The study of death within an individual religious tradition can take a number of forms. One concentrates on the place that death holds in the philosophical thought of the tradition. A recent example of this is Jan Assman's Death and Salvation in Ancient Egypt (Hamilton, N.Y.: Cornell University Press, 2005). Assman examines how the idea of death served as a generator for the thought superstructure of an entire tradition. In Muhammad's Grave: Death Rites and the Making of Islamic Society, Leor Halevi examines death from a different direction. His interest is mostly in the social forms that surround death and the way those forms interact with formal religious thought.
Each chapter but one of Halevi's book addresses a different social form related to death. In order, these include tombstones, washing the corpse, shrouds, wailing for the dead, public processions, and tombs. This series of topics allows for a pleasing mixture of material remains (tombstones, shrouds, tombs) and social practices (washing the corpse, wailing for the dead, processions). In examining each, Halevi follows a careful methodology. He begins by relating an example of the practice in question drawn from the life of Muhammad or some other early Islamic figure. This becomes the jumping-off point for a detailed look at the topic, typically involving three separate concerns: the prescriptive content of hadith and early legal texts, the social practices as they can be determined through material remains or other forms of evidence, and the parallel practices of Christians, Jews, and Zoroastrians. Each chapter involves a careful triangulation of these sources to resuscitate the lively debates revolving around how to treat the deceased in a fully Islamic way.
Chapter 4, on wailing for the dead, is exemplary of Halevi's method. Islam inherited from the jāhiliyya the tradition of women loudly wailing at the death of a loved one. This tradition of wailing is evident from the remains of pre-Islamic poetry and early Islamic reflection on the origins of this practice. The introduction of Islam brought about a new discourse concerning the treatment of the deceased as pietists began to teach that “silence, haste, and austerity” should be the marks of the Muslim treatment of death. Efforts were thus made to curtail women's wailing. It was in the community at Kufa that this curtailment was most zealously pursued. Halevi also points out that Christian, Jewish, and Zoroastrian communities were not nearly as interested in limiting wailing, thereby cutting off one line of thought that portrays early Muslims as conforming to the practices of the religious traditions around them. This is what I previously called “triangulation” because popular practices, Islamic legal opinions, and non-Islamic practices are each made to stand independently. This allows Halevi to pinpoint specific historical forces that gave rise to debate on this issue—as opposed to seeking one-dimensional development of theological ideas.
Muhammad's Grave is obviously an important work in reconstructing early Islamic practices surrounding death; it should win a broader audience, however, for its careful attention to the process of Islamization. The reader will be struck by the complexity of this process. It is clear from these chapters that Islamization was not under anyone's control. The pietists who formulated an ideal vision of the Islamic community could not actually impose that vision. Yet an Islamic community nevertheless did form—one that was distinguishable in numerous ways from surrounding religious communities. The end result of Islamization was not always to the liking of pietists, nor could it have been predicted, but it did turn out to be distinctive. Reflection on the process of Islamization could be pursued from any number of angles, but Halevi's focus on the practices surrounding death—which must be dealt with in every tradition—allows him a unique vantage for tracing the way in which Islam made its way into these deeply felt rituals.
The one chapter that does not quite fit the pattern described previously is the final one, “The Torture of Spirit and Corpse in the Grave.” This chapter fills out early Islamic beliefs regarding the whereabouts of the soul immediately after death, but in pursuing this topic the book breaks from its focus on social practices. Issues connected to theological envisioning of the afterlife demand their own separate treatment, and this chapter resides uneasily with the more methodologically unified chapters that precede it.
This book will be highly valued by anyone who works on early Islam and the process through which a distinctively Islamic community came about. It should be emphasized, however, that this is a book about the early development of Islam. The earliest practices and debates are illuminated, but the burial practices that led to the splendid Mamluk-era tombs in Egypt or the more exotic cultural compromises made as Islam took root in cultures beyond the Middle East are not dealt with here. Muhammad's Grave is a reminder of the complexities that we should expect to discover as we examine the process of Islamization outside his temporal and geographical frame.
