In pre-1970 Argentina, to all but a handful of diplomats and international law specialists, human rights were largely unknown as a unifying set of problems. Argentines understood the ingredients that would come to define human rights in the 1970s − the specific abuses associated with authoritarian rule and state terror, foremost among which were torture and murder. But two factors made the term commonplace and its meanings transcendent in the 1970s as ‘human rights’. First, dictatorship in Argentina, neighbouring Chile and elsewhere in South America became more punishing. And second, followed quickly by nascent South American human-rights groups, Amnesty International emerged as a vociferous and powerful advocate on human rights in Chile and Argentina. The lawyer Raúl Alfonsín was one of the best-known 1970s Argentine human-rights defenders. His inauguration as president of Argentina in December 1983 ushered in the decade that this excellent book addresses. When Alfonsín died in 2009, one Argentine working-class woman of colour wondered aloud whether anybody at his funeral might have hollered in reference to the disastrous inflation in the 1980s, ‘¿Y el precio de la leche?’ (‘And what about the price of milk?’). For many Argentines, as Jennifer Adair points out, the Alfonsín years (1983–9) represented economic and political failure, manifest in disastrous inflation. As more than one wag has put it, the Radicals (Alfonsín's governing political party) have always been a bit less corrupt and a bit less competent at managing the economy than the Peronistas (their long-standing political rivals).
But in this masterful analysis of post-dictatorship Argentina through the 1980s, drawing on a broad range of archival and other sources, Adair demonstrates three key arguments that turn orthodoxies on their ear. First, letters from ordinary Argentines to the president that the author uncovered in the Archivo General de la Nación, among a range of other sources, show strong popular support for the president – and growing dismay over Argentina's direction under his lead. Second, the 1980s democratic transition – led by Alfonsín – focused policy on a broad set of problems that human rights had come to mean for Argentines during military rule. The president campaigned on and equated political rights with social and physical wellbeing. To be sure, the 1980s Radical government was not the first to take on poverty, hunger and other social ills. But as Adair argues, it was the first to do so in a policy context that drew on the urgency of solutions in what she describes as ‘everyday rights’, building on human rights. Third, in what constitutes the best social history of this period (written in a dazzlingly tight 130 pages, minus notes and bibliography), Adair argues that in the ways in which Alfonsín's political project moved cabinet office policy to the streets, the 1980s marked a period of remarkable and successful popular politics.
The book begins with the end of military rule and introduces a problem that never stopped dogging the Alfonsín administration: Argentina's massive foreign debt. Adair then focuses on the 1983 presidential election campaign and follows Argentine government efforts in the 1980s to end hunger and to bring economic stability. The most significant social welfare initiative of the new government was the Programa Alimentario Nacional (National Food Programme, PAN) that both exposed a long-concealed crisis in middle-class media circles (hunger in Argentina) and sought to stop the crisis through the mass delivery of non-perishable food to affected communities. By the mid-1980s, the Alfonsín administration's inability to end growing poverty opened the door for renewed Peronista strength – politically, socially and culturally. Adair goes on to document the Caso Mazzorín, a disastrous government food purchase and distribution programme that helped prime Argentine government policy towards neoliberal economics in the 1990s. The book wraps up with Adair's analysis of the thousands of letters she found from ordinary Argentines to Alfonsín and the disastrous 1989 food riots that brought down the president and that made evident the persistent poverty in Argentina.
The book's greatest strength is starting by setting aside the elephant in the room without ignoring it. Wracked by foreign debt, runaway inflation and a broad range of economic and social problems it simply could not control, Alfonsín's government could not achieve its most ambitious anti-poverty policy objectives. But at the same time, Adair does comprehensively and compellingly argue what others have not: she establishes that, despite these failures, 1980s Argentina was a path-breaking period for popular democracy expressed in the language of human rights. Even in one of Alfonsín's greatest moments of crisis – the 1989 food riots – popular democratic expression reflected precisely the sorts of changes in everyday politics and rights that Alfonsín had sought. During May 1989, when the media described looting in Buenos Aires, Rosario and other Argentine cities, those on the front lines of protest were often working-class women accompanied by their children. This was no performance. It was unprecedented political action from people who had been promised an end to hunger by their government and were now taking matters into their own hands. Interviewed by the media, one woman spoke for many in rejecting accusations that nefarious political groups had sent people into grocery stores to loot. In an unprecedented demand for their rights, they were there to feed their families.
My only criticism of In Search of the Lost Decade comes despite my case for its tight and effective prose in expertly explaining the legacy of the 1980s. I wish that Adair had devoted more space to the legacy of her most important finding – that the Alfonsín years changed popular democracy and politics in Argentina. She spends a few pages at the end discussing how those changes played out after 1990, but there's much more she might have said in considering the ever-evolving place of human rights and everyday rights in Argentine popular culture.
