Fifty years on from when Tanzania was formed out of the union of the mainland territory of Tanganyika and Zanzibar, and 20 years on from the fall of apartheid in South Africa, veteran analyst and activist John S. Saul ponders his own initial optimism and the sneaking doubts that soon crept in about the liberation struggles in southern Africa. This collection of essays presents chapters on South Africa, Tanzania and Mozambique, with occasional references to Angola, Namibia and Zimbabwe. Thematically the essays deal with the reality and sanity of southern Africa's post-liberation predicament and place the post-liberation struggles in a regional and global context, drawing principally on the observations of Frantz Fanon, with references to Amilcar Cabral. In essence the collection builds on his own examination – and that of other struggle ‘comrades’ – of the shift from fighting ‘colonial empires’ (national) to wrestling with the Empire of Capital (globalisation) and the claim that a new ‘precariat’ has emerged in the gaze of economic, social and political crises with climbing levels of inequality, increased corruption and widespread violence against workers and protest movements.
The essays, which have all been published elsewhere and/or presented at various recent occasions marking or reflecting on the key moments in the history of southern Africa, build on the Introduction, ‘Globalization Made Me Do It’ vs. ‘The Struggle Continues’, in six chapters: 1. The Failure of the Southern African Liberation? 2. Tanzania Fifty Years On (1961–2011): Rethinking Ujamaa, Nyerere and Socialism in Africa; 3. Mozambique – not Then but Now; 4. On Taming a Revolution: The South African Case; 5. The New Terms of Resistance: Proletariat, Precariat and the Present African Prospect; and 6. Conclusions: The Struggle Really Does Continue in Southern Africa. The book ends with a tribute to Ruth First, and a salute to Nelson Mandela presented in an Appendix.
John S. Saul's collection of essays is firmly anchored in Marxist perspectives, and they are generally presented in understandable terms. He argues concisely that even though liberation struggles in the southern African countries were often flirting with or conducted in the name of socialism/Marxism and clearly subject to criticism, nonetheless the liberalisation struggles did defeat colonial racism, including apartheid. But Saul is scathing about the lack of constructive and far-reaching liberation objectives in practice from the same liberation movements once they come to power. He argues that ‘true’ (there is an insistence, as one may expect, on such a truth) liberation in southern Africa is not yet fully realised. The book presents and analyses a variety of ideas and factors that may have led to such a ‘half-baked’ state of liberation. These range from individual weaknesses of various leaders and their lack of analytical understanding of the economic-socio-political complexities they encountered, to external forces such as capital, neoliberalism and political domination. This ‘made something of a mockery of the decades of liberation struggle that had once seemed to promise’ a different and more equal rule (pp. 2, 18).
Whereas others see the emerging national middle classes as democracy's new hope, Saul argues that they just are the ‘intermediary’ (like the compradores of yesteryear) that has nothing to do with transforming the nation but is only the transmission line between the nation and global capitalism that today puts on the mask of neocolonialism. Instead he pins his hope on the precarious domain of the southern African societies and the boiling ‘social restlessness’, terming them ‘ticking time-bombs … stirring potentially effective and presumptively counter-hegemonic activity’ (pp. 11, 12). Indeed southern Africa is still poor and living with ‘unfulfilled dreams and unrealized possibilities’ (pp. 43, 44) but I wonder if this can really be undone by the ‘campaign’ character of ‘social restlessness’, however sympathetic the idea clearly is.
