There have been many books written on the history of McCarthyism, but Phillip Deery offers fresh insights in this new treatment. Interrogating not the origins of the Second Red Scare but also its effects, Deery explores the human costs of that period of political intolerance by examining the lives of six men who experienced persecution characteristic of the era. He personalizes the history of McCarthyism by showing how appearances before Congressional and Senate committees, federal convictions for contempt of Congress, loss of jobs and blacklisting, FBI surveillance, rumors, and broken personal relationships dramatically altered the lives of these men.
Deery focusses on New York City because it was the “epicenter of the Communist Party of the United States of America (CPUSA)” (3) and “became a crucible in which the politics of the Cold War was fought with bitterness and intensity” (2). This geographic focus, along with the close analysis of his six main subjects, allows Deery to delve deeply into the mechanisms of McCarthyism. His fine-grained examination of the bureaucracy of repression that marked the era is one of the most impressive contributions of the book. So too is the sensitivity with which he uses his sources, as he notes how the anticommunist individuals, groups and organizations that targeted his subjects “worked in tandem, although not necessarily in collusion,” with each other (1). Deery skillfully teases out the delicate web of cooperation and independent agency among those anticommunists. In his discussion of the political persecution of Edward Barsky, for example, the medical doctor and founder of the Joint Anti-Fascist Refugee Committee (JAFRC), Deery shows us the inner workings of HUAC and the federal court system (in which Barsky was convicted for contempt of Congress). But he also reveals the ways the Attorney General's List and the IRS went after the JAFRC, eviscerating it by 1955; how the New York Board of Regents, on its own accord, revoked Barsky's medical license; and how the FBI's infiltration of JAFRC contributed to the atmosphere of fear. In his chapter on Howard Fast, the famous writer, Deery similarly uncovers the complicated cascade of accusation, rumor, and repression that followed Fast's refusal to testify before HUAC, and he charts an analogous path for two NYU professors who also became caught in the web of McCarthyism: Lyman Bradley and Edwin Berry Burgum. In addition to reclaiming these less well-known figures from the past, Deery's chapters – largely made possible by his extensive use of recently declassified FBI files – demonstrate just how pervasive and far-reaching were the methods of McCarthyism.
Deery's final two chapters diverge somewhat from the first three. The case study on the Russian composer Dimitri Shostakovitch at first seems misplaced. The Cultural and Scientific Conference for World Peace (aka the Waldorf Conference) held in New York in 1949 was attended by Shostakovitch, who voiced Stalin's critique of the US and renounced the “bourgeois formalism” of his own musical work. At the time, the conference (which Deery admits was a Communist Party front initiative) became a target of American anticommunists and in this sense there is a connection to McCarthyism. But there is not in this chapter the complex interplay of domestic political repression aimed at its chief subject, as found in the others. What links this case to the larger story is the poignancy of the inner turmoil that men like Shostakovitch faced when they were caught up in the political fights of the era as they tried to preserve their livelihoods. This connection could have been more clearly drawn out, as is done in the final chapter on the activist lawyer John O. Rogge. Unlike other communists-turned-anticommunist of the era, Rogge remained committed throughout his life to the principles of civil liberties and the rule of law and he defended them against both the right and the left and against both the US and the Soviet Union. Recovering Rogge's story is another of the significant contributions of Deery's book: because of his evenhanded approach to the history of communism he brings this forgotten critic of both the right and the left back into the story, revealing just as much about the repression of Rogge's day as about the scholarly currents since that have often obscured such voices calling for a middle way.
Deery, however, only touches upon the stories of a few women, most extensively that of Helen Bryan, administrative secretary of the JAFRC. She, like Barsky and Bradley, served time for contempt of Congress. He also mentions Bradley's wife, Ruth, who was bitter over the dismissal of her husband from NYU, and Burgum's wife, Mildred, who committed suicide, but we only get glimpses of their stories. It seems like a missed opportunity to explore in his scrupulous manner just how the techniques of McCarthyism may have played out for women who were caught in its web. There may not have been a Board of Regents or a university administration to work in tandem with the FBI and the HUAC, but surely there were their equivalents in the world of these women. Uncovering those links would shed even more light on the human costs of the Red Scare and fill in what remains an incomplete picture. And one minor factual quibble – the mass political incarceration of Barsky, Bradley and sixteen others associated with JAFRC was not, as Deery claims, “the first since the Palmer raids nearly thirty years before” (11–12). That honor goes to the eighteen Trotskyists who were the first to be convicted under the Smith Act in 1941 and who served prison terms beginning in 1943. But even if the JAFRC defendants and others examined in the book were not the “first” to be subjected to such prosecution, their stories are still important for our understanding of the human impact of the Second Red Scare. And Deery's book is a welcome addition to this history. His meticulously detailed case studies and critical use of new sources enrich our understanding of just how McCarthyism worked on the grassroots level and how high were its human costs in broken lives and careers.
