These two volumes are welcome contributions to the study of early Southeast Asia's artistic and architectural heritage. They demonstrate ongoing international efforts to conserve Southeast Asian heritage in the twenty-first century. They also indicate sustained interest among art historians and connoisseurs in early Southeast Asia and perhaps reason to hope for many more such publications to come.
William Chapman's A Heritage of Ruins is a survey of some of the more famous ruins of Southeast Asia and a historical account of their conservation and restoration in modern times. The book focuses on the region's “ancient” ruins, or more precisely the remains of Hindu and Buddhist constructions built before the eighteenth century CE. At the center of Chapman's story are not the original builders but the colonial scholars, nation-state leaders, and international conservators who ushered Southeast Asia's ruins into the era of heritage preservation and mass tourism.
The colonial legacy of conservation in the region informs much of Chapman's narrative. The French archaeologists and conservators of the École Française d'Extrême-Orient (EFEO) spearheaded efforts to study and restore ruins in French Indochina (Vietnam, Cambodia, and Laos), particularly at Angkor, the extensive Cambodian city that Chapman calls “the elephant in the room” (p. 59) for its sheer quantity of ruins and its long history of conservation activity. Dutch scholars experimented with the restoration technique of anastylosis at Borobudur in central Java, which was later applied by the EFEO at Angkor. Thailand, while not colonized, enthusiastically called on EFEO surveyors and historians to inventory the country's historical sites. For Chapman, British colonialists in Burma and Malaya were outliers for their relative lack of interest in ruins (the much older ruins of the Indian subcontinent were the higher priority), which may explain the different and controversial approaches to heritage sites in modern Burma/Myanmar.
Though colonial scholars took for granted the importance of preserving ruins, deciding on a proper method of conservation was often a matter of controversy, and it remains even more so today. Returning a ruin to its original state is no longer the priority of “authentic” conservation today; rather, conservators aim to maintain the visible signs of a ruin's deterioration over time. Hence we see the present minimalist approach to conservation at sites like Banteay Chmar in Cambodia, where the Global Heritage Fund's goal is stabilization, not restoration. Chapman raises necessary questions about this and other approaches to the conservation of ruins. What should happen if in the future a wall of bas-reliefs at Banteay Chmar collapses overnight, or if earthquakes damage the Prambanan temple in Java or the temples of Pagan? Would these events not be part of the authentic lives of these sites? Should ruins be “restored” in cases like these? If so, are international conservators sensitive to local impulses to not simply restack the rubble but to remake a religious monument? Chapman suggests that the problem of whether and how to restore is never an easy or innocent one. He cites heritage efforts in Burma, where the desire of the country's military leaders to beautify and resacralize the monuments of Pagan has come into conflict with the colonial, and now UNESCO's, ideal of ruined authenticity. As ticket sales at the Angkor Archaeological Park soar over the two million mark and as conservators and tourism promoters debate whether and how to limit development around Borobudur, the problem of balancing authenticity and the economics of mass tourism becomes more pressing.
Chapman's primary task is to give a dispassionate, nuanced account of changing and conflicting conservation and restoration practices in modern Southeast Asia. He is not simply describing a phenomenon, however. He provides a template for how heritage scholars, site managers, and government leaders can safeguard ruins with reverence for the past, respect for diverse opinions, and a commitment to clear-headed compromise. Chapman's book provides a road map to the complicated world of heritage studies in the twenty-first century.
Gods of Angkor brings attention to a particular conservation effort in present-day Cambodia. This catalogue was published in 2010 to accompany an exhibition of bronzes from the collection of the National Museum of Cambodia in Phnom Penh. The exhibition took place at the Arthur M. Sackler Galley in Washington, D.C., from May 15, 2010, to January 23, 2011, and then was continued at the J. Paul Getty Museum in Los Angeles later in 2011. The exhibition and the book were the result of several years of collaboration between the Sackler Gallery and the National Museum of Cambodia's Metal Conservation Laboratory, which has received generous support from the Smithsonian, the Getty, and the Global Heritage Fund.
This art book consists of four scholarly articles analyzing the items in the exhibition, interspersed with page-length photographs and brief descriptions of each item. The featured Cambodian bronzes date from as early as the first millennium BCE to the fourteenth century in the late Angkor period. Ian Glover's article focuses on prehistoric bronze drums, bells, and urns, observing that the famous drums, which originated in southern China and northern Vietnam, have rarely been studied in the context of a controlled excavation. Hiram Woodward surveys the collection's Hindu and Buddhist images from Cambodia's early historical period, placing them in chronological context. John Guy comments on the ritual function of Angkorian bronzes, noting that certain icons of gods and goddesses called utsavamurti were made for use in temple processions. The fundamental mobility of bronze icons is nicely demonstrated by a group of bronze sculptures found in Cambodia in 2006, which are examined separately in this volume by Paul Jett. These seven Buddhist sculptures, all dating to the sixth or seventh centuries CE, represent three different styles and places of origin: two Khmer bronzes, three Dvāravati-style bronzes (probably from central Thailand), and two gilded Chinese Buddhist figures. Woodward uses these Chinese bronzes to evoke the possibility of profound artistic and architectural currents between China and Cambodia in this period. Along with these bronzes, highlights of the exhibition include an early tenth-century Maitreya from a time when Buddhist statuary was relatively rare, a bodhisattva image with a conveniently inscribed date of 970 CE, and the stunning twelfth-century standing Crowned Buddha found at Angkor Wat.
In the past, Cambodia's monumental ruins and stone statuary have largely overshadowed bronzes in the academic literature. When this volume was published in 2010, it marked an important step in the effort to showcase and conserve these neglected masterpieces of Southeast Asian art. It has since been followed by exciting new scholarship, including Brice Vincent's groundbreaking work on Angkorian bronzes from the eleventh to thirteenth centuries and Martin Polkinghorne's recent discovery and excavation of a bronze workshop adjacent to the royal palace at Angkor. The editors of Gods of Angkor can be satisfied that the study of Khmer bronzes has a bright future.
