Collins has written a magnificent book – enthralling, intriguing and challenging. It is also perhaps just a little self-indulgent and over long. The combination of vivid and deep ethnography, theoretical sophistication and an insistence on pushing beyond the standard tropes of anthropological analysis – albeit sometimes into murky territory – will make this a classic.
The basics are simple enough. Collins focuses on the Pelourinho, a city-centre zone of Salvador, once home to the city's nobles, later a place for brothels, bars, night-life and cheap rented accommodation. Since 1990, but with precursors in the 1960s and 1970s, the area has undergone patrimonialisation and conversion into ‘cultural heritage’, a state-driven programme that has displaced most of the zone's poor, Afro-Brazilian population. The Pelourinho has become commodified as a complex icon of Bahian (and, by selective extension, Brazilian) history, culture and identity; a site attesting to founding narratives of both mestiçagem (racial and cultural mixture) and the Africanness seen to contribute to that mixture.
Collins, who lived in the Pelourinho as an artisan in the early 1990s before doing research there, traces this process, mostly from the perspectives of the locals, but also paying attention to the politicians, state officials and social scientists who design and execute the reforms, and who map the zone, geographically and culturally; he also draws in the intellectuals who wrote about the area during the twentieth century. He focuses particularly on Bahia's Institute of Artistic and Cultural Patrimony (IPAC), the main bureaucracy that has intervened in the Pelourinho and developed an archive of its people and their lifeways from the late 1960s.
The substantive topics Collins deals with in this story are varied. We learn first about the Pelourinho, its history and some key characters in it. Chapter 2 focuses on Mario de Andrade, author of Macuanima and an early figure in the Brazilian heritage institutions that Collins describes. Chapter 3 tells the story of IPAC and discusses the informal sexual relations between white bohemian intellectual men and black women (often prostitutes) in the Pelourinho, which underwrite it as a site of mestiçagem. Chapter 4 looks at the 1990s process of sanitisation and displacement, focusing on one location known as the Gueto and its residents. Chapter 5 explores the unearthing of skeletons during construction works in the Pelourinho in the late 1990s: Collins traces the tales of mystery and treasure that circulated among state officials and residents around these remains. Chapter 6 – a riveting read – analyses an outburst by a local woman, Toba, challenging a visiting nurse who was dispensing advice about sanitation: Toba flummoxed the nurse by asking if, in the interests of santitation, she would let Toba into the nurse's house to use the toilet, if Toba were caught short during her garbage-picking activities in the middle-class neighbourhood. Chapter 7 looks at the Portuguese lyrics young reggae fans invent to sing along to English-language reggae tunes in the Pelourinho. This summary does no justice to the richness of Collins’ analysis, but it illustrates the varied ethnographic substance of the book.
The arguments Collins develops with this material are complex and multiple. One is about ‘co-production’, that is, the way in which Pelourinho residents actively participate with social scientists and state officials in the processes that end up objectifying and commodifying them and their spaces. The scientists and officials nurture and care for the residents – e.g., they produce ethnographies explaining how the people's ‘degenerate’ lifeways are a functional response to the city context; they deliver health-care education; and in the past IPAC employed local residents and lobbied for them. But they also displace them – the data scientists collect provide evidence of ‘degeneracy’; the data inform governance mechanisms that include relocations and evictions; the police harass and even kill residents. Residents, for their part, participated in these processes in order to further their own ends. This was partly a matter of engaging with and manipulating the ‘data’ that they perceived were so important to IPAC, whose workers carried out endless surveys. It also meant recognising themselves as objects of special scientific and patrimonial interest – quasi-sanctified (hence the ‘saints’ of the title) or what Collins calls ‘properly historical subjects’ – and using this status to make calls on the state, and to claim status not just as patrimony but also as patrimonialists and researchers.
A second argument is that, as researchers, we need to pay attention to the specificity of the material techniques or mechanisms by which people make meaningful connections – between people and the past or present – and think about belonging and identity. It is not only the categories and meanings themselves, in some abstract sense, that matter, but the techniques people use to know them. This means paying ethnographic attention to the diversity of people's everyday practices. It is not easy to illustrate briefly what concrete difference is made by approaching things this way. One example is that the creation of ‘culture heritage’ is a specific technique that inflects a category like ‘race’ – which posits relations between external signs and interior qualities – allowing people in the Pelourinho, who actually live through patrimonialisation, to construct connections and senses of belonging that construe race as property, just as ‘culture’ is property. In the Pelourinho, while this is going on, the particularities of the property regime there – where people carve out tenuous living spaces in the interstices of ruined colonial mansions, competing with others for room – also work against such proprietary essentialism, and mesh with the social conventions that discourage open talk about race. This argument fleshes out the common observation that race is becoming more essentialised and polarised in Brazil, alongside the continuing reticence about race that resonates with ideologies of mixture and ‘racial democracy’.
Collins’ book is a Caribbean pepperpot stew, an ongoing accretion of ingredients simmered for long periods. It is mature, flavourful, surprising and rewarding. Its constant reflexive re-framings and maze-like progressions fascinate, and occasionally produce an Alice-through-the-looking-glass sense of (not unpleasurable) disorientation.
