Over the past two decades, scholars have devoted increasing attention to Roman civil war literature and its poetics, from the vocabulary of nefas, paradox, and hyperbole to the pervasive imagery of the state as a body violated by its citizens. Thebes and especially the civil war between Oedipus’ sons became prominent lenses through which Romans explored their country's strife-ridden past.Footnote 1 Seneca's Phoenissae, however, has received comparatively little attention in this regard, often overshadowed by Statius’ epic Thebaid of the next generation. This paper investigates Seneca's contribution to the wider poetics of civil war through his expansion of the theme of incest, which Seneca uses to articulate civil war's most invasive, penetrative, and disintegrative effects. In particular, Seneca capitalizes on both the metaphorical potential of maternal violation and the eroticized imagery of Roman conquest to create disturbing points of contact between two generations of Jocasta's sons: the one who invaded her bed in the past, and the other who will soon invade his mother city. Seneca writes his Phoenissae to be an escalated return to the original sins of Oedipus’ incesta domus as another of Thebes’ native sons prepares to conquer his motherland.
Incest and Parental Crimes: Oedipus and Jocasta
Critics have long noted Seneca's focus on incest as the predominant crime of the Theban cycle.Footnote 2 Though we might expect Laius’ murder to be the crime from which civil war springs given the longstanding metaphorical association of parricide with civil strife in Roman thought,Footnote 3 Seneca's Phoenissae uniquely categorizes parricide as lower in the Theban hierarchy of crime.Footnote 4 Oedipus articulates a cursus of guilt on which parricide becomes a leue crimen (‘light accusation’) compared to incest with a fertile mother:Footnote 5
Name that unprecedented, wild, and unheard of deed that makes people shudder, that every age would deny had happened, that would put parricide to shame: I brought hands sprinkled with a father's blood into his bed, I accepted a greater sin as sin's reward. Light is my crime against my father: my mother was led into my bed, and lest that be too insignificant a sin, she came fertile: nature can bear no crime greater than this. But if something nevertheless is possible, we produced those who could do it.
While Oedipus notes that he can commit no fouler violation than fathering brothers on his mother, his comparative (maius) hints that there is more to come from the next generation:Footnote 6 in order for Polynices and Eteocles to live up to their father, they must surpass his maternal violation.Footnote 7
In one of the landmark articles of Seneca Tragicus, Elaine Fantham pondered the unusual imagery of Oedipus’ subsequent curse on his sons, his last speech in the play:Footnote 8
Nor is this enough. Something ought to happen, such that a sin after our own fashion occurs, one that would suit my marriage bed: give arms to your mother!
Why does Oedipus feel that violence against Jocasta (date arma matri) is a crime that would replay the sins of his marriage bed?Footnote 9 Fantham suggested a somewhat radical reading: that Oedipus exhorts his sons to violate Jocasta sexually'.Footnote 10 She goes on, however, to suggest that the Jocasta-focused second half of the play offers a completely different parent-child relationship than the one Oedipus envisions, one free of concerns about incest and preoccupied with traditionally maternal fears about impending fratricide.Footnote 11 And yet while fratricide looms large in any treatment of Eteocles and Polynices, I suggest that incest's suitability as a way of interpreting civil war's horrors is not limited to Oedipus’ imagination. Rather, Jocasta's appeals to her son and her description of the coming siege brim with sexually-charged language that links the sins of Oedipus’ bed to those of Polynices’ would-be violations.
Jocasta's opening monologue shows an awareness of her sinful past. Not only did she make sons guilty, she bore sons destined to surpass the previous generation's guilt:
Lucky Agave, she bore that horrifying crime with the hand that had committed it, and as a bloody Maenad carried the spoils of her shredded son; she committed the crime, but the wretch did not have to face it further. I am guilty—this is a minor thing. I made men guilty. This also is still minor: I bore guilty men. The only thing missing from my travails was that I would love an enemy.
Like Oedipus, Jocasta rehashes Thebes’ guilty history and her own criminal past. In doing so, she notes that Agave's legendary murder of her son is a light crime (leue, Phoen. 367) compared to her own sin: she made her sons guilty (nocentes, Phoen. 368). And yet, like Oedipus, Jocasta goes on to insist that even this is light (leue, Phoen. 368) compared to the real crime: her womb birthed guilty men.Footnote 12 Her escalation from feci to peperi echoes Oedipus’ claim that his mother's fertility made incest greater (Phoen. 262-74, above). At her speech's culmination, Jocasta claims that the only thing worse than bearing incest-produced children would be if it led her to love a man who is now her enemy (Phoen. 370). In another context, Jocasta's words would enhance the pathos of a family divided by civil war. But Seneca's Jocasta is not any mother, and her language alerts us to the problems of her maternal love.Footnote 13 For in language and context she once more echoes Oedipus, who lamented that loving his mother was the worst scelus he could imagine.Footnote 14 Both Oedipus and Jocasta use a similar vocabulary to underscore their awareness of their union's criminality; to each the murder of a family member is leue compared to the maius scelus of the incest they committed.Footnote 15
Despite her awareness of her scelus-ridden past, however, Jocasta seems unaware of the danger she confronts in a world where the present can replay the past. For as Jocasta welcomes a son returning to Thebes for a second time, Seneca seems bent on reminding his audience of the previous iteration, turning Polynices’ invasion into a doublet for his father's original sin.Footnote 16
A Son Returns to Thebes
In general terms, both Polynices and Oedipus come to Thebes as powerful outsiders, each associated with wealthy Peloponnesian kingdoms. And yet both also arrive as quasi-Thebans; though Oedipus is ignorant of his heritage while Polynices feels the sting of separation, each belongs and does not belong to the kingdom as its native son. Seneca further underscores these contextual connections by recalling his Oedipus in his description of Polynices’ return.
Particularly important to Oedipus’ self-perception at the start of Seneca's earlier play is his relationship with two different maternal figures: Merope, the woman whose maternal bed he fled (Oed. 12-27), and the foreign bride Jocasta, whose bed gave him a kingdom (Oed. 14). The audience, of course, knows that Oedipus’ fear of the one ought to be directed towards the other, and Seneca plays with this contrast between Oedipus’ ignorance and our knowledge. In the subsequent Phoenissae, however, Seneca stages an equally complicated relationship between mother and son, but this time the only mother is Jocasta. Around this figure alone Seneca reworks the maternal tensions of fear and desire from his earlier tragedy.Footnote 17
Like Oedipus, a defining aspect of Polynices’ relationship to his mother is his status as an exile, and Jocasta obsesses over this aspect of his identity:
As a refugee from your native land, the gods of a foreign king protect you; so many diverse seas, so many misfortunes drive you as you wander…
Her language and imagery, in turn, recycle elements of the prologue of the earlier Oedipus, in which the king rehearses his past experiences in similar terms:Footnote 18
This fear drove me from my father's kingdom, on account of this I left my gods as a refugee.
But in that context Oedipus referred to his status vis-à-vis Corinth and Merope, to his belief that a return to that mother would condemn him to incest. Here we see highlighted the common mythological thread of exile between father and son, but Oedipus’ misguided fears about exile and home have become Polynices’ conscious decision to return to Thebes, his motherland, and Jocasta.
As Jocasta's maternal anxiety increases during her exchange with her son, the echoes of Seneca's Oedipus likewise intensify:
Will I, an anxious mother, speak to each with alternating pleas? Whom should I embrace first miserably? I'm led by equal affection for each side. This one has been away…embrace me first, you who've suffered so many trials and so many evils, who, weary from long exile, behold your mother.
Later she reiterates this same anxiety (sollicita) when she describes her prayers for his return at any cost:Footnote 19
Son, returned to me after many days, son, an anxious mother's fear and hope, whose sight I always begged of the gods, though your return would rob me of as much as it would give in your arrival.
While a mother's grief over a son's exile might not seem noteworthy in another context, Jocasta's language in each passage once more recalls a key scene from Seneca's Oedipus. When the senex Corinthius (‘Old Corinthian’) in that play reports Polybus’ death and recalls Oedipus to his pseudo-patria, Oedipus hesitates:
With this exchange, the two begin the line of questioning through which Oedipus will soon realize that he has feared the wrong mother and the wrong motherland all along.Footnote 20 Jocasta's description of her own anxiety recycles words familiar from the scene in which she first realized the truth of her incestuous marriage.Footnote 21 In doing so, moreover, we see her attempt to align herself with Merope, a woman whose love was wrongly feared by her son. Boyle has suggested that the Oedipus’ unusual focus on Merope's psychology is driven by Seneca's privileging of the incest theme, and thus Jocasta's echo of that psychological portrait here in the sequel play becomes all the more pointed.Footnote 22 She wants to play the role of the innocent yet anxious mother whose love is uncomplicated by her past. Her inability to play this role, however, is one of the fundamental tensions that Seneca's text stages; in the Phoenissae, the separate maternal roles of Merope and Jocasta have been conflated into one woman who loves her son yet represents the potential for devastating sin.
In the Oedipus, Oedipus chooses exile and a foreign bride as a means of avoiding the maternal violation that awaits him at home. But while for Oedipus these were only deceptive illusions of escape, Polynices is in a position to achieve the very freedom from domestic crime that his father sought. Nevertheless, instead of celebrating her son's escape from his hereditary curse and her polluting amor, Jocasta's distress increases as she ponders her son's foreign marriage and kingdom.Footnote 23 Once she has him in her arms these things do not seem to be benefits to her.Footnote 24 Instead she laments that he has repeated Oedipus’ marital error:
Lest anything of your father's fate has been lacking to you, this also you have from him—to have erred in your marriage.
The logic here is difficult to follow: while Oedipus’ marriage was a disaster because he married not a foreign woman but Jocasta herself, Polynices succeeds where his father failed. And yet not from Jocasta's perspective—for this union has kept her removed from her son's married life, and from his marriage bed: non te duxit in thalamos parens / comitata primos (Phoen. 505f.).Footnote 25 Her language (duxit) looks to the Roman tradition of deductio, and yet no evidence for a maternal deductio for a son exists.Footnote 26 Moreover, her subsequent mention of thalamos primos typically describes a first sexual experience.Footnote 27 Its juxtaposition with parens is jarring, especially considering Oedipus’ earlier use of this phrasing for his own incestuous wedding to Jocasta, there too in the context of a perverted maternal deductio: in thalamos meos / deducta mater (Phoen. 270f).Footnote 28 While to Jocasta, Polynices’ foreign marriage seems to replay Oedipus’ mistakes, Seneca's audience glimpses the true repetition of error that threatens if Jocasta welcomes a second son back to Thebes.
As Jocasta continues to chide her son for staying away from her for so long, she attempts to disarm him in a scene which drips with double-entendres:
Come closer, sheathe your impious sword, and pierce the earth with your spear that trembles and even now desires to thrust. Your shield prevents your mother's breast from touching yours. Put it aside too. Take off the armor from your brow, and remove this grim covering for a warrior's head, and restore your face to your mother. Where do you turn your head, observing your brother's hand with fearful gaze? I'll cover your body entirely with my embrace, pouring myself over you: a path will be made for your lifeblood through mine. Why do you hold back? Do you fear your mother's devotion?
As she tries to persuade her son to remove all obstacles to her affection—both sartorial and emotional—she focuses on her desire to join their bodies together using language that populates Adams’ lexicon of Latin sexual vocabulary.Footnote 29 Word order too adds to the tension: when she declares her desire to join her breast to his, the two interlocking sets of adjectives and nouns surround coire, juxtaposing pectus with pectori (Phoen. 469f.) to visualize the desired entanglement of limbs.Footnote 30 But though Polynices is not yet allowed to respond to her monologue, we get the sense from Jocasta's words that he begins to resist her advances by turning his head away (Phoen. 473). Even this does not stop Jocasta, however, who believes that her son fears only his brother's treachery. Not to worry, she asserts, for she will pour herself (affusa, Phoen. 475) over him so completely that any penetrating wound will create a path for his life-force through her own body.Footnote 31
Jocasta's subsequent questions as to why Polynices holds back (Phoen. 477) suggest that he is less ready to fall into his mother's arms. His one word reply (timeo, Phoen. 478) leaves open a number of possible unstated objects of unease which he then goes on to clarify: nihil iam iura naturae ualent. / post ista fratrum exempla ne matri quidem / fides habenda est (Phoen. 478-80).Footnote 32 Polynices’ reference to the broken laws of nature on one level must refer to the perversions of brother fighting brother, but the imagery is also a ubiquitous trope in Senecan drama for incest. In fact, it has already appeared in various forms in both the Oedipus and the Phoenissae (Oed. 371, 942-45; Phoen. 84f.).Footnote 33 Thus when Polynices responds in these terms to his mother, he reminds us of the inversion of nature that led to his conception by the woman who currently thrusts her love upon him. Polynices’ reference to exempla fratrum (Phoen. 479) is similarly ambiguous: the clear referent is the brother who currently glowers at him (Eteocles), but the plural noun also suggests the incestuous exempla set by Polynices’ other brother, Oedipus.Footnote 34
Thus the opening dialogue between mother and son sets the stage for us to consider the manifold ways in which Polynices’ assault on Thebes could mirror and surpass his father's original incestuous conquest of Jocasta. That Polynices’ brief reply—his first words in the play—couches the strife engulfing Thebes in language reminiscent of the incest from which that civil strife was born becomes significant on multiple fronts. First, it makes manifest the validity of his parents’ hierarchy of crime: the only thing worse than incest is when the products of incest turn against the family and state from within. Moreover, Polynices’ words draw attention to the similarities between the exempla of civil war and incest: each crime involves a son violating boundaries set up by nature, and in both violations the mother's body plays a central role. For as Jocasta will make explicit, Polynices’ assault on Thebes will be waged over, on top of, and through her body. That Jocasta's language of assault will everywhere link the imagery of sex and siege to incestuous ends articulates the disastrous consequences of Polynices’ actions. Through the violation of her body Polynices has the opportunity to restage and out-do Oedipus’ past.
Over a Mother's Body
The symbolic potential of Jocasta's body dominates the play's second half from the moment she thrusts it between warring sons:
Turn your weapons and flames into me, let every youth rush into me alone, both the spirited troops who came from Inachian walls and those who fiercely descend from the Theban citadel. You who are citizen and enemy at the same time, attack this womb which bore brothers for a husband. Tear asunder my limbs and scatter them everywhere. I who bore each of you—do you lay down your swords more swiftly? Or should I say from whom (you were born)? Give your right hands to your mother.
As many note, Jocasta here replays a pivotal moment from Livy's first proto-civil war in which the Sabine women fling themselves as barriers between their husbands and fathers, holding their infants as symbols of pax and concordia (Liv. 1.13). As they urge the warring men to attack them instead, they make manifest the link between early Rome and the mothers whose bodies are symbolic of its pietas and fecunditas. Through these bodies they brought Rome back from the brink of civil war, and it is this exact moment that Jocasta echoes, appropriating the Sabine's voice for her own ends: si adfinitatis inter uos, si conubii piget, in nos uertite iras (Liv. 1.13.3).Footnote 35 Jocasta also recalls the legendary mother of Livy's Coriolanus, Veturia, who prevented her son from attacking his native land through similar appeals to her maternal status (Liv. 2.40).Footnote 36 To capture Rome, Coriolanus must render the woman who bore him a capta; in order to violate the city, he must violate her with it. As with the Sabines, Veturia's maternal voice and the symbolism of her body as proxy for the state cause her son to abandon his planned aggression.
Nevertheless, while Jocasta replays the actions of legendary mothers whose bodies represent boundaries that even civil strife dare not violate, her actions emphasize the differences in her situation. The success of these women is predicated on their stable identities as guarantors of the state's purity and virtue.Footnote 37 But Jocasta's confused relationship with her men strips her body of this symbolic potential: her body symbolizes impurity and impietas stained by the wrongful violation that engendered civil wars to begin with; her body might invite, rather than repel, further transgressions.Footnote 38
Jocasta's address to her sons dares them to penetrate her, to send their armies’ collective energy into her (Phoen. 443f., above).Footnote 39 Livy's Sabines had predicated similar imperatives within a conditional statement (Liv. 1.13.3, above), but Jocasta's commands are nowhere thus qualified. The unusual triple elisions of the first line underscore her passionate frenzy while her specific words emphasize the transgressive command as me, arma, and omnis slide into one another, eliminating the boundaries that the words—and the objects they signify—ought to maintain. Moreover, beginning with her initial, chant-like anaphora (in me! in me!, Phoen. 443), we are never allowed to stop gazing at her body. Her womb and limbs are marked out with deictic demonstratives;Footnote 40 elsewhere her face, breasts, and tears invite us as proxies for the male audience of her sons to gaze at the parts of her body that define her confused, incestuous maternity.Footnote 41 As Jocasta places her body in between her warring sons, drawing our attention to that body and its sexual past, we move closer and closer to the moment in which bellum ciuile might allow Oedipus’ sons to surpass their father's original sin.Footnote 42 For these reasons, I take line 447 (hunc petite uentrem, qui dedit fratres uiro) as genuine, rather than a distracting interpolation based on the Oedipus.Footnote 43 Even if it were an interpolation, however, it would suggest that Seneca's readers were aware of the sexual overtones of Jocasta's wish to make the first act of civil war the penetration of her own body.
Jocasta's Siege Narrative
Though anticipation of war builds throughout the play, we never actually see bellum ciuile come to pass in what remains of the text. But while civil war may be absent from the surviving fragments, civil war narrative is not. An extensive and detailed description of the war, the siege, and the eventual triumph comes not from the typical anonymous messenger, but from the mouth of Jocasta herself, the woman whose womb birthed discordia and over whose dead body civil war would engulf Thebes.Footnote 44
Jocasta's description of Thebes’ imagined fall (Phoen. 540-71) adheres to the Roman conventions of direptio, a narrative trope ideally suited for Seneca's incestuous designs.Footnote 45 Descriptions of direptio, with its connotations of tearing and ravishing, often portray siege warfare in sexual terms.Footnote 46 The early empire also saw a proliferation of images that reimagined the conquered land as a woman bound, disheveled, and led away violently by a victorious general, a woman whose grief and captivity underscored the vulnerability of her country.Footnote 47 Though bruised and terrorized, these anthropomorphized conquered lands were also timelessly seductive, as if they stood individually for the spoils gained by war.Footnote 48 Thus Seneca inherits a system of imagery that links the conquest of land with the domination of its women.
Jocasta's narrative of direptio taps into this wider Roman assimilation of sex and siege as she recycles the language and rhetoric with which she earlier exhorted her sons to assault her body. In both places the violence is described with forms of uertere; weapons and fire will assault both mater and tecta: euerte Thebas… armis uris infestis solum…haec telis petes / flammisque tecta (Phoen. 557-66; cf. 100).Footnote 49 She even uses the same insistent piling of deictic demonstratives to draw attention to the spectacle of perverse violence perpetrated by Polynices’ assault: haec tecta…haec saxa (‘these roofs…these rocks’, Phoen. 565f, 571; cf. Phoen. 447f. above). This intratextually charged language simultaneously builds on a pre-existing assimilation between Thebes and Jocasta's body from elsewhere in the Phoenissae. Earlier, Oedipus worried that his incestuous presence continued to assault Thebes, the fertile mother of all (alma parens, Phoen. 222). So too, as Littlewood has noted, Seneca uses abstrusum (‘hidden’) only twice in the play, once to describe Oedipus’ hiding place in the Theban earth (Phoen. 360) and once to describe his position in Jocasta's womb (Phoen. 251).Footnote 50 Finally, when Jocasta earlier commanded her sons to rend her limb from limb ( diuellite , Phoen. 448), an audience may recall Oedipus’ proleptic wish to see Thebes torn apart piece by piece ( disicite , Phoen. 343) and to see that final devastation ‘begin from [his] marriage bed’ ( a thalamis meis/ incipiat ignis, Phoen. 346f).Footnote 51
Thus within the symbolic economy of Seneca's Theban dramas, the conquest of Thebes and the conquest of Jocasta become intratextually interrelated. Thebes, however, is no generic foreign land with which Polynices could augment his empire, nor is Jocasta a neutral female figure whose conquest can be readily viewed in sexual terms. Rather, by assimilating her son's planned siege of Thebes to an assault on her own body, Seneca has Jocasta reimagine bellum ciuile as a maximum scelus (Oed. 629) outdoing Oedipus’ sin. Polynices will not only violate his mother as Oedipus had done but will likewise violate his mother city, a symbolically incestuous act with far greater consequences.
The incestuous aspects of this direptio become even more manifest as we reach the climax of Jocasta's civil war narrative, her son's triumph:
As victor will you carry off your spoils and those leaders your father's age who've been bound up? And will a savage soldier chain and drag off mothers snatched from their husbands’ bosoms? Should a Theban virgin go as spoil for Argive daughters, mixed in a captive flock? Or will I myself, bound with palms tied behind my back—your mother—be carried as the prize booty of your brotherly triumph?
Jocasta pulls no emotional punches. Although her first line merely articulates the relationship between uictor and spolia, she quickly clarifies that the spolia refer to the human conquest of Polynices’ campaign. She focuses on Theban women, a fitting detail given the symbolism of women's bodies in Roman conquest-narratives both as captives whose bodies are vulnerable and also in the larger metaphorical language of siege. She imagines mothers snatched from husbands’ bosoms as a savage captor drags them away in chains, imagery that reinforces the sexual nature of conquest through the use of rapere (‘to seize’, Phoen. 573). When Jocasta turns to the unmarried maidens (adulta uirgo, Phoen. 575f.), she highlights their status as untouched women on the verge of sexual maturity, forced into slavery as a huddled mass without male protection. In these ways, Jocasta forces her son to confront the cost paid by Theban women for a victory represented in increasingly erotic terms. Nevertheless, while matres and uirgines might appear on the surface to be little more than stock types drawn from generic narratives of direptio, within the context of the Phoenissae they take on additional significance as the categories into which the two women of this play fall: Antigone the uirgo (e.g. Phoen. 50, 81, 94, 103) and Jocasta the mater (e.g. Phoen. 37, 50, 93, 211, 250, 262, 271). Thus Polynices represents a sexual threat not only to the women of his city, but especially to the women of his family.
Jocasta reserves the most elaborate image of conquest for herself. Earlier she articulated her fear in ways suggestive of the sexual violence ubiquitous in images of military conquest:Footnote 52
I stand agape and tremble bloodlessly, when I see two brothers standing on this side and that within crime's range, my limbs quake with fear.
Once we reach Polynices’ victory, Jocasta's fear is validated as she becomes the ultimate prize of his triumph (praeda, Phoen. 578). She sits hands bound, defeated, like one of the royal women often paraded in triumphs whose individualized suffering stands for her country's, or as a personification of the conquered land itself.Footnote 53 The elegiac charge of the term praeda further imbues this finale with erotic associations.Footnote 54 Thebes is but an extension of her body, the conquest of her body but a symbol for Thebes.
Nevertheless, while Roman conquest can use the vulnerability of the desirable foreign female as a proxy for a foreign population brought into Roman control, the female bodies of Thebes are more problematic. This is especially true of Jocasta's, which she is so ready to visualize as praeda for her son. The last time her body became the prize of a quasi-foreign hero, she entered into the sexual relationship which bore the men now seeking to dismantle the city. If the conquest of Thebes is akin to the conquest of its women's bodies, as Jocasta suggests, who better to be violated than Thebes’ queen-mother and who better to do the violating than its native son? In this way, Seneca manipulates the sexualized language of Roman conquest to fit his background both of incest and civil war, suggesting that Polynices’ would-be conquest of his native land becomes yet one more unnatural and sexual violation of family and familial ethics. While Jocasta's status as Polynices’ mater should repel him, her rhetoric suggests that the dangerous symbolism of her body might invite his assault instead.
Conclusion
The Phoenissae’s Oedipus and Jocasta are deeply mindful of their disastrous past. This past underpins their mirrored sense of self-loathing and becomes a regular point of comparison for the ongoing strife at Thebes. Seneca, in turn, uses these memories of the past along with pointed echoes of his earlier Oedipus to rewrite Polynices as a doublet for and echo of his father's disastrous history, going so far as to bring his Jocasta back from the dead in a move that has long puzzled critics. But Jocasta's living presence in the Phoenissae allows the playwright to capitalize on the tradition of incest associated with Thebes and the erotic language that pervades Roman military narrative to recast Polynices’ would-be conquest of Thebes in incestuous terms. In doing so, Seneca offers us an innovative yet disturbing image of bellum ciuile that both incorporates and expands upon the symbolic resonance of boundary violation and familial ethics at the heart of Roman literature's poetics of civil war. Through his multivalent assimilation of Thebes and Jocasta—an association largely accomplished through Jocasta's voice—Polynices’ penetrative assault on his mother city becomes a perversely natural fulfillment of the exemplum his father set for him.Footnote 55
