This is a fascinating story about Mary Gorman, an American teacher recruited by Argentine minister (later president) Domingo F. Sarmiento to direct a normal school (what we would now call a teacher-training college) in San Juan province, Argentina. Due to personal circumstances, Gorman refuses to go to San Juan, stays in Buenos Aires for a while, and, after marrying an Irish entrepreneur, moves to the southern frontier. Her life appears as a long peregrination from New Mexico to Argentina's southern frontier. With her husband, Mary settles in town of Pigué, in an area recently populated by rebellious Indian tribes. In a way, this is the story of the intellectual, moral and ‘sentimental education’ of an American woman, who faces many difficult decisions. Her father Samuel – himself a Baptist missionary – wants Mary to train for missionary work. Her female mentor, Mary Hastings, wants her to be an independent woman, dedicated to educating other women. Her second ‘spiritual father’, the Reverend Brooks, shows her a different path to religion, one that sees God in nature and embraces the study of science. Mary's high standard of education allows her to marry into wealth and so, rather than becoming a female educator, she ends up as the head of a large family on the Argentine frontier.
At first sight a biography of one of the first American teachers recruited to improve Argentina's educational system, the study actually focuses on a series of connected questions that relate women, education, sociability and civilising impulses both in the United States and in Argentina. Among these questions are the relations between Mary and her parents, the choices Mary had to make concerning education, marriage and wealth; and her accommodation to radically different social milieus (the US southwest, the US northeast, and the Argentine Indian frontier). Mary Gorman's story, furthermore, deals with a variety of themes: from the Second Great Awakening to female education in the United States; from the US occupation of New Mexico to the American Civil War; from the settling of the Argentine pampas to Sarmiento's educational policies. These detours greatly enrich the biography, making the personal and the social–cultural context interact in interesting ways. The documentary bases for this biography are scattered letters that relate to different moments of Mary Gorman's life. This evidence is so fragmented that the author is forced to fill in blanks of information with conjectural statements. At many points in the narrative, she uses verbs in the past conditional (‘would have’, ‘may have’) to complete these empty spaces. Everyone who has done subaltern history knows the difficult of working with fragments, yet the reader may wonder, is this what Mary really thought or felt?
At the beginning of the story we find Mary growing up in a religious family. Her father Samuel has moved from Ohio to New Mexico to establish a Baptist mission among the Pueblo Indians in the town of Laguna. The family endures all kinds of privations until they are recognised as part of the local community. Samuel's ‘civilizing mission’ (pp. 30, 39) meets with much resistance: the Pueblo peoples had managed to preserve for centuries a syncretic religiosity that combined elements from Indian tradition and Spanish Catholicism. Mary grew up in this multicultural frontier environment, attentive to her father's advice on how to be a good missionary or, more generally, how to build a life ‘useful’ in the eyes of God.
The second part deals with Mary's education in the East. In 1857 Mary leaves New Mexico to study at the Hamilton Female Seminary in western New York. There she encounters a strong female educator, Mary Hastings, who teaches her Latin and the classics, and transmits to her a devotion to teaching, an interest in science, and the basics of Pestalozzi's pedagogy, founded on pupils’ activity and experimentation. During her stay in the East, Mary moves freely, visiting friends in Chicago, Cleveland, and other cities in the Midwest. She goes to the theatre for the first time and starts to enjoy museums and literature. Then the Civil War comes, a sad time when Mary loses her brother James. At this time, Mary reads literature that celebrates middle-class values. After graduating from Hamilton (1863), Mary is a free, career-oriented woman, in possession of a superior education. Yet labour market conditions force her to accept teaching jobs that are low-paid and temporary. So she moves from one place to another, until she gets a suitable position at a female seminary in Philadelphia. In 1868 she learns from Sarmiento's assistant Mary Mann that he is recruiting American female teachers to boost the Argentine educational system. Through the mediation of Mann, she is offered a three-year contract to teach in San Juan, Argentina. She accepts it.
Immediately after arriving in Buenos Aires (1869), Mary tells Sarmiento that she will not go to San Juan: the journey poses many dangers and a montonera guerrilla rebellion spreads panic among the population. To fulfil her contract, she enters under the protection of female educator Juana Manso, who assigns her to different teaching jobs in the city. Her refusal to go to San Juan has much to do with a life-changing decision: in the steamer which brought her to South America, Mary has fallen in love with a young man. This young American, John Beans, works for Samuel Hale, one of the richest men in the country. So Mary gets to know – and enjoys – the good life of well-to-do porteños, as the inhabitants of Buenos Aires are known. In other words, she enters a social world that would be inaccessible to a provincial teacher. Two years later (1871), her fiancé dies in the yellow-fever epidemic. Mary has then to consider two options: either she stays in Argentina or she returns to the United States. At this point, her social acquaintances come to the rescue: she meets an entrepreneur, John Sewell, who works as the manager for Eduardo Casey, a commercial, financial and land magnate. Mary marries John, and after two years, moves to the recently-founded town of Pigué to assist her husband in the managing of a large estancia and a land colonisation business. An independent woman prepared for a career in education, Mary ends up occupying a more traditional role: as wife and mother of a frontier family. Yet, the author presents this last part of her life as a new civilising mission: Mary has become part of the social and economic elite that is transforming the wealth and culture of southern Buenos Aires province. Having been a ‘desert’ dominated by semi-nomadic Indian tribes, the land is now occupied by industrious immigrants who grow wheat, raise sheep, and have built a small town with its own church and school.
Of Mary's life in the last 20 years of the nineteenth century, only photographs remain. Julyan Peard reads these photographs with great attention and sensibility. In 1902 Mary became a widow. Her lasting achievement is to have raised a large family and to have given a good education to her children of whom all one went to England for their education. This is part of the transformation experienced by Mary on the South American frontier: through Eduardo Casey, she had entered into the social world of the British in Argentina. In addition, she was exposed to, and open-minded about, other religions: she married John Sewell at the Anglican Church in Buenos Aires, abandoning her parents’ Baptist religion; Eduardo Casey, the couple's employer and benefactor, was an Irish Catholic who brought French Catholic nuns to Pigué.
This is a well-written, complexly contextualised and enormously interesting biography that will attract the attention of scholars involved in women and gender studies, transnational studies, and, to a lesser extent, those interested in the history of education. Non-Argentine readers will learn a great deal about Argentina during the beginning of the Golden Age (1880–1920), while Argentine readers can find much information about frontier life, female education and the East–West cultural gap in the United States. I have learned much from this book; I really enjoyed reading this biography and would expect other readers to have a similar experience.
