The volume under review has its origins in a conference held in 2012 as part of the Syrian-Norwegian research project ‘Palmyrena: City, Hinterland and Caravan Trade between Orient and Occident’. The resulting publication presents an overview of research conducted in Palmyra and its hinterland prior to the outbreak of the civil war in 2011 and the subsequent uncertainty of the future of Palmyrene studies. Since the publication of the volume, two monographs — from Eivind Seland in 2016 and Jørgen Christian Meyer in 2017 — have been released as part of the same project.
The volume's editors seek to expand our understanding of the relationship between Palmyra, its hinterland and systems of long-distance trade (iv), and the papers presented largely satisfy this aim. The contributions examine various aspects of the history, culture and archaeology of Palmyra in the longue durée, ranging from the Bronze Age to the Byzantine era. In what follows, I give an overview of the papers included and discuss some particular examples in further detail.
The first five contributions deal with Palmyra's role in trade networks, and collectively form the most coherent line of inquiry in the volume (1–48). Marta Żuchowska and Taco Terpstra respectively investigate Palmyrene trade with the East (29–38) and the West (39–48). At first glance, Kristina Hesse's paper (1–10) on the interaction of social groups in the Old Babylonian period might seem at odds with a collection on classical Palmyra; but her discussion of the relationships between settled and nomadic groups in the region shares many conclusions with Michael Sommer's contribution to the volume (11–18). For such a short article, Sommer presents a number of complex ideas; I think that one has to refer to his 2005 monograph (Roms orientalische Steppengrenze) in order to see his argument in full. In the present volume, Sommer reiterates his not-uncontroversial thesis that ‘there is little evidence that Palmyra's organisational structure resembled that of a Greek polis’ (14). This interpretation is part of the wider critique of Maurice Sartre's view of Palmyra as ‘une cité grecque’ (AArchArabSyr 42 (1996), 385–405), within which many scholars instead correctly emphasise the city's uniqueness (for example, T. Kaizer, Klio 89 (2007), 39–60; A. M. Smith, Roman Palmyra (2013), 132–43). Nevertheless, Sommer's uncompromising presentation of this viewpoint — particularly with reference to the ‘four tribes of the city’ — needs more extended discussion than he is able to give in this volume. Michał Gawlikowski's excellent paper is also worthy of particular mention (19–28). Beginning with the re-interpretation of a bilingual inscription from the Bel precinct, Gawlikowski re-evaluates the nature of Palmyra's eastern trade routes. His conclusions — that Palmyrene traders did not use the so-called ‘Silk Road’ across modern-day Iran, and that Palmyra's oriental trade primarily served the needs of the Syrian market — are of great significance to Palmyrene studies. Collectively, these five papers re-evaluate a number of assumptions regarding Palmyra's role in facilitating trade networks across the region and thus make a valuable contribution to Palmyrene studies.
The second group of papers investigate the city of Palmyra itself and its regional context (49–114). In contrast to the previous group, the majority of these contributions are archaeological case-studies or methodological papers, although two papers deviate from this. Firstly, Paola Mior's contribution combines archaeological, geographical and epigraphical data to identify the road from Palmyra to Damascus mentioned in the Tabula Peutingeriana, a medieval copy of a possible Roman original map of the region (49–57). This paper will undoubtedly be a useful resource for future work on this topic. Secondly, Pavel Alipov's paper follows the historiographical legacy of Michael Rostovtzeff, particularly focusing on the study of Palmyrene religious cults (87–91). Alipov's contribution is interesting and readable, but it does not sufficiently clarify the impact of this research on Palmyrene studies more broadly. Also of particular note from this second group is the excellent contribution from Christiane Römer-Strehl, who presents an analysis of different cultural influences on Palmyrene pottery and evaluates the impact of this analysis on the question of Palmyrene identity (107–14). She notes that the lack of a ‘distinct general Palmyrene style in the ceramics’ evidences the flexibility with which the Palmyrenes adopted different styles and thus emphasises the importance of their role as traders to the construction of Palmyrene identity (112). The paper provides another useful viewpoint on Palmyrene trade, and thus complements the first five papers discussed above.
The volume closes with four papers from Japanese scholars, who present archaeological case-studies on tombs and skeletal remains (115–70), and one paper from Knut and Jonatan Krzywinski on the potential for crop production in Palmyra's hinterland in the Byzantine period (171–83). These papers will clearly make an important contribution to Palmyrene studies within their specialist fields.
Palmyrena presents a diverse group of noteworthy papers that are testament to the interdisciplinary research community working at the site before the outbreak of the civil war. Whilst the volume does not have the elegiac quality of Paul Veyne's Palmyre: l'irremplaçable trésor (2015) or Annie Sartre-Fauriat and Maurice Sartre's Palmyre: vérités et légendes (2016), the many votes of thanks and sympathy throughout the work are nonetheless touching. Palmyrena gives a clear sense of the diversity of Palmyrene studies and will continue to be a useful resource for the field moving forward.
