No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 23 September 2005
Bird has written a well-researched and engaging account of the Kurds, a people who figure prominently in the milieu of current politics in Iraq, Turkey, Iran, and Syria. The strength of the book is the way Bird weaves together several strands of thought: her own insightful perceptions, questions, and reactions; an astute account of Kurdish culture past and present; and Kurdish political history. Historical accounts, folktales, music, dance, first-person experiences, and introspective analysis build on a sound base of research to paint the most complete and engaging picture of the contemporary Kurdish experience to date.
The intrepid Bird spends most of her time among the Kurds of Iraq and deftly paints a picture of their culture and politics. Bird deserves praise for the honesty and wide range of her inquiry, which encompasses both Kermanji- and Sorani-speaking regions, KDP- and PUK-controlled zones, and the Yezidi Kurdish religious minority and the Assyrian Christian community. She does not flinch from discussing the (at times) acrimonious relations among these groups or from describing the authoritarian tendencies of the main Kurdish political parties. Her trenchant critique of the oil-for-food program and the “culture of dependency” it created in the Kurdish quasi-state from 1997 to 2003 is a view that deserves much wider discussion. Since her three-month visit occurred prior to the United States invasion of Iraq, she focused on the Kurdish-controlled regions and excluded Kirkuk, a contested city between Kurds and Arabs, and its Turkman minority.
Sections on Iran, Turkey, and Syria are shorter than one would hope but nevertheless match the Iraq chapters in the rich tapestry of personal observation woven with history, folklore, and social commentary. While most of Bird's observations about politics, history, and society are spot on, her frequent references to “democracy” in Turkey beg for a definitional starting point that makes a clear distinction between electoral democracy and liberal democracy. Syrian Kurds would be the first to disagree with her observation that their oppression has been somewhat less odious than that suffered by Kurds in Turkey, Iraq, and Iran.
Because she is neither a historian nor a social scientist, Bird raises more questions than she can provide answers to, but to her credit the questions are excellent ones that suggest areas of study for an area specialist. How has modernization affected gender relations among the Kurds? How can one account for the upsurge of interest in Islam among Kurdish youth? How much permanent social and economic change can be managed by the state (top-down) versus emanating from individual choices and adaptations (bottom-up)?
As Bird herself states, this book is not primarily about politics or history. It is a finely wrought traveler's tale that documents her own process of discovery about a people she knew little about before undertaking her journey into Kurdistan. With skill and clarity she documents the complexity of the Kurdish experience—its struggles with tradition and modernity; the various competing tribal, religious, and national identities Kurds face; fraught gender relations and generation gaps. While the scholar will wish for traditional footnotes and a more systematic analysis of the many important questions Bird addresses, there is nevertheless ample insight in this volume to engage academic and lay readers.