advances the course of interpretation, it is convincingly argued that Nadwi's eventual decline into political irrelevance was the result of his desire to give every one of his many patrons and clients their due.
Although it is easy to see how Hartung's book could be shortened and revised into a punchy monograph (hopefully in English), no such possibilities present themselves in Riexinger's thesis. Not by default but quite deliberately, his exposition of the thought and organization of the Ahl-i Hadis is as scholarly impressive as it is “intellectually anorexic”—to borrow Tariq Ali's somewhat unkind phrase. Riexinger makes it absolutely clear that he does not think very highly of “theory-building” or of the adoption of social science models into Islamic studies. The thorough study of “texts” alone can help us to understand the sociocultural “context,” he affirms. This is, of course, a perfectly legitimate form of scholarly approach, but one would like to see it grounded in some form of engagement with textual strategies and literary theory. Beyond an invocation of philological exactitude, Riexinger does not reflect on what precisely a text is, not even at the fairly elementary level of offering a formal analysis of the different textual genres he uses as sources.
The basic problem is that Riexinger remains caught up in the very historical and sociological mode of enquiry that he rejects, but without any willingness to propose any arguments of his own. The lack of any narrative aim is already apparent in the structure of the book: it simply lays out several thematic aspects of Ahl-i Hadis history—their formation in response to the thought of Shah Wali

ullah Dihlawi and the Yemeni Hadis scholar Muhammad b.

Ali al-Shaukani, the historical context of British Punjab, the life histories of leading personalities, the contents of all accessible writings by the central character Sana

ullah Amritsari, and so on—but without ever telling us what exactly we should learn from this exposition and how the different parts hang together. It is significant that clear arguments emerge only when it comes to a rejection of the existing body of literature on the grounds of empirical detail. Barbara Metcalf saw the movement as an elite formation; Riexinger retorts that there were also peasants involved. Jamal Malik speaks of the articulation of an urban and modernizing commercial consciousness; Riexinger points out that there is much in Ahl-i Hadis' writing that is not in conformity with such an assumption, and there were also artisan and small-town members.
Some of this criticism appears well taken; some is unnecessarily vindictive and smacks of point scoring, particularly in the engagement with Malik or the German historian/Arabist Reinhard Schulze. However, the overall line of critique remains simplistic in the eyes of more theory-minded readers. Anybody who takes the interface between grand theory and history seriously knows that the “modernity,” class orientation, or sociocultural stance of any movement or mode of thought can never be positively deduced from a laundry list of necessary “facts.” The presence of contradictions, diachronic moments, and ideological transpositions challenge the historian into developing sophisticated theoretical models in the light of empirical evidence. Riexinger does not take up this challenge, and to criticize him for this is only commensurate with the cutting language he employs against others. All this is a pity, because Riexinger's book succeeds brilliantly in opening up Ahl-i Hadis' writings as an interesting body of material. The new demand to preach in local vernaculars, the persistence of “traditional” cosmologies, the advancement of certain women's rights on one hand and the emphasis on a very conservative patriarchal morality on the other, the advocacy of Western learning, the return to texts and the rejection of taqlīd—all this is evidence, which, if handled well, can significantly advance our understanding of what it means to be “modern” the South Asian Muslim way.
