Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-z4zkx Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T07:58:50.350Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Shear-thinning mediation of elasto-inertial Taylor–Couette flow

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  24 March 2021

Tom Lacassagne*
Affiliation:
Flume, Department of Mechanical Engineering, University College London (UCL), London WC1E 7JE, UKIMT Lille Douai, Institut Mines-Télécom, Univ. Lille, Centre for Energy and Environment, F-59000 Lille, France
Neil Cagney
Affiliation:
School of Engineering and Materials Science, Queen Mary University of London, London E1 4NS, UK
Stavroula Balabani*
Affiliation:
Flume, Department of Mechanical Engineering, University College London (UCL), London WC1E 7JE, UK
*
†Email addresses for correspondence: tom.lacassagne@imt-lille-douai.fr, s.balabani@ucl.ac.uk
†Email addresses for correspondence: tom.lacassagne@imt-lille-douai.fr, s.balabani@ucl.ac.uk

Abstract

We study the shear-thinning mediation of elasto-inertial transitions in Taylor–Couette flow of viscoelastic polymer solutions. Two types of high molecular weight polymers are used at various concentrations and in water–glycerol solvents of various viscosities. This allows us to access a wide range of elastic numbers and effective shear-thinning indices. Conservative ramp-up (slow acceleration of the inner cylinder and subsequent increase in Reynolds number) and steady-state (constant rotation speed) experiments are performed, in which the flow is monitored continuously using flow visualisation. Depending on the shear-thinning and elastic properties of the working fluid, very different behaviours are observed. In almost constant-viscosity fluids (Boger fluids), or shear-thinning fluids with significant elasticity, the flow transitions from purely azimuthal Couette flow (CF) to a highly chaotic flow state referred to as elasto-inertial turbulence (EIT) via Taylor vortex flow (TVF) and elasto-inertial rotating spiral waves (RSW). When the degree of shear-thinning is increased and elasticity reduced, elastic waves or EIT may fade to a wavy Taylor vortex flow (WTVF) with increasing inertia. Significant shear-thinning leads to a delay in the onset of EIT. Remarkably, in some highly shear-thinning cases, even with a significant elasticity, elastic flow features (EIT, RSW) are completely suppressed, and the flow exhibits a ‘Newtonian-like’ transition sequence (CF–TVF–WTVF). Shear-thinning acts to modify, delay, or even completely suppress elasto-inertial behaviours (RSW, EIT), that would otherwise have existed in the absence of shear-thinning. It is, thus, possible to induce various hydrodynamic regimes by tuning the relative degrees of shear-thinning, elasticity and inertia.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2021. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Sketch of the test section and flow visualisation system.

Figure 1

Table 1.Polymer solutions and their rheological properties at $20\,^{\circ }\textrm {C}$. The sample labelling scheme is the following (ID column): XXiii-jj where XX is the polymer molecule used (N if no polymer); iii is the polymer concentration in ppm (empty if no polymer); and jj is the glycerol volume fraction in the solvent in volume $\%$.

Figure 2

Figure 2.Viscosity as a function of shear rate for polymer solutions (filled symbols for XG; open symbols for polyacrylamide (PAAM)) at various concentrations and in solvents of three different glycerol volume fractions: $25\,\%$ (triangles); $50\,\%$ (circles); and $72\,\%$ (squares). Expected solvent constant viscosities $\mu _s$ are derived from Volk & Kähler (2018) and plotted as dotted lines. The measured viscosity for the reference Newtonian case ($72\,\%$ glycerol in water) is represented by black crosses.

Figure 3

Figure 3.Here $G'$ (open symbols) and $G''$ (filled symbols) moduli for XG and PAAM solutions at various concentrations and in various glycerol water solvents.

Figure 4

Table 2.Experimental conditions for ramp-up experiments, and transition sequence reported. The samples rheological characterisation is reported in table 1.

Figure 5

Table 3.Experimental conditions: steady-state experiments. Here $\varGamma _0$ specifies the maximum non-dimensional acceleration rate used in the ramp-up leading to the recorded steady state.

Figure 6

Figure 4.Illustrative panel of observed flow maps and flow states. Panels (a–f) are space–time diagrams on ${\rm \Delta} t$ intervals of 3 to 15 s spanning the $10 < z/d < 15$ vertical region: (a) N72, $Re=120$; (b) N72, $Re=250$; (c) P500-72, $Re=110$; (d) P500-72, $Re=150$; (e) XG2000-50, $Re=52$; (f) P500-72, $Re=50$. Panels (g) and (h) illustrate typical spatial and temporal spectra, $\mathrm {FFT}_s$ and $\mathrm {FFT}_t$, obtained by FFT processing along the vertical and horizontal dashed lines in panels (a–e), respectively.

Figure 7

Figure 5.Summary of experiments in (a) $(Re/Re_0,1-n_e,El)$, (b) $(Re/Re_0,El)$ and (c) $(Re/Re_0,1-n_e)$ parameter spaces. Each path corresponds to a single ramp-up experiment. Each flow state is associated with a line colour according to the legend (colours online). Full lines report experiments from the present work, and dashed lines experiments from Cagney et al. (2020), performed in similar conditions (polymer batch, geometry, ramp-up protocol, flow visualisation method) on XG samples at various concentrations dissolved in a 25$\%$ glycerol in water solvent.

Figure 8

Figure 6.(a) Intensity signal, (b) flow map and (c) frequency map for the N72-1 experiment ($\bar {{El}}=0$, $\bar {n}_e=1$). In panel (a) and all subsequent similar panels, $i^*$ is the RMS grey level intensity of panel (b) along the $z/d$ dimension, scaled by its maximum value on the $Re$ range. The dashed line on panel (c) denotes the inner cylinder rotation frequency $f_{\varOmega }$. Here $f_{max}$ is the rotation frequency corresponding to ${Re}_{max}$. Vertical dotted lines shows the transitions between flow regimes.

Figure 9

Figure 7.(a) Intensity signal, (b) flow map (c) and frequency map for the P500-72-3 experiment ($\bar {{El}}=0.19$, $\bar {n}_e=0.96$). The dashed line on panel (c) denotes the inner cylinder rotation frequency. Vertical dotted lines denote the transitions between flow regimes.

Figure 10

Figure 8.(a) Intensity signal, (b) flow map (c) and frequency map for the XG1000-25-1 experiment ($\bar {{El}}=1.2, \bar {n}_e=0.58$). The dashed line on panel (c) denotes the inner cylinder rotation frequency. Vertical dotted lines denote the transitions between flow regimes. Note that the rotation frequency detected varies nonlinearly with $Re$, due to the shear-thinning behaviour (Cagney & Balabani 2019b).

Figure 11

Figure 9.(a) Intensity signal, (b) flow map (c) and frequency map for the XG1000-72-2 experiment ($\bar {{El}}=13$, $\bar {n}_e=0.71$). The dashed line on panel (c) denotes the inner cylinder rotation frequency. Vertical dotted lines denote the transition from CF to EIT. Note that the rotation frequency detected varies nonlinearly with $Re$, due to the shear-thinning behaviour, but this nonlinear trend is weaker than in figure 8(c), the shear-thinning index being here closer to 1.

Figure 12

Figure 10.(a) Intensity signal, (b) flow map(c) and frequency map for the XG200-50-3 experiment ($\bar {{El}}=0.14, \bar {n}_e=0.73$). The dashed line on panel (c) denotes the inner cylinder rotation frequency. Vertical dotted lines denote the transitions between flow states. Note that the rotation frequency detected varies nonlinearly with $Re$, due to the shear-thinning behaviour (Cagney & Balabani 2019b).

Figure 13

Figure 11.Steady-state recordings at constant $Re$ of successive RIB and WTVF states for the XG200-50 case ($\bar {{El}}=0.14$, $\bar {n}_e=0.73$). (a–c) Space–time diagrams over 50 s time spans. (d–f) Close-ups of the same flow maps on the first 5 s and in the central region (dashed rectangles). (g) Spatial spectrum and (h) temporal spectrum of the three steady-state experiments.

Figure 14

Figure 12.(a) Intensity signal, (b) flow map (c) and frequency map for the XG200-72-1 experiment ($\bar {{El}}=0.88$, $\bar {n}_e=0.85$). The dashed line on panel (c) denotes the inner cylinder rotation frequency. Vertical dotted lines denote the transitions between flow states. Note that the rotation frequency detected varies nonlinearly with $Re$, due to the shear-thinning behaviour (Cagney & Balabani 2019b).

Figure 15

Figure 13.(a) Intensity signal, (b) flow map and (c) frequency map for a highly elastic, highly shear-thinning fluid (XG2000-50-2 experiment, $\bar {{El}}=74$, $\bar {n}_e=0.56$). The dashed line on panel (c) denotes the inner cylinder rotation frequency. Vertical dotted lines denote the transitions between flow states. Note that the rotation frequency detected varies nonlinearly with $Re$, due to the shear-thinning behaviour. Panel (d) is a close-up of panel (b) in the SVF state.

Figure 16

Figure 14.Steady-state experiments in the SVF (S1), RSW (S2) and EIT (S3, S4) states, shown on ${\rm \Delta} t$ intervals (horizontal axis) (the S1 interval is larger in order to better describe the SVF state). Superscripts ‘$-$’ and ‘$+$’ in S1 denote upward and downward spiralling velocities, respectively.

Figure 17

Figure 15.Steady-state experiment (30 s) showing the transitional stage between RSW and EIT in highly elastic and shear-thinning XG2000-50 fluid, at $Re=79$: (a) reflected intensity; (b) binarised intensity map. Some of the numerous merging and splitting events of Taylor-vortices are highlighted by dashed circles, and the associated vortex drifting by dashed lines.

Figure 18

Figure 16.Two-dimensional FFT (time and space) of steady-state experiments for the highly elastic, highly shear-thinning fluid (XG2000-50-2 experiment, $\bar {{El}}=74$, $\bar {n}_e=0.56$) at (a) $Re=69$, (b) $Re=79$ and (c) $Re=152$ corresponding, respectively, to RSW, RSW transitioning to EIT, and EIT. Spectra are plotted in arbitrary units along a temporal frequency axis scaled by the inner cylinder rotation frequency $\varOmega /2{\rm \pi}$, and a spatial wavelength axis where the wavelength is scaled by the gap width $d$. Space-averaged and time averaged one-dimensional spectra are plotted in time-magnitude (blue) and space-magnitude (purple) planes, respectively. Vertical arrows are a guide to the eye showing peaks in both dimensions.

Figure 19

Figure 17.Critical Reynolds number value for the onset of EIT $Re_c^{EIT}$ as a function of the (a) averaged shear-thinning index and (b) elastic number. Marker colours on panels (a) and (b) indicate the values of $\bar {{El}}$ and $1-\bar {n}_e$, respectively. Vertical lines are plotted at $n_e=0.82$ and $\bar {{El}}=1$ on panels (a) and (b), respectively, and those threshold values are also reported on the colour map of the conjugate figure (panels (b) and (a), respectively) as horizontal tick marks with arrows. Finally, panel (c) reports the critical values of ${El}$ at the onset of EIT, ${El}_c$, as a function of the critical shear-thinning $1-n_e$ also at the onset. Here $\bar {{El}}=1$ and $\bar {n}_e=0.82$ thresholds are noted as horizontal and vertical dashed lines, respectively.

Figure 20

Figure 18.Shear-thinning versus elasticity parameter map in TCFs of polymeric solutions for the present study and literature experiments in the ($1-\bar {n}_e, \bar {{El}}$) parameter space. White symbols indicate reported EIT and black ones the absence of it, for $Re < Re_{max}$ as reported in table 4. The flow transition patterns observed in these studies are also reported in table 4.

Figure 21

Table 4.Flow transition patterns in shear-thinning and viscoelastic polymer or micellar solutions. Here N/A denotes quantities non-available or non-assessable from the available data.

Figure 22

Table 5.Experimental conditions: influence of ramp-up acceleration rate. Experiments are conducted for samples expected to exhibit different behaviours: Newtonian (N) figure 6; purely shear-thinning as described in figure 8 (ST) where elastic instabilities are suppressed by shear-thinning; purely elastic Boger fluid (E) (figure 7) with negligible shear-thinning; and shear-thinning dominated by elasticity (STE) figure 13. The superscript ‘*’ denotes experiments with $\varGamma _0 < 1$ also reported in table 2.

Figure 23

Figure 19.Flow maps of fastest (top row) to lowest (bottom row) ramp-up experiments for (a) a Newtonian fluid, N; (b) shear-thinning fluid with a Newtonian-like transition, ST; (c) purely elastic Boger fluid, E; (d) shear-thinning fluid with strong elasticity, STE. The fluid type (N, ST, E, STE), run index (A to E) and maximum non-dimensional acceleration rate $\varGamma _0$ are reported in each subpanel.

Figure 24

Figure 20.Values of critical Reynolds number for the onset of various flow states in the four investigated cases: Newtonian (N); shear-thinning with Newtonian-like transitions (ST); purely elastic Boger (E); and shear-thinning with elastic flow patterns (STE).

Supplementary material: File

Lacassagne et al. supplementary material

Lacassagne et al. supplementary material

Download Lacassagne et al. supplementary material(File)
File 210.6 KB