I teach at Iowa State University, a large, public university in the American Midwest. While the campus includes students, faculty and staff from around the world, most students come from Iowa and the broader Midwest. Lately, the state has felt like one of the longest-running conflict zones in the renewed culture wars. Legislators have questioned the integrity of faculty and devoted special attention to the teaching of history, pairing a law restricting the teaching of ‘divisive concepts’Footnote 1 with new laws mandating American history courses as supervised by state-endorsed campus civics centres.Footnote 2 The state’s legislative, executive and higher education leadership have been among the most active and successful at limiting Diversity, Equity and Inclusion activities, intervening in general education curricula, and encouraging the closures of academic programmes.Footnote 3 The persistent scrutiny and animosity of these attacks have depressed campus climate across the state.
Students in my classes don’t seek, and I don’t initiate, conversations about the historical precedents or echoes that these policies suggest. I continue teaching as I have, but I now observe that students’ intellectual curiosity has cautiously receded. They are now more careful, reluctant to take risks; students have heard that history class is where you can get ‘cancelled’ by wokeness or where the content is treacherously ‘controversial’. Students who are anxious and nervous have trouble trusting each other, their instructors and even their own curiosity, which makes conversations about identity and politics — essential themes in historical studies — harder.
The study of fascism is a necessary part of the curriculum in my modern European and German history classes. Students find the material difficult to understand; what they’ve been taught about fascism and fascists is more akin to a basic lesson in ‘evil’ than one in political mentalities or ideologies. To add nuance to this understanding, I emphasise some core features of the fascist ideology and worldview. Among others, I stress to my students that fascists see the world as divided into allies and collaborators on the one side and mortal, existential enemies on the other side. Existence in the world is a battle, and fascists seek the pleasure of confrontation. After the fight is won, fascists celebrate victory by pressing on towards complete annihilation of their foes. To be a fascist is to identify the enemy, attack the enemy, destroy the enemy and then degrade the defeated enemy such that they lose again and again, day after day. To a fascist, there is moral purpose in total victory, and pleasure in the power of superiority.
Today, many state legislators in the United States define professors as their enemies. Restrictions on academic freedom are imposed, reinforced, revised and added to, each time further erasing the traditions of academic freedom while revealing the powerlessness (or fecklessness) of universities. The current academic ‘reformers’ want university faculty and students interested in nuanced and complex understandings of history to kneel, be silent and have the shame of their defeat broadcast to all. This onslaught is the wellspring of students’ instinctual apprehensiveness and timidity around history.
These trends threaten to alienate professors from students, students from each other and professors from their colleagues. If alienation replaces trust and community, then it becomes nearly impossible to humanise the past. This danger is especially acute in Holocaust courses. Students in my undergraduate course ‘The Holocaust in History’ struggle to appreciate the scale of the Holocaust; not just the well-recognised ‘problem of large numbers’, but also the intimate losses experienced by individuals and communities. Because Iowa State is a majority White institution, with just a few dozen Jewish students out of a total student body over 30,000, students in my classes generally have little to no experience with Jewish life, culture or history. The distance in time and space between 2026 Iowa and the Holocaust only exacerbates the challenge. Students can usually conceptualise the idea of a ravaged culture and civilisation, but their understanding lacks immediacy or maturity because of the emotional and temporal separation.
Alongside their distance from the history of the Holocaust, my students are increasingly alienated from one another and from the wider world. The current generation of undergraduates reports itself to be lonelier and to suffer from higher rates of isolation and depression.Footnote 4 Add the tidal wave of anomie manufactured and peddled by tech companies and the anti-human future peddled by AI developers, and I see a world in which, whenever we can, we should be trying to counter these forces and build communities of trust and connection so our students can grow and learn.
My response: I ask my students to play a game. The game is Rosenstrasse (Unruly Designs, 2022), created by the indie game developers and scholars Moyra Turkington and Jessica Hammer. Rosenstrasse is a story-based, tabletop roleplaying game that uses short, improvised scenes to reenact the lives of Jewish men and Christian women married to one another and living in Berlin under Nazi rule. The game culminates in its eponymous protest against the deportation of Jewish men in February and March 1943. For one week, a score of mostly women protested the incarceration of about 2,000 Jewish men by the Gestapo at a Jewish community building on Rosenstrasse in Berlin. The protesters feared that their husbands, fathers, and sons would be deported to Auschwitz. In the end, most were released, at least in part because of this protest which was the only public demonstration in Germany against the deportation of Jews.
In the play, Rosenstrasse consists of four players sitting around a table with a fifth ‘Director’ acting as a combination narrator and guide. Each of the four players plays two characters, a man and a woman. Their two characters have no direct relationship, but each is connected to a character of a player to their right and left. In this way, the game has eight characters, four relationships, three marriages of a Jewish man and a Christian woman (two of the characters are Mischlinge) and a Jewish brother and sister, each married to a Christian spouse. The relationships are intimate and complex with realistic imperfections and challenges. The Director’s role is to keep the game on pace and otherwise support the story told by the in-character players. Play occurs over three acts with a prologue and an epilogue. Each act is divided into scenes, and these scenes are initiated by prompts on cards, told in sequence. Scenes play out to a natural emotional conclusion, ideally building out more factual and emotional elements of the characters’ lives and relationships. The story progresses through the characters’ early marriages, the implementation of the Nazis’ racial and antisemitic codes, the economic distress caused by Aryanisation, the onset of street violence, the knowledge of the deportation of unprotected Jewish Germans and the ultimate seizure of the men and the protest for their release staged by those men’s female loved ones.
You can probably imagine that asking my students to play this game was a big swing. As written, Rosenstrasse is a five-player, four-hour, intimate, and emotional exploration of love, marriage, fear and loss. Students would have to dive in, or as I later put it, ‘get over themselves,’ if this was going to be successful. They needed to get over ‘never really having done this before,’ as many said. Others needed to suppress their urge to remain aloof, to keep their inner selves bottled up. They would have to take (social and emotional) chances, play ‘pretend’ in front of their peers and recreate themselves as emotionally alive people from the past. ‘Getting over themselves’ meant imagining themselves in love and in danger, embracing vulnerability in the interests of their own learning.Footnote 5
Incorporating the game into my class required substantial planning. I had to revise my typical syllabus to make space for the game while preserving essential content that I delivered by more traditional methods. The game required me to create the right space and supportive atmosphere for students to play confidently. For assessment, I had to design tasks that would hold students accountable without distracting them from the work of play. And I had to establish an environment in the classroom that nurtured students with little or no experience in roleplaying or any other form of improvisational play. In the end, students played the game over five class sessions. After each session, they journaled responses to two prompts, one asking them to reflect ‘out-of-character’ about their learning experience, and the second asking them to write ‘in-character’ on a theme related to that session’s events. At the conclusion of the game, students crafted an analytical essay integrating their play with selected secondary and primary sources.
Though the planning presented challenges, the game’s pedagogical benefits made it worth the risk. In general, play offers new learning opportunities.Footnote 6 By allowing my students to lean into play and emotions, Rosenstrasse provided the opportunity to deepen their experiential understanding of the Holocaust. Theorists of games and play argue that humans at play enter an intermediate space between the real and the imaginary that fulfils a distinct and essential element of human experience. Because of their liminal nature, games allow humans to investigate and experiment with reality through play. Gordon Calleja stresses that play ‘heightens awareness of the present moment’, and that communal play creates durable and lasting feelings of community.Footnote 7 In these times of oppressive alienation, I knew that a well-planned game could help centre humanity in my classroom.
I also knew that by asking the students to inhabit their roles, the game could foster and encourage human connection in two configurations: first, in contemporary reality as students built trust and emotional moments through their imaginations; and second, across time as they creatively inhabited the lives of German Jews and Christians in 1930s and 1940s Berlin. While playing the game, the students had to partially become that person facing danger and oppression from the Nazi state. For example, in Act II, the young couple of Annaliese (Christian) and Max (Jewish) are forced to relocate from their small apartment to an even smaller space in a Judenhaus. The scene builds around the couple’s conversations as they pack up their belongings, encouraging the characters to reminisce about their relationship; at the same time, it allows the players to experience the dislocation and dispossession forced upon them by the National Socialists.
As my students played the game over five class sessions, I observed as their small groups practised emotional connection and lived (in admittedly circumscribed and improvised ways) the experiences of Jewish-Christian couples during the Third Reich. Students seemed to agree that play brought them together. One appreciated his group’s agreement to ‘let go of any uncertainties and fully give ourselves to the game … [and to] support[] one another through this journey’.Footnote 8 Another student reflected on the opportunity to bring her emotional side into play with the game, to be ‘open with our feelings … like we would with everything else in our lives’. As one player put it, the game helped him ‘better understand the emotional side of history’. As another student summed up the experience, without the game he ‘probably never would’ve been able to put [him-]self into the shoes of a Jewish man’. Finally, as another student wrote, ‘I think a positive part of Rosenstrasse was getting out of my comfort zone.’ She continued, ‘[A]ll of my group members were feeling nervous too, so being in an environment where everyone was patient and still trying to have fun … was a very good experience.’
Students also found the sessions kindled their appreciation for the daily experiences of Jewish people and their loved ones during the Holocaust. The game helped them ‘understand the emotions people might have felt like fear, pressure, and confusion. It showed how difficult everyday choices were’. For example, one key scene in the game has the couple Klara (Christian) and Josef (Jewish) debating whether to baptise their children. The student playing Josef shared her reluctance to give up that part of Josef’s identity (all players play a woman and a man). She felt the burden of the decisions, ‘something [she] wasn't expecting’ and she sensed her scene partner felt the tension, too. Her scene partner’s own reflective essay confirmed he recognised the gravity of the situation. In another group, a student described the anxiety he felt playing Izak, a working-class and eventually impoverished Jewish man whose Christian wife leaves him to shelter their children. The student recognized the pain of being a father unsure whether he could feed his children or even keep a promise of a visit to the park. At the same time, Rosenstrasse also allowed students to feel the joy their characters felt – as in a family celebration of a Seder or the characters Kurt and Inge’s proud discussion of their children's futures.
I doubt that I have ever managed with more conventional discussions or lectures to achieve this level of empathetic appreciation of the intimate, heart-rending ‘choice-less choices’ forced by Nazi oppression. Judging from these students’ reflections on the activity, Rosenstrasse played out as exactly the sort of teaching intervention I sought. Students engaged with historical questions in a more emotional and open manner, and that engagement was facilitated by the human connections that the game created both among the students and between the students and the characters they played. Playing the game also linked historical content and learning with areas of experiential pleasure; students understandably struggled to explain that they thought the game was ‘fun’. I know they did not mean they felt good as their characters suffered, but instead they felt rewarded by the activity and appreciated the emotional connections that they experienced.
The game makes allowances for players to shy away from attending the Rosenstrasse protests in Act III. But most players lean towards that hopeful part of the story, the part in which love joined with courage. In fact, the entire tone of the game is one that recognises the importance of human love and its ability to prevail. I asked students to reflect on their characters’ decision to attend the protests, and they often explained their characters’ bravery as showing a commitment to the future of their families. One also claimed a desire to retain agency, ‘control over my life’. And a third found hope in the story they told with their classmates. These emotional responses of empowerment, hope and love seem, to me, to be valuable experiences for students to have in a time when historians and the study of history are caught up in a cloud of negativity inspired by anxiety and hostile actors.
Playing Rosenstrasse in class is a big commitment, and it requires significant preparation and planning; teaching with it means that some other material receives less time or attention. It also demands a lot of students and their instructor. I present it here as an example of what is possible and to suggest a new approach to teaching about fascism in these times: as a response to a political and cultural situation that feels hostile to honest historical teaching and the ongoing project of higher education. I want to share one way that I have chosen to confront the aggressive hostility that many academics and students feel right now.
I encourage other teachers to find their own examples, big or small, of Rosenstrasse. Some of you may wish to take it up and use the game yourselves, in which case I am happy to offer my advice and support in that endeavour. But others may want to do something else better suited to their style, disposition, or campus community. For the latter, the main point I suggest you take away from my experiences with roleplaying in the history classroom is to be bold and brave. History is not outdated just because it looks to the past; we know our subject matter is not boring. But we need to find ways to show our students how exciting and powerful this work can be. I encourage you to try new things, to innovate and to do what you can to build joy into what you are doing. While our students come to us with some kind of curiosity about history, they may be anxious about the work and unenthusiastic about lectures and readings. I don't suggest losing those methods, as they are still valuable, but we can reinforce our students’ choices to study history by feeding their passions and helping them find joy in the study of the past, even when the past is unpleasant.
The anti-intellectual assault on universities and the steady impulse to restrict and limit historical teaching, paired with antidemocratic waves across the Atlantic, have filled many historians with despair and anxiety. This is by design; the current forces assaulting the freedoms of universities see themselves in a Manichean struggle for civilisation. And part of their impulse is to see their enemies defeated, scared and demoralised. In my position, I can do little to fight back in the arenas of public and civic power, but I choose not to give in. I refuse to feel bad about my work as a historian and teacher, and I do not want to take a ‘last stand’ approach. Instead, I choose to counter their negativity by teaching through human connection and shared joy. I think you should too.
Acknowledgements
I would like to acknowledge Jessica Hammer and Moyra Turkington, the brilliant designers of Rosenstrasse; Evan Torner who provided valuable advice as I prepared to teach with the game; and, finally, the students in my courses, History of Modern Germany and The Holocaust in History from Spring 2023 and Fall 2025, respectively, for ‘getting over themselves’ and playing Rosenstrasse with deep emotional honesty and open-minded curiosity. Finally, I would like to thank my brother, Chris, for introducing me to roleplaying more than thirty years ago with an adventure for a brave ranger played by me.
Jeremy Best is an associate professor of history at Iowa State University of Science and Technology in Ames, Iowa. He is the author of Heavenly Fatherland: German Missionary Culture and Globalization in the Age of Empire (University of Toronto Press, 2021). His current research is on the relationship between Cold War-era tabletop wargames and their influence on historical memory of the Second World War and the Holocaust.
