Admiral Togo's claim to fame is that he commanded the Imperial Japanese Navy's main battle fleet at its climactic victory over the Imperial Russian Navy's Baltic Fleet at Tsushima in 1905.
The battle was one-sided. The Baltic Fleet had just completed an arduous voyage of 18,000 miles, its vessels were not ship-shape, coal was piled high on the decks and neither officers nor men had received up-to-date training in naval warfare. The Baltic Fleet's commander, Zinovy Rozhestvensky, was a bad-tempered martinet who had little control over himself let alone over his fleet. Togo on the other hand was a man of impressive calm and resource, leading a fleet of excellent warships crewed by consummate professional seamen. Togo had already bottled up the Russian Far East Fleet at Port Arthur and had brought the China Seas under effective Japanese control.
At Tsushima the Russian fleet opened fire at 14.08 and the Japanese replied at 14.11. Within the space of those three minutes the Russians released some three hundred shells, striking the Mikasa, Togo's flagship, and several other Japanese vessels. The Japanese suffered casualties before firing a shot. However, half an hour later the Russian formation was scattered, and the battle was effectively over. This signal victory was the result of years of dedicated naval service; as Togo was to remark later although the decisive battle took such a short time, it required ten years of preparation.
Togo became a hero both in Japan and elsewhere and his tactics at Tsushima were subjected to intense study by the naval staffs of the great powers. Eleven years later at the battle of Jutland, on 31st May 1916, both Admiral Sir John Jellicoe of the British Grand Fleet and Admiral Reinhard Scheer of the German High Seas Fleet strove, inconclusively, to replicate Togo's tactics at Tsushima.
Japanese seamanship and gunnery were excellent. Togo alluded to the latter during his farewell speech to the fleet on 21st December 1905 saying that “a gun whose every shot tells can hold its own against a hundred guns that can hit only one shot in a hundred”. And although Togo said, with characteristic modesty, that the Japanese won their victory where it was easy to win and “not over something that was hard to conquer”, it is certain that his consummate professionalism, mirroring that of the Imperial Japanese Navy (IJN) as a whole, played a significant role in the Japanese triumph. Togo's personal qualities of modesty, calm, and humility, his single-minded pursuit of excellence, his aggressiveness as a commander, were the ideal of the officers and men of the IJN. Togo saw a warrior's life as one of continual war: “If war breaks out we display our military power; if we are at peace, we cultivate it”.
Togo's victory at Tsushima destroyed Russian naval power in East Asia. It was not until Admiral Gorshkov became Commander-in-Chief of the Soviet Navy in 1955 that Russia was to re-emerge as a maritime force in the Pacific and, indeed, the world.
In the meantime the IJN went from strength to strength, supplanting the British Royal Navy as the premier force in East Asian seas and eventually challenging the US Navy for control of the Pacific. The IJN regarded Togo as the founder of its greatness, and Togo came to enjoy a stature in Japan roughly equivalent to that of Horatio Nelson in Britain. As the Nelson of the IJN Togo was a model of duty, courage and cool leadership, and stories about him became as familiar to generations of Japanese as tales of Nelson had been in Victorian and Edwardian Britain. Togo's flagship, Mikasa (built by Vicker's at Barrow-in-Furness), is preserved still at Yokosuka Navy Yard, just as HMS Victory remains in dry dock at Portsmouth.
Togo's life is of significance as a great naval commander and as a central figure in the history of Imperial Japan. I was therefore very interested to learn of this new biography of Togo and looked forward to learning something new of this fascinating individual.
Chapter One covers the early years of Togo's life, his traditional education as a samurai during the latter years of the Tokugawa Shogunate. The chapter contains the usual tales of youthful daring one would expect in an old-fashioned biography, as well as some detail on the politics, local and national, of the period. Chapter Two recounts Togo's experiences during the struggles of early Meiji and explains how he was introduced to a naval career in the budding Japanese fleet of the 1860s. Chapter Three tells us of Togo's professional formation as a cadet aboard the British training ship Worcester. We are given an account of his adventures in England and of his, invariably positive, relationships with various Britons. This chapter ends with the early Meiji incursions into Korean and Taiwanese waters and the romantic, but wrong-headed, rebellion of Saigo Takamori. Chapter Four contains various accounts of Togo's developing career as a professional naval officer and of his diplomatic ability as he interacted with the ships' captains of various foreign navies. The last quarter of the nineteenth century was a delicate period in the history of American and European involvement in East Asia, and naval officers frequently found themselves engaged in dealing with complex political issues where they had to think fast and act decisively. As a representative of the emerging power of Japan, Togo acquitted himself well, assisted in large part by his good grasp of the English language and his habitual calm.
Chapter Five gives a good account of Japan's involvement with Hawaii and the role played by Togo as the political temperature rose over American intervention in the islands. Once again, Togo carried out his duty with his characteristic coolness. Togo's tranquil nature and soundness of judgment are well described. Chapters Six, Seven and Eight are concerned with Togo's significant role in the war with China in 1894–1895. His controversial decision to sink the British-registered Chinese troopship the Kowshing is described in detail and gives Togo's reasons for his actions in this matter. The China War burnished further Togo's reputation as a skilled officer and brought him some recognition outside the confines of the IJN. Chapter Nine covers Togo's operations in Taiwan as Japan sought to bring her new won province under control, and closes with Togo's participation in the suppression of the Boxer uprising. The book really gets into its stride with Chapter Ten which is concerned with Togo's appointment to the senior sea-going post in the IJN, command of the Standing Squadron, his surprise attack on the Russian naval base at Port Arthur and the outbreak of the Russo-Japanese War. It was generally felt that Togo had failed at Port Arthur: the object of the attack had been the destruction of the Russian squadron and possibly the seizure of the base by coup de main. This had not been achieved. Reaction both inside the IJN and in foreign navies was unfavourable: in London the First Sea Lord, Admiral Sir John Fisher, an outspoken opponent of Japan, had laughed at the apparent failure of Britain's ally. Nevertheless, Togo held his force together, bottled up the Russian vessels in harbour, and secured his strategic objective which was to deny the sea to his enemy.
Chapter Eleven describes Togo's checking of the Russian Pacific Fleet at the battle of the Yellow Sea and his operations in support of the Japanese army during the siege of Port Arthur. Chapter Twelve gives an unexpectedly brief account of the battle of Tsushima. This climactic naval engagement, the one for which Togo is famous and which makes him worthy of a full-scale biography, is dismissed in a handful of paragraphs. Chapter Thirteen covers Togo's life as a celebrity after the battle of Tsushima, and Chapter Fourteen is in much the same vein as it follows Togo from man to myth, and his elevation to the status of icon of the IJN.
This book sets out to be an account of the life of Admiral Togo aimed squarely at the general reader. Jonathan Clements is a skilled popular historian responsible for a welcome recent biography of Marshal Mannerheim (Jonathan Clements Mannerheim: President, Soldier, Spy [London, 2009]) and is also a scholar of Japanese and Chinese. Clements does bring to his biography of Togo a clear understanding of the context of the Admiral's career, giving a comprehensive account of the changing world of the Meiji era. Togo's participation as an officer of the forces of Satsuma-Choshu in the struggle with the Tokugawa Shogunate is well described, and Clements is also aware of the ironies of the period: Togo's brother succumbed by the side of Saigo Takamori as the power struggle within the triumphant Satsuma-Choshu coalition was played out to its bloody conclusion.
However, there is, regrettably, nothing new in this book. It leans all too heavily on the 1930s biographies by Falk (E.A. Falk Togo and the Rise of Japanese Sea Power [Longman's, Green and Co., New York 1936]) and Ogasawara (Vice-Admiral N. Ogasawara The Life of Admiral Tōgō [Seitō Shorin Press, Tokyo 1934]). It contains little about the development of the IJN, nor anything of interest about the men and ships that made the IJN one of the most formidable fighting forces in the world. The writing is often pedestrian, managing to make Togo's career in the IJN somewhat tedious. One is not informed why Togo ascended to command of the IJN's premier battle fleet at such a crucial moment in Japan's history. We are told nothing of Togo's rivals for high command in the IJN, nothing of his captains and nothing of the tactical and strategic doctrines that shaped the Japanese art of war at sea. We are told little of Togo's opponents, whether Chinese or Russian, and information about the naval units at their command is scanty. We are told, for example, that the German-built Chinese warships the Zhenyuan and Pingyuan were massively impressive, but we are not told anything about their speed, armour or firepower. Clements has not, apparently, consulted any works on the Russian experience during the Russo-Japanese war or at the climactic sea battle of Tsushima. It would have also been useful had Clements given the reader some insight into the Beiyang Fleet that the Imperial Japanese Navy so conclusively trounced in the war with China 1894–1895. I found myself consulting the first volume of the Committee of Imperial Defence's Official History of the Russo-Japanese War (HMSO, 1910) to remind myself of the naval resources of the contending Russian and Japanese empires; the absence of detail on life and leadership in the Imperial Russian Navy could be rectified by looking at Constantin Pleshakov's The Tsar's Last Armada (New York, 2003), which makes exhaustive use of the material in the Russian State Archives.
Despite the book's subtitle there is no comparison of Togo with his hero Nelson. We are told nothing of Togo's devotion to Nelson and to the British naval tradition. Yet Togo referred to Nelson as his ‘God’, and remembered with emotion a memorial ceremony for Nelson he had witnessed when a young cadet aboard the training ship HMS Worcester. Nor does the book allude to the Nelsonic echoes in Togo's signal (flag Z) to the fleet at the battle of Tsushima: “The country's fate depends upon this battle: let every man do his utmost”. Nor are we told of the remarkably close relationship between the Royal Navy and the IJN. In the year of Tsushima timbers from HMS Victory were presented to the Japanese naval attaché in London, for which gift Togo cabled his ‘heartfelt thanks’. The Imperial Navy Academy at Etajima (now the Officer Candidate School of the Maritime Self-Defence Force) was constructed with British bricks, and to this day houses a museum containing a portrait of Nelson and a lock of his hair, as well as, close by, some hairs of Admiral Togo. The connections and parallels between Nelson and Togo as icons of naval prowess are left unexplored.
There is little attempt to tell the story of the development of the IJN, and other significant Japanese naval commanders have at best only walk-on roles. The crucial figure of Admiral Yamamoto Gonnohyoe, Navy Minister during the Russo-Japanese War, is mentioned only in passing. In a conversation some years later Yamamoto made the intriguing claim to the British First Sea Lord, Admiral Fisher, that he, Yamamoto, had planned Togo's every move at sea. It would be interesting if someone could check if there is any evidence to back this in the Japanese archives. Nor does Clements inform us why Yamamoto chose Togo for the top sea-going post in the IJN at the critical moment.
Clements tells us more of Togo's post-war fame than of the rather more significant earlier part of his career. In the later chapters we are treated to exhaustive accounts of Togo's enthusiastic receptions in both Britain and the USA, and a series of rather pointless anecdotes about his meetings with the celebrities of his day. Curiously, in place of anything new and interesting to relate, Clements shares with us his surmise that in spring 1884 Togo “received an enthusiastic send-off from Mrs Togo, as the couple's eldest son, Hyo, was born nine months later on 28 February 1885'. (p. 65), and that Navy records have Captain Togo returning to active duty [after a bout of rheumatism] in May 1890, although Mrs Togo would probably have more accurately dated her husband's recovery to a night in January when the couple conceived their second son, Minoru (born 10 September 1890) (p. 74). Clements has not consulted any archival sources, either British or Japanese, nor has he put his Japanese scholarship to any particular purpose. The Japanese language works listed in his bibliography are not really germane to Togo's career. Although Clements tells us in his acknowledgements that his wife “lugged her camera from Hakodate to Sendai to Yokosuka in search of Togo relics” no fruits of that quest appear in the book.
It is symptomatic of this biography that the photo on page 72 purporting to be of Togo is actually one of Ito Hirobumi.
There have been many very good popular yet scholarly works published recently on naval and military history (one thinks for example of Mungo Melville's recent book on Field-Marshal Erich von Manstein [Manstein, London 2010] which was based on sound archival research), leading one to feel that Clements has missed an opportunity here. While it is always good to see new work on the Russo-Japanese War, I think it is fair to say that Admiral Togo still awaits a full modern biography.
