Jean-Jacques Rousseau (1712–1778) is indisputably one of the most important, innovative and challenging figures of the European Enlightenment. His contributions as a philosopher, novelist and music theorist have received considerable attention. Yet his concerns and writings extended beyond these areas and included also scientific domains such as medicine, chemistry and botany. As Alexandra Cook shows in Jean-Jacques Rousseau and Botany: The Salutary Science, of these three fields botany was certainly the one that attracted most of Rousseau's attention, and the one that he considered as having a crucial role not only in his intellectual pursuits but also in the edification and consolation of his soul.
Alexandra Cook's full-length book is the culmination of a long and meticulous research project on the personal, social and philosophical meaning of botany for the Swiss philosopher. The research is based on a wide range of sources and, in some cases, on painstaking detective work. The book presents a substantial number of quotations from original sources, especially from works by Rousseau. In all cases, they have been kept in the original language. Although this seems to have been, at least in part, for reasons of consistency, it is also unclear to what extent this will alienate some potential readers unfamiliar with the French language. A few quotations in Latin and German are also kept in the original. The book builds also on a significant number of articles published by the author. In addition, Cook was the translator and editor of Rousseau's botanical writings in Volume 8 of the Collected Writings of Rousseau (2000) and she is now contributing to a French edition of Rousseau's Oeuvres complètes. The author's proven expertise in the subject has a clear correspondence in the detail and care maintained throughout the work, as well as in her general assertiveness. Besides the main text, Cook provides the reader with very useful lists of information, including a chronology of Rousseau's life, his botanical sources, his correspondents and his contacts, as well as his herbaria. The significant number of illustrations presented in the book should also be emphasized and, in particular, the originality and aesthetic value of Rousseau's extant compositions of dried specimens.
The first part of the book addresses the main events in Rousseau's life, especially during his interest and engagement in botanical activities which occurred from 1764 until his death in 1778. The author provides also a sense of the political, philosophical and scientific context of the period and of the places where the philosopher lived. A special emphasis is given to the development and increasing affirmation of botany in the eighteenth century and how this can be related to Rousseau's own interest in the subject. Another relevant issue highlighted in the book is how classificatory schemes of nature were considered fluid and provisional by most naturalists and amateurs of botany. Rousseau's views on the topic are certainly pertinent within this context. The author also calls attention to the many botanical activities in which Rousseau was involved, ranging from the individual contemplation of nature to activities promoting sociability such as the exchange of letters, books and specimens, as well as collecting, preserving and classifying the natural world.
The final chapters of the work are dedicated to Rousseau's legacy, which, for a long time, has been prone to historical neglect and misinterpretation. Special attention is inevitably given to the famous eight Lettres élémentaires sur la botanique and how they were appropriated mainly by Thomas Martyn, an advocate of Linnaeus's artificial system of classification, but also by others. The English professor of botany's translation and Linnaean framing of the eight letters influenced generations of botanical authors, especially women. They had a crucial role in the circulation of Rousseau's botanical ideas but contributed also to identifying the philosopher as a supporter of Linnaeus, a view that Cook explicitly denounces in her book. Instead, she argues that throughout his life Rousseau was open to the use of various forms of artificial and natural methods of classification. In this section, the author examines Rousseau's botanical legacy in terms of material culture. This is one of the most interesting and original components of the book since some of Rousseau's extant herbaria were previously unknown. These boundary objects in the access and circulation of the knowledge of nature are analysed in terms of their purpose, the techniques employed and how they differed from others produced by other eighteenth-century botanists.
Alexandra Cook's Jean-Jacques Rousseau and Botany is a major and decisive addition to the vast field of Rousseau studies and studies of eighteenth-century botany. It shows how his dedication to botany for a significant period of his life had implications for his emotional, intellectual and social life and how he was part of larger and dynamic processes in accessing and ordering the knowledge of nature.
