No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 May 2004
This new book on Islam is definitely not part of the genre of literature written in the wake of the 11 September 2001 attacks on the United States that has sought to exploit an emerging mass market. On the contrary, The Ulama in Contemporary Islam represents one of the most significant contributions to our understanding of the dynamics of power and change within contemporary Muslim societies. It challenges conventional wisdom that portrays the traditional authority within Muslim society as anachronistic and oblivious to the rapid transformations wrought by modernity. Its central thesis is that the ulema have astutely negotiated and subtly re-articulated the millennium-old tradition of Islamic learning with the “reflexivity of modernity” (i.e., the need to constantly adapt existing forms of knowledge, institutions, and social relations to relentless flows of information), such that they now occupy an enlarged role within the public sphere (p. 1).
Zaman not only draws on the best of modern scholarship on religious studies and contemporary Muslim societies. He has also enriched his well-balanced and thorough study by consulting many primary Urdu and Arabic texts written by the key ulema figures whose lives, activities, and thought he focuses on.
The book comprises an Introduction, six chapters, and an Epilogue. In the Introduction, Zaman carefully lays out his theoretical approach. He critically engages cutting-edge scholarship on the contemporary role of religion in public life. He draws on the nuanced theoretical insights of scholars such as Barbara Metcalf, William Graham, Alisdair MacIntire, and Talal Asad in illuminating the critical concepts of “tradition and modernity.” Building on Asad's proposition that Islam in general ought to be approached as a “discursive tradition,” the author makes a case for approaching particular aspects of the Islamic tradition, such as the shari

a, Islamic historiography, and institutionalized Sufism, as discursive traditions in themselves (p. 9). He contends that it is the ulema who not only self-consciously represent these multiple discursive Islamic traditions but who also skillfully negotiate and re-articulate its veracity in the face of unprecedented ruptures wrought by the “reflexivity of modernity.” Explicating the complex nature of this process and illuminating the intricate changes within the framework of the traditional Islamic discourses it evokes is the subject of Zaman's book.
Chapter 1 investigates the South Asian ulema's responses to the challenge of colonial India. Chapters 2 and 3 illustrates the creative ways in which the ulema began to reassert their religious authority in the face of encroachments made possible by the onset of print technology. Zaman argues that the ulema rapidly adapted to the technology of print and, through discursive commentaries on classical madrasa texts, began to re-establish their traditional authority.
Chapter 4 usefully illustrates how the ulema's conception of an Islamic state differs from that of the Islamists. Non-specialist scholars—and every so often, even Islamicists—neglect this important nuance. As a consequence, analysts and policy-makers are invariably unable to fully appreciate and understand the internal diversity of contemporary Muslim movements.
Chapter 5 demonstrates how in the last decades of the 20th century, in response to the reconfiguration of the social, political, and religious landscape at the local and transnational level, the ulema in Pakistan began to take on a more radicalized political role. Zaman correctly identifies most of the important factors: the Iranian Revolution of 1979 and Pakistan's active support for the Afghan jihad against the Soviet occupation. An obvious oversight here, however, is the impact that Islamist movements or Jama

at-i-Islami, had on the ulema's new radical political stance. This oversight reveals a lot about Zaman's own bias. In trying to write a compensatory account of developments within contemporary Muslim societies, Zaman has perhaps tried too hard to downplay the wide-scale impact of Islamist movements on all aspects of Muslim societies, including the ulema. The same fault line is evident in studies of the role of the Shi

i ulema in the Iranian Revolution. To what extent Ayatollah Khomeini's revolutionizing of the quietist Shi

i theology was a direct response to the sharp critiques and reinterpretation of Shi

i theology by non-ulema Islamic intellectuals (such as the influential Iranian sociologist Ali Shari

ati) is a question that has yet to be fully explored (though the impact of Islamist ideology on the public role of the ulema is discussed, for example, in Abdul Kader Tayob's Islamic Resurgence in South Africa: The Muslim Youth Movement [Cape Town: UCT Press, 1995]).
Ironically, the major weakness of The Ulama in Contempary Islam is related to its strength. Its author dedicates the entire sixth chapter to providing his readers with a comparative perspective of the dynamics of change within the ulema of South Asia and that of Iran, Egypt, Saudi Arabia, and the southern Philippines. In making the South Asian ulema the major focus of his study, Zaman has wisely drawn on his expertise in the Urdu language and intimate knowledge of the inner dynamics of the long-standing South Asian madrasa system of Islamic learning. His fine-grained analysis of the sectarianism on which the South Asian ulema's new political role is predicated in unparalleled. Needless to say, the same detailed analysis is absent in his account of the ulema from the non–South Asian contexts. The book would have benefited from a more thorough comparison with ulema outside of the South Asian context. Nevertheless, Zaman has opened the way for scholars with greater expertise in these contexts and languages to confirm or contest his findings through similar thick descriptive studies.
The Ulama in Contemporary Islam caters primarily to an academic audience. The non-specialist may find the book's technical terms and subtle discourse heavy going. The language is lucid, but the author has a penchant for trying to do too many things in one sentence. Moreover, time and again the lengthy sentences commence with “yet.” This, combined with a few other glaring grammatical errors, such as “which is emphasizes” (p. 11), clearly suggests that the book might have benefited from more careful editing. Readers will, however, find the carefully constructed glossary useful in understanding traditional vocabulary and concepts. The book is richly annotated and has a useful index and an extensive bibliography that expose the reader to most, if not all, of the most influential contemporary studies on religion and Muslim society. The book fills an important gap within existing research on contemporary Islam and is essential reading for anyone interested in understanding the dynamics of change and authority structures within Muslim societies.