It is a well-known fact that many Victorian women writers such as the Brontë sisters, George Eliot, and Elizabeth GaskellFootnote 1 adopted pseudonyms or anonymity in publishing their literary works, but few people are aware of how such naming practices had been received by contemporary readers, especially by Victorian periodical reviewers – the very first readers and mediators that presented any major literary works to the public. Since we, as modern day scholars, have become so intimate with their present forms of author names appearing on course syllabuses, school curriculums, and academic papers, we hardly ask how such naming has become possible.
What concerned most Victorianist scholars, instead, was why these women writers had to adopt such unique naming practices in the first place. Gynocritics of the late 1970s and early 1980s often read male pseudonyms as a marker for the repressive psychology of women writers. Sandra Gilbert and Susan Gubar saw male pseudonyms as evidence for female “anxiety of authorship” (45). Elaine Showalter kept a similar view on women writers’ male pseudonyms. Later, new historicist scholars such as Nancy Armstrong tried to reverse this kind of gynocritical thinking – which had been often denounced as a victimology discourse for Victorian women writers – by showing how these women writers played major roles in forming middle-class bourgeois ideologies through their domestic heroines. In these representative feminist scholarship, how to interpret women writers’ names – especially their male pseudonyms – has become a critical matter for determining the extent of authorial agency for Victorian women writers.
Despite many achievements, these traditional approaches had often focused too much on women writers’ intention as a way to determine their authorial agency which has been either granted or denied in a wholesale way depending on each scholar's purpose. In other words, they failed to consider the practical impacts this naming act actually brought to readers in a larger cultural context – for instance, how it collided with professional readers’ (that is, Victorian reviewers’) responses and reactions, very active and dynamic elements that constituted Victorian literary scenes, and how it has been adapted and re-created in the process.
I want to revisit this naming issue by perceiving author names as discursive constructs. That is, what we've learned as familiar Victorian women author names are, in fact, cultural and discursive constructs of Victorian print culture and have been formed through complex critical histories. The benefits of viewing author names as discursive constructs of mid-Victorian print culture is that it allows us to pay attention to some of the specific issues that have been ignored so far, such as how Elizabeth Gaskell started her publishing career with anonymity yet had been addressed and printed as “Mrs. Gaskell” right after her identity as a married woman was revealed (and this practice lasted for quite a long time, even into the mid-twentieth century), and how “Currer Bell” and “George Eliot” had similar births as pseudonyms yet came to different endings in their critical afterlives.
Author names are crucial components that construct authors as social characters. Like a metaphor, author names serve as the most important index that reveals the discursive mode of the text: “The author's name, unlike other proper names, does not pass from the interior of a discourse to the real and exterior individual who produced it; instead, the name seems always to be present, marking off the edges of the text, revealing, or at least characterizing, its mode of being” (Foucault 147). Here, Foucault inscribes author names as part of discursive formations where his famous concept of author-function emerges: “The author-function is therefore characteristic of the mode of existence, circulation, and functioning of certain discourses within a society” (148). Unlike other proper names that refer to real individuals, author names remain always present on the boundary of the text as a discursive entity to reveal its mode of being, circulation, and functioning in society. As author names are always characterized as part of the discursivity of the text, they become social constructs rather than references for biographical authors. What Foucault emphasizes here is not the referentiality but the discursivity of author names – the ways in which author names characterize social discourses.
In other words, Foucault construes authors as social characters by emphasizing the discursive function of author names circulated in society. As Alexander Nehamas puts it, “the author is not a person at all, but a ‘function’ or ‘figure’” in Foucault's account (685). Nehamas interprets Foucault's authors as characters manifested in texts: “Authors are not individuals but characters manifested or exemplified, though not depicted or described, in texts” (686). Not only do authors serve as “formal causes” for texts, they are also “produced through an interaction between critic and text” (686). This view defines the reciprocal relationship between authors and critics. Inasmuch as texts are products of authors, authors are products of critics. Hence this sequence: “writers produce texts; some texts are interpreted and are thus construed as works; works generate the figure of the author manifested in them” (Nehamas 688). What is notable here is the mediating role of critics who turn texts into works by generating the figure of the author. Through critical works, authors become certain characters in social space. This essay pays attention to this aspect of authorship – how authors turn into certain social figures through their names in print.
This paper taps into Victorian periodical reviews, a cultural site where I can examine women authors as social characters. Just as authors present fictional characters through specific acts of narrative naming in literary works,Footnote 2 Victorian reviewers defined and presented authors as certain social characters through their own discursive act of naming. Of course, such an act of naming in the discursive field was necessarily influenced by the time period's larger cultural forces such as gender ideologies. Whether an author herself wanted or not, a new social character or personality was created by this massive discursive flow led by periodical reviews. Thus were created feminine “Charlotte Brontë” instead of coarse and masculine “Currer Bell,” intellectually superb but morally improper “George Eliot,” and mild and motherly “Mrs. Gaskell.” All these authorial characters / images came into being through specific acts of naming conducted by Victorian reviewers, especially through obituaries and biography commentaries after their deaths.
I focus on these three specific forms of women author names used in the discursive field of Victorian print culture with the following goals in mind. First, I try to explain away a long-standing conundrum caused by discrepancies between “Currer Bell” and “George Eliot” in the contemporary criticism as one name has remained firm with us while the other one has fallen into oblivion. Second, by debunking another old myth regarding “Mrs. Gaskell,” we can think back to our past feminist consciousness and think over the political implications any author names might bring to the reader in general.
First, why do we call George Eliot “George Eliot” while we do not call Charlotte Brontë “Currer Bell” anymore? Given that both writers continued to publish their works under these pseudonyms even after their secrecy was lifted, it seems odd that one name has stuck while the other one has fallen into disuse. Recently, a few scholars raised the same issue, though with side glances. Catherine Judd takes note that “George Eliot” displays “a profound tenacity that is entirely lacking with the Brontë s. . .. In the same way that Amandine Aurore Lucie Dudevant is always ‘Geoge Sand’. . . we think today of ‘George Eliot’ and never consider Mary Ann Evans to be Mary Ann Evans” (262). Judd attributes such endurance of “George Eliot” to the mere “faults” and “habits” of modern critics and publishers (262) and decides to use “Mary Ann Evans” instead of “George Eliot” throughout her essay to demonstrate the ways in which Mary Ann Evans used the male pseudonym to promote her social and moral authority in the public sphere. Rosemarie Bodenheimer also observes that the name of George Eliot is “the one that has proven the most enduring, the one that did not fade away once the gender and identity of the author became known” (“A Woman of Many Names” 20). While both Judd and Bodenheimer recognized the unusual persistence of “George Eliot” in modern critical naming practices compared to other Victorian women writers, they do not offer a satisfactory answer to this question.
Yet, “George Eliot”’s tenacity as well as “Currer Bell”’s disappearance can be traced back to the nineteenth-century naming practices by periodicals. That is, a diacritical reading of these two names in periodical reviews will be helpful in figuring out the answer to this question. As noted already, “Currer Bell” and “George Eliot” were continually marketed as official author names for their books during their life. Most Victorian periodicals respected and followed such naming practices even after their identities had been revealed. Yet, the biggest difference between “Currer Bell” and “George Eliot” was their longevity in printed form. One name was short-lived and the other one long-lived in print. As Brontë died very young, she produced only three major novels during her lifetime – Jane Eyre, Shirley, and Villette – all published under the name of “Currer Bell.” Although George Eliot was only three years younger than Brontë, Eliot was able to write for twenty-five years longer than Brontë. Given that Eliot published all of her novels under the name of “George Eliot,” this pseudonym, repeatedly marketed for longer periods, was more likely to grow into a “rigid designator” than the short-lived “Currer Bell.” For “Currer Bell,” Charlotte's death served as an occasion for its discontinuance. Simply put, any name which has been marketed for longer periods of time is more likely to grow rigid than other names which have not.
“Rigid designators” is a key concept derived from the philosophy of language. Saul Kripke, a major proponent of the causal theory of proper names, argues in Naming and Necessity (1980) that a proper name is created by an initial baptismal act of naming for an object and continues to be used via chains of designation that directly link one user of the name to the next one. Opposing the descriptivist view of proper names held by Bertrand Russell, Kripke stresses the designative function of proper names and offers the term “rigid designators” (14–15). I apply this concept to George Eliot and Charlotte Brontë. While any alternative names would refer to the same person in all possible worlds, the most frequently used author name would become an identifying tag for each author in reality.
It was a well-known fact that Currer Bell, Ellis Bell, and Acton Bell were three distinct Brontë sisters by the time that Villette was published in 1853. Still, most periodicals marked the author of Villette as “Currer Bell” not as “Charlotte Brontë.” In April 1853, Westminster Review followed this naming convention:
Indeed, no more distinct characteristic of Currer Bell's genius can be named, than the depth of her capacity for all passionate emotions. Comparing “Villette” with “Ruth,” in this respect, we are comparing sunlight with moonlight, passion with affection; and there is no writer of our day, except George Sand, who possesses the glory and the power which light up the writings of Currer Bell. She has not the humour, so strong and so genial, of Mrs. Gaskell. . .. Nor has Currer Bell any tendency towards the graceful, playful, or fanciful. ([Lewes] 490)
Two interesting observations can be made about this review. First, “Currer Bell” was preferred over “Charlotte Brontë” as the proper name of the author for Villette. Second, different authorial characters / images were created by this periodical's different act of naming. While “Currer Bell” was constructed as “genius,” “Mrs. Gaskell” was noted for her mildness. This review comparing Gaskell's Ruth and Brontë’s Villette was, in fact, written by George Henry Lewes. Notably, Lewes named the author of Villette as “Currer Bell” throughout this essay. He knew who “Currer Bell” was in reality, but never mentioned her true name in this review. Instead, Lewes used female pronouns for “Currer Bell” and compared her genius with George Sand's.
In contrast, Lewes addressed the author of Ruth as “Mrs. Gaskell” whose humor is “strong” and “genial.” For Ruth, Lewes unreservedly revealed the biographical personage of its author by addressing her as “Mrs. Gaskell” from very early on in his review: “We wish to show how Mrs. Gaskell treats the subject, and in her exposition we follow, as she has followed, ordinary notions” (477). While Lewes had knowledge about both women writers’ identities, he divulged only “Mrs. Gaskell,” keeping Charlotte Brontë intact. Other periodicals followed the same naming practices for Brontë and Gaskell. Thus, “Currer Bell” operated as the only author name for Brontë during her lifetime. This review, in addition, shows how the feminine designation “Mrs. Gaskell” was already in circulation in the early 1850s despite her assumed anonymity during her early writing career. I will return to discuss this matter more fully later in the essay.
Likewise, George Eliot was referred to as “George Eliot” even after the revelation of her secret authorship for Adam Bede. John Chapman in the July 1860 Westminster Review essay on The Mill on the Floss bragged without modesty about his correct speculation about the gender of the author of Adam Bede but still addressed the author as “George Eliot.” As Lewes did with “Currer Bell” in the above review, Chapman used female pronouns for “George Eliot”: “[W]hatever may have been George Eliot's motive in shrinking from personally gathering her abundant laurels, whether constitutional fastidiousness, over-refined taste, or real indifference, she could not possibly have decided upon a more efficient disguise than that of the clerical character” (24). Other periodicals followed the same mixed practice of naming the author as “George Eliot” but modifying the male pseudonym with female pronouns. Even if some of these periodicals marked George Eliot as “the authoress” to denote her gender more explicitly,Footnote 3 “George Eliot” functioned as a legitimate author name for most Victorian critics. This way, both “Currer Bell” and “George Eliot” appeared in print as the only author name for Brontë and Eliot during their lifetime.
However, deaths became a historical turning point for their author names by raising a social demand for obituaries and biographies. I shall compare the receptions of their posthumous names in periodicals by reading obituaries as well as critical responses to the first biographies of the two authors. I will demonstrate how death served as a crucial occasion where a significantly different naming pattern appeared in the critical practices for the two women authors. On April 7, 1855, the Examiner issued the following obituary for Charlotte Brontë:
On Saturday, March 31st, 1855, died at Haworth Parsonage, Yorkshire, CHARLOTTE, wife of the REV. ARTHUR BELL NICHOLLS. Strangers knew her through the fame she had earned by her writings; but her friends forgot the genius of ‘CURRER BELL’ in the greater qualities of the woman. In proportion to the strong love borne to her while living is the bitter regret caused by her death. (215)
This obituary highlighted the biographical person of “Charlotte Brontë” instead of the authorial identity of “Currer Bell.” The death of the author created a division between private and public self for Brontë and one was quickly preferred over the other – that is, Currer Bell's genius was easily superseded by Charlotte Brontë’s womanhood. It was and had to be as a woman that her value was recognized by her friends, not as a genius writer. Here, the long-used author name was forgotten as obsolete or not good enough to acknowledge the author's private self, her womanhood.
This critical behavior stood in contrast with the continuance of “George Eliot” as the signifier for both the author and the woman after her death. The Times issued its obituary entitled “George Eliot” on December 24, 1880, only two days after the death of the author: “A great English writer has suddenly passed away. ‘George Eliot,’ to give her the name by which Mrs. Cross was known wherever the English language is spoken or English literature is prized, died on Wednesday evening, after only three days’ illness” (9). Unlike in the case of Brontë, the Times definitively chose “George Eliot” over “Mrs. Cross” as the proper signifier for the author because “George Eliot” already became a designative name for her in the publishing world of “English literature.”
Throughout this obituary, the Times referred to the author as “George Eliot” not only to emphasize her intellectual properties – “the life of George Eliot is, as we have said, little more than the history of her literary activity” (9) – but also to mention a few biographical facts or traits about her: “For the biography of George Eliot few materials exist. . .. Marian Evans – whom all the world knew as ‘George Eliot’ – was born, we believe, in Warwickshire. . .” (9). While bringing up Eliot's earlier maiden name “Marian Evans” to mark her birth at Warwickshire, this obituary writer stressed once again that “George Eliot” was the name that this author was known to the whole world. The Times continued to capitalize on “George Eliot” as a marker for both the person and the writer until the end of this essay: “the friends of George Eliot have long recognized her rare and commanding gifts both of intellect and character” (9).
Likewise, the Saturday Review, on January 1, 1881, published its obituary entitled “George Eliot.”
MRS. CROSS was so little known by the name which she had recently acquired that it is convenient to speak of her by her chosen literary designation as George Eliot. It happens, by an odd coincidence, that a great French writer had many years before assumed a similar disguise. There can be little doubt that one of George Eliot's motives in taking the name of a man was to puzzle readers and critics. The partial success of the experiment, though the mystery was soon removed, illustrated the peculiar character of her genius. (12)
Just like the Times, the Saturday Review decided to use the well-known author name “George Eliot” instead of her “recently acquired” legal name “Mrs. Cross.” This reviewer formed an interesting analogy between George Eliot and George Sand to link their similar pseudonyms to their peculiar genius. Just like the case of Currer Bell whose genius was compared to George Sand's in the Westminster Review article written by George Henry Lewes, “George Eliot” also received great compliments of being paralleled with another female pseudonym George Sand. Although both “Currer Bell” and “George Eliot” were thus constructed as “genius” by periodical reviews, the former's image of genius was soon to be replaced by the feminine image of Charlotte Brontë.
This disparity in the critical naming practices for Brontë and Eliot after their deaths has intensified after the publication of their first biographies. While it was after the publication of Gaskell's Life that “Currer Bell” was fully transformed into “Charlotte Brontë,” “George Eliot” became further rigidified as the one and only identifying name tag for the author over the course of the late nineteenth century. Margaret Harris, in comparing George Eliot with Currer Bell, notes that “It is notable that [George Eliot] continues to be known by her pseudonym, while Charlotte Brontë and her sisters quickly passed from the anonymity provided by their pen-names. Elizabeth Gaskell published The Life of Charlotte Brontë in 1857, but it was George Eliot's Life that her widower John Cross ‘arranged and edited’ for publication in 1885” (131). In short, “George Eliot” firmly remained as part of the title of her biography whereas “Charlotte Brontë” replaced “Currer Bell” in the title of her biography.
I take a closer look at this linkage between biographies and the institutionalization of author names. My research shows that “Currer Bell” gradually turned into “Charlotte Brontë” after the publication of Gaskell's biography in 1857, whereas “George Eliot” survived two biographical turns in 1883 and 1885 by not allowing her alternative proper names such as “Marian Evans” and “Mary Ann Evans” to overwrite her famous authorial identity.
Gaskell's The Life of Charlotte Brontë played a significant role in turning “Currer Bell” to “Charlotte Brontë,” not only through its book title but also through its project of recovering Brontë’s proper femininity. Through this biography, “Charlotte Brontë” could emerge as a feminine proper name separated out from the coarse and immoral “Currer Bell” often touted in many periodical comments even after her death. According to Linda Peterson, the Life was a project conceived by Charlotte's closest friend Ellen Nussey who urged Charlotte's husband Arthur Nicholls to “authorize a biography in order to refute errors in fact and judgment that were circulating in the obituaries” (134). To defend Charlotte against further ignominy of impropriety and coarseness, Gaskell erased all improper materials from Charlotte's letters provided by Nussey and stressed “Brontë’s exemplary domesticity” throughout her biography (135). One of Gaskell's strategies for achieving this goal was to divide her subject into two different but compatible categories of the author and the woman, adopting what Peterson calls a “parallel currents” model: “This masterful biography constructed the woman writer in terms of a ‘parallel currents’ model: ‘her life as Currer Bell, the author; her life as Charlotte Brontë, the woman.’ It separated the identity of the author from that of the woman” (132). “Currer Bell” had to be renamed as “Charlotte Brontë” to shake off the former's image of masculinity and immorality. The much denunciated author “Currer Bell” was thus reinvented as the amiable, feminine, dutiful daughter and sister “Charlotte Brontë” in the biography.
Indeed, after the Life was published, most reviewers changed their critical naming practices for the author from “Currer Bell” to “Charlotte Brontë” and paid more attention to Brontë’s quality as a woman than as an author. In June 1857, the National Magazine issued a review of the Life with the title “Charlotte Brontë.”
It is a pregnant fact, indeed, that a writer, one of the most original, powerful, and popular of her day, stands out from the rest of the world still more by her life than by her genius. The reader of these volumes will find it more possible to forget Jane Eyre and Lucy Snowe than this small still woman, with her indomitable soul; her quiet self-denying heroism, both active and passive; her strong, but not stubborn will; her warm and generous, but steady and consistent feelings. Her genius was brilliant, but her soul shone, we think, with a fuller light than that which through her writings has flashed upon the world. (76)
The magazine urged readers to turn their attention from Currer Bell the genius writer to Charlotte Brontë the “heroic” woman whose will was “strong” but not “stubborn” and whose feelings were “warm,” “generous,” “steady,” and “consistent.” It asserted that anyone who reads this biography would take more interest in “Charlotte Brontë” the creator than in her literary creations such as Jane Eyre and Lucy Snowe. By emphasizing the feminine qualities of “Charlotte Brontë,” the magazine successfully separated out the biographical person of Charlotte Brontë from the masculine writer Currer Bell. Later, this reviewer even exclaimed, “[W]hat a new idea is given of the masculine-minded reckless writer of Jane Eyre, when we hear of her quietly shedding tears of grieved feeling over a harsh criticism in the Times newspaper!” (78). This sentence illustrates the process in which a new image of the author was successfully created through the social discourse led by Victorian critics. That is, the former “Currer Bell” known to be masculine and harsh turned out to be a mere girl who would be heartbroken to hear her works criticized by other people. Such a feminine image of Charlotte Brontë overrode the masculine writing of Currer Bell in this review.
In the same month, the Eclectic Review opened its review of the Life with even stronger biographical focus on Charlotte Brontë than the National Magazine:
This is one of the saddest lives we have ever read. We opened it with great curiosity to discover how it was that the daughter of an obscure Yorkshire clergyman had been able to learn enough about human nature to write three such remarkable fictions as “Jane Eyre,” “Shirley,” and “Villette;” but before we had read many pages we became far more interested in the fate of the woman than in the discipline and development of the authoress: the genius of Currer Bell was forgotten in the sorrows and struggles of Charlotte Brontë. And now that we have finished the strange, sad story, we have no heart for mere literary criticism; we must lay aside her books, and leave their brilliant excellences uneulogized, and their scarcely less brilliant faults uncensured: others may criticize her writings – we are unable to think of anything but her life. (630)
The Eclectic Review confessed that it became more interested in the personal fate of the woman Charlotte Brontë than in the literary development of the genius Currer Bell after reading Gaskell's Life. The Review was so infatuated with this woman that it was determined to leave all her creations behind and concentrate on her life story. No more was it necessary to give literary criticism to her works as her life story was so unique. Here, once again, the previously formed character of Currer Bell as genius writer was easily superimposed by the image of Charlotte Brontë as woman.
All these biographical turns testify to what Miriam Elizabeth Burstein calls “the nineteenth century's obsession with the Brontë s not as authors, but as women” (177). Burstein argues that Charlotte's “Biographical Notice” along with Gaskell's Life had affected the mid-nineteenth-century critical responses to the Brontës. While the former text “introduced a biographical focus that shaped all subsequent discussion of the text,” the latter work “consolidated. . . the Victorian interest in reading the Brontë s through a biographical lens” (175). As Burstein points out, Brontë biographies would soon overwrite all Brontë criticisms.
In another example, Blackwood's Edinburgh Magazine entitled its review of the Life as “Currer Bell” instead of “Charlotte Brontë” but ended up identifying Charlotte Brontë with her heroine Jane Eyre. E. S. Dallas, the writer of this review, denounced “Mrs. Gaskell” for inserting unnecessary details about Charlotte's growth as a woman in the biography which he saw as unrelated to Currer Bell's development as an author. To correct this error, Dallas tracked down the literary merits of “Currer Bell.” However, he followed the same “parallel currents” model held up by Gaskell the biographer by marking Brontë’s authorial self as “Currer Bell” on the one hand and by addressing her private self as “Charlotte Brontë” on the other hand.
In The Professor, however, as in Villette, and in Jane Eyre, she carries out her favourite idea of a heroine. In the general outline of character she is herself, in fact, her own heroine. She purposely made her heroines plain, if not ugly. . .. Full of strange fancies, morbid likings and dislikes, the heroine – the double of Miss Brontë – was the most matter-of-fact person in the world. . .. A good little woman, no doubt. But what was there so attractive about her? How was this humdrum little creature – this Frances Henri, this Lucy Snowe, this Jane Eyre, this Charlotte Brontë – raised into a heroine of romance? She was not only attractive, she was fascinating, because she had an eye which nothing could escape. . .. Powers of observation so acute had. . . a fascination like the eye of a basilisk. . .. (91–92)
Dallas associated the plain but powerful character of Jane Eyre with her creator. “Miss Brontë” intentionally created Jane Eyre as her double who carries the same traits as herself. Not only did Dallas call the author “Miss Brontë” but he also identified the author with her fictional characters by putting together their names in a row – “this Frances Henri, this Lucy Snowe, this Jane Eyre, this Charlotte Brontë.” Dallas later claimed that “She [Charlotte Brontë] is herself, in fact, her own heroine” (92). In this review, “Currer Bell”’s authorship all summed up into Brontë’s romantic heroines that were mere reflections of herself.
These Victorian receptions of Gaskell's Life were a signal for the biographical shift to Brontë criticism which has continued until the mid-twentieth century. According to Elizabeth Langland, Gaskell's Life “advanced an image of Charlotte Brontë as a model of Victorian womanhood” and this biographical criticism predominated Brontë criticism until the early 1960s (394). Carol Bock more minutely traces the history of biographical criticism of Charlotte Brontë from mid-Victorian period up until the late 1970s. Bock shows how Victorian critics, after the publication of Gaskell's Life, came to identify the storyteller of Brontë’s novels with the author Charlotte Brontë by “[referring] indiscriminately to Jane Eyre or Charlotte Brontë as though they did not know the difference between a novelist and a first-person narrator” (28). This critical tendency facilitated what Bock calls “the confessional tradition” in Brontë criticism (32). And, as I have demonstrated so far, Victorian print media set the stage for such biographical criticisms by reconstructing “Currer Bell” as “Charlotte Brontë.”
While the biographical name of “Charlotte Brontë” supplanted the author name of “Currer Bell” after the huge success of Gaskell's biography, “George Eliot” firmly kept its place as the sanctioned author name without losing its designative force after the publication of two early biographies of George Eliot. One is Mathilde Blind's George Eliot, published in 1883 as part of John Ingram's “Eminent Women Series.” The other is The Life of George Eliot, arranged by her short-term husband John Cross, published in 1885. While contemporary reviewers often reverted to Eliot's maiden names such as “Marian Evans” and “Mary Ann Evans” to follow the earlier part of her life in the biographies, they all returned to “George Eliot” at the end of their essays, helping to perpetuate “George Eliot” as the only designation for the author. As Susan Bernstein notes, Blind's biography was “the first biography of Eliot” (105). Though lesser known than Cross's biography to today's critics, Blind's biography enabled contemporary reviewers to appreciate the biography of one eminent woman writer written by another like Gaskell's Life. In October 1883, the British Quarterly Review gave out these commentaries to Blind's biography:
Miss Mathilde Blind deeply sympathizes with George Eliot. She has spared no pains to make a coherent and attractive narrative; she has ‘interviewed’ Miss Evan's [sic] brother and some of her early friends, and has thus succeeded in presenting us with a complete biography; interspersing her account with many incisive criticisms. Occasionally she carries her sympathy almost to the point of excess, particularly in the attempt directly to justify George Eliot's relations with Mr. G. H. Lewes. . .. Miss Blind's style of tracing the literary result to the experience and life of the author is very attractive. (“Eminent Women Series” 473)
This review took turns between “George Eliot” and “Miss Evans” in referring to the subject of the biography. While it was for the author “George Eliot” that Blind felt deep sympathy, it was the woman “Miss Evans” that the biographer sought to retrieve through her interviews with Eliot's private circles. The review, however, did not use “Miss Evans” in marking her illegal relationship with Lewes. Instead, it returned to “George Eliot” in referring to the private identity of the author. While praising Blind's biographical methods overall, this review faulted Blind for overusing her sympathy to defend the author's private choice.
Yet, only a few months earlier, the Academy rather depreciated the value of Blind's biography in its review entitled “George Eliot”: “[I]t must be confessed that one lays down this study of George Eliot with some disappointment” (286). Unlike the British Quarterly Review, the Academy regretted that Blind gave “fewer glimpses into George Eliot's personal relations” (286). While acknowledging that it was informative to know about “the kindly encouragement afforded to Marian Evans” (286) by her early intellectual friends at Coventry, the Academy still deplored that Blind had not delved into Eliot's private relationship with George Henry Lewes as well as her short married life with John Cross.
[People] will be still more wishful to discover what new light is shed upon the peculiar bonds that linked the clever, volatile George Henry Lewes with a woman who was his superior by so many degrees. . .. Again, many will be desirous of ascertaining more about the second domestic connexion formed by the novelist shortly before her premature death. But on these points Miss Blind just repeats information of which we are already possessed. Mr. Cross has but a line or two at the end of the volume; and we are not told whether the account of his wife which he promised to the world is in progress. The episode of George Eliot's informal union with Lewes is passed over in a slight account which will cheat the scandal-lover of his quest. . .. (286)
Just like the British Quarterly Review, the Academy adopted Eliot's maiden name “Marian Evans” in introducing the author's early life but used “George Eliot” in referring to her scandalous life with “volatile George Henry Lewes.” Despite its strong curiosity for the private part of George Eliot's life, the reviewer refrained from using any of her maiden names. This was so different from the case of Charlotte Brontë whose private identity as woman was instantly separated out from her public identity as author right after her death. Anyhow, in most reviews for Blind's biography, “George Eliot” appeared most frequently as the author name.
The same was true for Cross's biography published later. As this much anticipated biography mostly consisted of Eliot's own letters and diaries, it raised disappointment and acceptance at the same time. With few guiding commentaries about the subject, Cross's biography often failed to rouse or satisfy people's curiosity about Eliot's private life. The Wesleyan-Methodist Magazine in April 1885 issued an article entitled “George Eliot” that evaluated Cross's biography in a negative way.
In many respects expectation will be disappointed by the Life of George Eliot. Mr. Cross gives us a bundle of letters instead of a portrait. On the most crucial question in George Eliot's life he is altogether silent. The result is a volume of some interest, but in no sense a biography. Vicious as was Mr. Froude's method, he has given us Carlyle, ‘warts and all.’ But this excessive reticence of Mr. Cross leaves George Eliot just where she was before this book was published. (271)
The magazine was quite disappointed by this biography since “Mr. Cross” failed to give a portrait of George Eliot's private life, the essence of all biographies. Comparing it with Froude's unrestrained biography on Carlyle, Cross's biography could hardly be called a biography. In the midst of these negative commentaries, the magazine still called the biographee “George Eliot.”
Likewise, John Chapman in his July 1885 Westminster Review article criticized Cross's biographical method.
The first few words of this programme are liable to raise hopes destined only to speedy disappointment. A full collection of George Eliot's letters, with extracts from her journals and private memoranda – a collection arranged in proper order, and linked together almost into a narrative by the discreet adjunction of a few explanatory notes – what could be more desirable? It would be preferable even to an autobiography. . .. But alas! this simple reproduction of old letters, with their faded ink and yellowish-tinged paper, is very far from the “particular method” adopted by Mr. Cross. He has “pruned” the precious relics in his hands – pruned them of everything that either seemed irrelevant to his own purpose, or that his wife, according to his judgment, would have wished to be omitted. He tells us, with something like complacency, that no single letter has been printed in its entirety!. . . we cannot hinder the melancholy reflection that the very passages which the author of a correspondence is likely to expunge, are precisely those which would be of most interest to posterity. And if this be true of autobiographers in general, how much more so of George Eliot! (162)
Chapman suspected that “Mr. Cross” expunged all important materials from Eliot's letters, preventing readers from constructing a right sense of the private character of George Eliot. Given that George Eliot was an author very susceptible to literary criticism, “Mr. Cross” had to display Eliot's correspondence as it was without such “pruning.” Chapman especially resented the fact that Cross did not copy any of her letters concerning the most interesting part of her life including her early religious revolt as well as “her connection with THE WESTMINSTER REVIEW” (163). Having had once enjoyed a close friendship with George Eliot, Chapman even went so far as to claim that “no reader of her novels will believe that she was such a lamb as this correspondence would depict her. ‘A little more wickedness, if you please!’ is what we are tempted to call for” (163).Footnote 4 In spite of many private evidence offered by her only legal husband, the author remained as impenetrable “George Eliot” in this review.
Still, other periodicals like the Athenaeum praised Cross's new method of biography- writing that presented the author's first-hand materials as they were with the least editorial intervention – “These long-expected volumes have been compiled with great tact. Mr. Cross has aimed at making them a self-revelation of his wife's career and character, and he has been for the most part successful in the discharge of this difficult undertaking” (145). The Athenaeum further approved such arrangements as a good way to illuminate the author's own thoughts and feelings about her life and works: “The novel method of extracts arranged in order of time tells the tale spontaneously, and George Eliot the woman stands forth revealed to the world in all the strength and refinement of her intellect, in all the clinging trustfulness of her moral and emotional nature” (145). Here, it is “George Eliot the woman” – an expression of oxymoron – that appealed to the reader. Unlike the case of Charlotte Brontë, “George Eliot” was still used to mark her womanhood.
While most reviewers of Cross's biography conveniently skipped George Eliot's private relationship with George Henry Lewes, focusing either on the biographer's editing techniques or on the biographee's literary achievements overall, the conservative Saturday Review made a pause to offer a distinct criticism against Eliot's conduct as a woman.
One other not very pleasant subject we may as well mention at once and get over. For Mr. Cross's treatment of the connexion between Mary Ann Evans and George Henry Lewes we have no blame, and indeed very little comment; he has got himself out of a difficult situation very well. George Eliot's own attitude towards her conduct is briefly but significantly exhibited here, and simply condenses into little the curious paradox (some cynical people say the amusing inconsistency) of a woman who for years inculcated the sternest submission of inclination to duty in her books, and practically illustrated her principles by living all the time with another woman's husband. . .. [W]e shall only say that, when third persons speak of “Mrs. Lewes,” of “husband,” of “wife,” and so forth, in reference to this connexion, they not only debase the moral currency, but, taking the matter out of debatable points, endorse a deliberate literary and historical falsification. It is no more true that the author of Adam Bede was Mrs. Lewes than it is true that the author of Adam Bede was Mr. Liggins. (“George Eliot's Life” 181–82)
The Saturday Review in this passage showed some interesting dynamics in naming George Eliot. It first used one of Eliot's earlier maiden names “Mary Ann Evans” to allude to her private “connexion” with George Henry Lewes but soon reverted back to “George Eliot” to divulge a literary irony of how the author's stern morality in her works belied her own conduct in private life. The Review objected to any person's address to George Eliot as “Mrs. Lewes” as such reference would not only contradict the current social morale but also commit a serious misattribution of her literary works. Just as “Mr. Liggins” could not become the author of Adam Bede, “Mrs. Lewes” would not serve as the rightful author name for Eliot's novels. That is, calling George Eliot “Mrs. Lewes” would be as wrong as putting the con artist's name “Mr. Liggins” on the cover of Eliot's novel.
This was one of the harshest and the most conservative reviews on George Eliot after her death. Although the Review recognized George Eliot as a great author, it debunked the unstable correspondence between her biographical self as a fallen woman and her authorial self as a moral instructor. Rejecting both “Mary Ann Evans” and “Mrs. Lewes” who had an illegal liaison with a married man, the conservative magazine settled on the name “George Eliot” to walk a safe moral ground. Here, “George Eliot” became the only author name morally sanctioned by the conservative magazine. This whole process forms a stark contrast with Charlotte Brontë whose former identity of “Currer Bell” was erased after her death. The same cleansing process could not occur to George Eliot, due to her ignominious scandal. While Charlotte Brontë could turn into a feminine image by losing her negative qualities as Currer Bell, the same separation of the author and the woman was neither possible nor desirable for George Eliot due to her already contaminated femininity. Thus, her pen name remained the safest way to mark her authorship.
In addition, the Review’s earlier vacillation between “Mary Ann Evans” and “George Eliot” anticipates and echoes modern biographers’ concern about what to call George Eliot in different stages of her life. For instance, Rosemarie Bodenheimer writes: “the play between ‘Mary Ann / Marian Evans / Lewes’ and ‘George Eliot’ must concern everyone who writes about this woman and artist of many names, not least when it comes to making decisions about what to call her. I use George Eliot when the working novelist is in question, and I follow the lead of her signatures in naming her for any given period of her personal life” (xvii). In this strategy, “Mrs. Lewes” can be one of her official author names as Eliot signed herself thus in her private letters during her stay with George Henry Lewes.
So far, I have compared the critical naming practices for “Currer Bell” and “George Eliot” before and after their deaths, in an attempt to address the question of why one pseudonym has stuck while the other one has disappeared. While Gaskell's biography served as a significant site for changing Currer Bell's masculine authorial identity into Charlotte Brontë’s feminine personal identity, Cross's biography failed to do so by merely copying Eliot's own words and views about herself and her works. Even though Blind's biography made a significant contribution to Eliot criticism by offering a female point of view about Eliot's life, its adulation was often denounced as too facile. Whereas “Currer Bell” could become “Charlotte Brontë” through Gaskell's active intervention, “George Eliot” endured its fame as “George Eliot” with no one definitively proper feminine name inserted by either biographer and approved by Victorian critics.
Such different Victorian receptions of each woman author's biography, along with different degrees of persistence for each pseudonym in print, affected not only late Victorians’ but also modern critics’ naming practices for Charlotte Brontë and George Eliot. In other words, the immediate posthumous naming acts in the obituaries and in the reviews of early biographies set the stage for how these women writers continue to be named. Indeed, one can see how predominantly “Charlotte Brontë” appeared as posthumous author names in print media throughout the rest of the nineteenth century. Likewise, “George Eliot” marked every title page of periodical reviews written after her death. Unlike “Currer Bell,” “George Eliot” failed to be rewritten into a proper female identity. As such, “George Eliot” has remained as the only designation for the author in modern criticism.
Now I turn to trace the critical history of “Mrs. Gaskell” to show how such naming practice contributed to building up a feminized authorial image for Elizabeth Gaskell, as a contrast to Charlotte Brontë and George Eliot. Granted that an author's social character is determined by the form of an author's name used in the discursive field, “Mrs. Gaskell” best illustrates how such process actually occurred. Here, the married title “Mrs.” played a definitive role in characterizing Gaskell's authorship. As Gérard Genette points out, any surname attached to a woman writer can have a huge impact on readers, and this is more so for a married woman as she “must choose among her father's name, her husband's name, or some combination of the two. . . many careers of women of letters are punctuated with these onymous variations that reveal marital, existential, or ideological variations” (40). Although Gaskell did not “choose” her married title as her author name, she was soon designated and addressed as “Mrs. Gaskell” by the Victorian publishing world after her initial anonymity for Mary Barton was lifted. She had previously adopted such strange pseudonyms as “Cotton Mather Mills” and “Stephen Berwick,” yet, as soon as her married status was known, she was instantly renamed as “Mrs. Gaskell.” Thus, “Mrs. Gaskell” became the most commonly used author name for Gaskell in the periodicals, especially after the publication of The Life of Charlotte Brontë, although this biography allowed her to have the first form of onymity “E. G. Gaskell” on its cover.
This married title continued to define her authorial identity before and after her death. All obituaries uniformly marked her name as “Mrs. Gaskell” and gave mixed reviews about her works. In December 1865, Macmillan's Magazine announced Gaskell's death through its obituary entitled “Mrs. Gaskell”: “Another of the writers I have known has passed away in the person of Mrs. Gaskell” (153). The Magazine asserted that any biography of Gaskell would not help to illuminate her literary works since she led a “more calm and less eventful” life compared to other women writers (154). This forms a contrast with other reviewers’ earlier enthusiasm over the biographies of Charlotte Brontë and George Eliot. The Magazine stressed how “Mrs. Gaskell” began to write as a mother to “drown the memory of a dead child” (154). While praising Gaskell's mild and feminine writing style, this reviewer noted a lack of depth in her characters compared to Brontë’s Jane Eyre and Eliot's Adam Bede. Readers could not learn about Gaskell's characters as they did about “the Père Goriot, or Colonel Newcome, or Jane Eyre, or Adam Bede” (154).
Likewise, the Saturday Review, a month earlier, made “the unexpected announcement of the death of Mrs. Gaskell” in its obituary column entitled “Mrs. Gaskell” (638). The Review criticized “one-sided” social views manifest in Mary Barton and commented that it was desirable for “Mrs. Gaskell” to abandon her earlier social aims to write for more sympathetic and appealing stories such as Cranford and Sylvia's Lovers. It chose Cranford as the work best representing Gaskell's feminine authorship and compared it with Austen's works: “Cranford is, in its way, the most perfect of Mrs. Gaskell's creations, and we do not hesitate to say that it is the most perfect little story of its kind that has been published since the days of Miss Austen” (638). With the repeated uses of the married title “Mrs. Gaskell,” all these obituary reviews reproduced Gaskell's image as a docile, womanly writer.
A decade later, this tendency has further intensified. Many periodicals connected Gaskell's literary merits with her married status as a domestic woman. George Barnett Smith, in his 1874 article “Mrs. Gaskell and Her Novels” published in the Cornhill magazine, first and foremost, praised Gaskell's talent as a dutiful domestic wife and mother:
[W]hilst at the same time, Mrs.Gaskell lacked none of those virtues which make home “the earthly paradise.” We have had several illustrious examples of women who never allowed their literary work to trench upon their domestic duties, conspicuous amongst these being the late Mrs. Somerville, and to the number must be added Mrs. Gaskell. No matter how eager she was to complete ventures which she had in hand, and which, as literary offspring always are, were exceedingly dear to her, it is interesting to know that she was much prouder of ruling her household well, which she did in the most admirable manner, than of all that she did in those writings which have made her name so justly popular. It is said that she had a peculiar tact in training her servants. . .. (192)
Smith added “Mrs. Gaskell” to the group of “illustrious examples” of women writers whose writing venture was not surpassed by their domestic duties. “Mrs. Gaskell” was one of these excellent domestic women who managed their households perfectly. Smith linked such domestic “tact” to her literary skill later, emphasizing her feminine qualities such as sympathy and earnestness: “But even a cursory perusal of her works will show that Mrs. Gaskell must have deeply studied most of the questions affecting her sex, that of female labour being perhaps the most paramount. Her sympathies were quick and ready. . . ” (192). While praising Gaskell as a “true observer” of human life, Smith surmised that her literary power derived from her role as a dutiful and sympathetic wife and mother.
Similarly, William Minto, in the review article “Mrs. Gaskell's Novels” published in Fortnightly Review in September 1878, defined “Mrs. Gaskell” as “pre-eminently a moralist in the sense of being a writer whose works touch the heart rather than the imagination or the philosophical intellect” (366-67). For Minto, “Mrs. Gaskell” carried no ambition higher than her reach:
No one would dream of ranking Mrs. Gaskell as a novelist beside Dickens or Thackeray, but she deserves a very high place among those who are comparatively unambitious in their efforts, and who, having a just measure of their own powers, succeed perfectly in what they undertake. She never attempted high flights, but pursued her way steadily and surely at a moderate elevation. Her style has not the magnificent reach of her friend, Charlotte Brontë; it is homely, as suited her subjects. It was natural that art such as hers, working earnestly within a definite field, without straining to get beyond it, and never wasting its strength against the precipices, should become more perfect as she went on. (368-69; my emphasis)
Here, the married title of “Mrs. Gaskell” is naturally linked with her “moderate” and “unambitious” writing skill. “Mrs. Gaskell” could not be put on the same pedestal as Dickens or Thackeray, nor could she be compared with her genius friend Charlotte Brontë, as her writing style was “homely.” Just like Smith in the Cornhill, Minto dwelt on the feminine quality of “Mrs. Gaskell” by calling her a moralist with sympathy and earnestness. These reviews reinforced Gaskell's image as a moderate, domestic writer by referring to her as “Mrs. Gaskell,” the wife and mother.
Gaskell's perpetuated image as a motherly and submissive Victorian woman writer continued into the twentieth-century criticism as represented by David Cecil's infamous metaphor of Gaskell as a dove in his book Early Victorian Novelists: Essays in Revaluation (1935).Footnote 5
Charlotte Brontë’s admirers do not think of her as Mrs. Nichols; George Eliot's admirers would wonder whom one meant if one referred to her as Mrs. Cross. But Elizabeth Cleghorn Stevenson is known to the world as Mrs. Gaskell. This is just as it should be. There is a great difference between her and her famous rivals, and this difference is fitly symbolized in the different form of name under which she elected to write. The outstanding fact about Mrs. Gaskell is her femininity. . .. though Charlotte Brontë and George Eliot are unmistakably women, they are not ordinary women. . .. In the placid dovecotes of Victorian womanhood, they were eagles. But we have only to look at a portrait of Mrs. Gaskell, soft-eyed, beneath her charming veil, to see that she was a dove. (207–08)
For Cecil, it is only natural that Gaskell should be called “Mrs. Gaskell” as she was the most “womanly” writer of all. Although Charlotte Brontë and George Eliot had married titles, those legal names would sound strange to the public ears as they were too extraordinary to be recognized as married women. In contrast, “Mrs. Gaskell” was an ordinary woman, a “dove” perfect for home. Many critics of later generations built on this remark to establish the critical convention of garnishing Gaskell's literary presence with the married title of “Mrs.”
This persistence of “Mrs. Gaskell” continued until modern biographical writings were released in the late 1970s. That Gaskell's letters became available only in 1966 with the title The Letters of Mrs. Gaskell demonstrates not only the same lack of interest in her life but also the same endurance of her fame as “Mrs. Gaskell” as practiced by Victorian print media. Winifred Gérin's Elizabeth Gaskell: A Biography published in 1976 was the first modern biography that made full use of Gaskell's letters and recovered her full name “Elizabeth Gaskell.” This late biographical turn for Gaskell can be contrasted with early and unceasing interest in the lives of Charlotte Brontë and George Eliot.
Still more stunning is the fact that major feminist critics of the late 1970s, despite their pioneering spirits of rediscovering forgotten women writers from the nineteenth-century England, rather followed the old convention of naming Gaskell as “Mrs. Gaskell” and thus helped to construct her image as a “motherly” writer. Such practice is found in many representative feminist works such as Ellen Moers’ Literary Women (1976), Elaine Showalter's A Literature of Their Own (1977) and Sandra Gilbert and Susan Gubar's Madwoman in the Attic (1979). Although Moers mentioned Gaskell several times throughout her book, it was mostly in relation to other supposedly more prominent women writers such as George Sand, Jane Austen, and Charlotte Brontë. Moers claimed in the preface that she rediscovered “Mrs. Gaskell” who “had once bored [her]” through her project and praised Mary Barton as one of the earliest industrial novels of England. In the meantime, Elaine Showalter argued that Gaskell “got preferential treatment” as a writing-mother who had been considered “normal” in her own times as opposed to other unmarried or childless women writers (70). After discussing Gaskell's “normal” status as a married / motherly writer, Showalter declared that “Mrs. Gaskell became the heroine of a new school of motherly fiction,” (71) turning the author into the symbol of a “motherly” fiction.
Likewise, Gilbert and Gubar offered little insight on Gaskell while making an extensive survey of other Victorian women writers. They made only “four mentions of ‘Mrs.’ Gaskell and one brief reference to Gaskell's Mary Barton, each only in relation to another woman writer. . .” (Davis 515). At one point, Gilbert and Gubar described “Mrs. Gaskell” as a domestic novelist who had once wished that George Eliot had been Mrs. Lewes in her letter (484). A decade later, Nancy Armstrong still kept the same practice in Desire and Domestic Fiction: “Although Mrs. Gaskell includes political material in its most topical form, history virtually disappears from her novel as class conflict comes to be represented as a matter of sexual misconduct and a family scandal” (178).
These cases clearly demonstrate how the married title “Mrs. Gaskell” is closely related to the ways in which her literary works have been received by early feminist critics. Gaskell's construct image as a motherly writer further prompted feminist critics to depreciate the author as a conservative anti-feminist. As Deanna L. Davis argues in her 1992 article “Feminist Critics and Literary Mothers: Daughters Reading Elizabeth Gaskell,” Gaskell could not have the same appeal to feminist critics as Charlotte Brontë or George Eliot due to the “widespread feminist view of Gaskell as decisively contained and dominated by Victorian sexual ideology” (509). Gaskell's nurturing femininity as a mother often led the critics to read her heroines as passive rather than active figures controlled by Victorian gender ideology. That is, Gaskell criticism has been at the hands of feminist “daughters” whose attitudes towards their literary “mothers” have often changed depending on their own feminist goals and agenda. The same feminine value has been rendered positive or negative depending on each critic's view on the figure of the mother: “Thus the root of both the feminist neglect and the feminist celebration of Elizabeth Gaskell is the equivocal status of the mother within feminism and feminist criticism themselves” (Davis 507).
Similarly, Deirdre D'Albertis questions the history of feminist literary criticism itself, asking why Gaskell has “fared so poorly in feminist accounts of women's literary culture in the Victorian period?” (Dissembling Fiction 16). Just like Davis, D'Albertis attributes its cause to the founding literary academy of the late 1970s: “the values affirmed by pioneering feminist readers have since become institutionalized in histories of nineteenth-century women writers” (16). D'Albertis criticizes Showalter's as well as Gilbert and Gubar's strategic separation of female writers and raises doubts about the “traditional” approach of their feminist criticism that prizes defiance and anger instead of care and nurturance. Gaskell does not fit into this feminist critical model, as she is too “normal” or too “motherly” (169). While her “maternal” novels such as Cranford and Wives and Daughters have been criticized as too feminine, her social-problem novels such as Mary Barton and North and South have been dismissed for merely copying male writers’ topics. While the motherhood / womanhood of “Mrs. Gaskell” was unanimously celebrated by conservative Victorian critics, it fared not so well in modern criticism, especially among feminist scholars.
Although later feminist critics have played a crucial role in transforming Gaskell's identity from “Mrs. Gaskell” to “Elizabeth Gaskell” by paying more attention to the diverse aspects of her writing career, not everyone has settled on the question of what to call her. In her more recent essay, D'Albertis offers “E. C. Gaskell” as a proper critical name, instead of “Elizabeth Gaskell.” The rationale is that “E. C. Gaskell” was the most frequently signed name in her letters: “We have reason to believe, however, that she would have signed herself neither as Elizabeth Gaskell nor as Mrs. Gaskell had it not been for the marketing concerns of publishers” (“The Life and Letters of E. C. Gaskell” 14). Here, D'Albertis sees an author's signature as an important element in deciding an author's proper critical name: an author's signature is “a form of address, a way of announcing herself to a world beyond any essential self” (15). This is similar to the strategy adopted by Rosemarie Bodenheimer who decided to use a different authorial signature at a different stage of George Eliot's writing career. However, this does not change the fact that Gaskell was most frequently perceived as “Mrs. Gaskell” by critics during her life time and evaluated as such for quite a long time even after her death. And another important fact is that most critics today take up “Elizabeth Gaskell” as the most legitimate author name for Gaskell, as the title of the recent volume of the Cambridge Companion to Elizabeth Gaskell suggests.
All these controversies have their deep roots in the Victorian periodicals’ naming and construction of Gaskell. Victorian reviewers played a powerful role not only in defining social characters of Victorian women writers but also in forming our perceptions of Victorian female authorship. The initial reception of Gaskell by the first round of readers set the stage for the later generations’ assessment of her character and identity as author. Her feminine image as “Mrs. Gaskell” had been so deeply inscribed in the minds of so many people, it survived modern critical turns, even the revolutionary feminist criticism of the 1970s.
This brings us to the politics of naming – how important it is to name an author, how certain critical habits and culture define and characterize authors in specific ways in society. As a container of literary and discursive significance, an author's name can work as a critical framework for literary practitioners. Therefore, it is important to know how the history of an author's name is enmeshed with the history of literary criticism. Institutionalization of an author's name has influenced and shall influence our own critical models. That is why critical names matter.
