As noted in the introduction to this book, traditional justice mechanisms have triggered substantial debate in the field of transitional justice. Huyse summarises it: “the debate is a clash between two opposing models” positioned at “extremes of a continuum”. At one end of the continuum are scholars who favour traditional justice mechanisms as the most legitimate and effective fora for reconciliation in a given society, praising the bottom-up nature of these mechanisms and arguing that these forms of justice have been practised for centuries.Footnote 1 At the other end are staunch supporters of retributive and prosecutorial approaches, who are sceptical and dismissive of traditional justice mechanisms, arguing that they fail to reach minimum fair trial standards or do not uphold the duty to prosecute crimes against humanity, genocide and war crimes.Footnote 2 However, Huyse says there is currently a move away from “a de facto dichotomy (impunity or trials) to multiple conceptions of justice and reconciliation”. (Emphasis original) The 2004 report of the UN secretary general on the rule of law and transitional justice in conflict and post-conflict societies, for instance, notes that “due regard must be given to indigenous and informal traditions for administering justice or settling disputes”.Footnote 3
This book evaluates the role of traditional justice mechanisms in dealing with the atrocities committed during armed conflict in Rwanda, Mozambique, Uganda, Sierra Leone and Burundi. The book's even-handed and methodologically sound assessment makes it a valuable resource for academics, practitioners and policymakers alike.
The first chapter introduces the theories in the field of transitional justice and reconciliation, and examines the debates around traditional justice mechanisms. It also addresses problems of terminology and methodology. For example, it discusses the appropriateness of the term “traditional”, when the case studies show that “traditions” are continuously changing. The book uses the term “traditional” for want of a better alternative, but the case studies demonstrate a commitment to tracing the evolution of the traditional mechanisms under scrutiny. Huyse also engages with the issue of ethnocentrism. He argues that western scholars are at risk of romanticizing or simply misunderstanding socio-political phenomena in Africa. In order to avoid this, all but one of the case studies were written by African scholars.Footnote 4 Huyse introduces the core notions that will be used throughout the book to assess the value of traditional justice mechanisms in dealing with the legacies of a violent past. He argues that transitional justice has two general objectives: healing the wounds of victims; and restoring societal relations. These objectives are achieved through the “instrumental objectives” of reconciliation, accountability, truth telling and reparations. The five case studies in the book evaluate the extent to which traditional justice mechanisms contain elements of these instrumental objectives in order to assess their contribution to the general objectives of transitional justice.
In his case study of the Gacaca courts in post-genocide Rwanda in chapter 2, Bert Ingelaere labels the modern Gacaca “an invented tradition” that is fundamentally different from traditional Gacaca. The core aim of these state-sponsored Gacaca mechanisms is accountability for the crime of genocide and other crimes against humanity. Elements of restorative justice and reconciliation were only added later. Ingelaere points out that many Rwandans are fatigued and disappointed with the process. Participation is no longer voluntary, but must be coerced. In the perception of many Rwandans, Gacaca is merely an “instrument of the state”, and uncovers a partial and one-sided truth. Of greatest concern is Hutu disillusionment with the court's failure to address Rwandan Patriotic Front crimes and Tutsi revenge killings. The author is concerned that such grievances may create a Hutu subculture.
In chapter 3, Victor Igreja and Beatrice Dias-Lambranca discuss restorative justice and reconciliation in post-war Mozambique. Mozambique had no government policy on reconciliation with the country's violent past. Rather, the policy was to “forgive and forget”. Igreja and Dias-Lambranca argue that, contrary to the idea that unaddressed grievances will cause new cycles of violence, survivors in the district of Gorongosa employed socio-cultural practices to deal with the atrocities of the war. The authors focus on the phenomenon of magamba spirits: spirits of dead soldiers who return to claim justice. When a person is possessed by a gamba spirit, a gamba healer conducts a public ceremony to appease the spirit. During this ceremony, the gamba spirit (speaking through the possessed person) makes indictments and discloses the truth regarding a particular violent act. The gamba healer then mediates public discussion in order to determine an appropriate settlement. Igreja and Dias-Lambranca argue that this socio-cultural practice creates social spaces where victims can make their peace in a mediated manner that fosters reconciliation and healing. However, there are severe limitations. Christian Mozambicans do not participate in these ceremonies, and female spirits cannot return to the realm of the living and demand justice. The authors reject the argument employed by political elites that, because customary practices are working well (“Mozambicans have their own way”), formal justice is not needed. They argue that there is no excuse for state inaction regarding the legacy of the civil war.
In the fourth chapter, James Ojera Latigo discusses several tradition-based practices in the Acholi region of northern Uganda. Mato Oput, for example, is a rite of reconciliation used to repair social relations after the spilling of human blood. During this ceremony, members from different clans drink from the same cup containing an extract from the root of the oput tree mixed with an alcoholic drink in order to restore social order. The author derives essential principles from these mechanisms to understand the nature of conflict resolution in Acholi culture. Latigo concludes that, in northern Uganda, traditional systems of justice incorporate principles of both restorative and retributive justice. He argues that the aim is peace before justice, as the objective is the reintegration of perpetrators, and that this is directly opposed to the retributive approach, where justice comes before peace. This conclusion is especially significant in light of the International Criminal Court arrest warrants for senior Lord's Resistance Army commanders. According to Latigo, though Acholi culture has been under significant stress during the conflict and subsequent internal displacement, the Acholi continue to adhere to their spiritual beliefs and their perceptions of truth, justice, forgiveness and reconciliation. He concludes that a complementary approach to transitional justice is needed in Uganda, where western elements and the traditional Acholi mechanisms can operate alongside each other.
In chapter 5 on Sierra Leone, Joe Alie evaluates the traditional practices of the Kpaa Mende after a brief discussion of the other transitional justice mechanisms employed in the country: the Truth and Reconciliation Commission; and the Special Court for Sierra Leone. He argues that the justice systems of the Kpaa Mende are both restorative and retributive. The principal aims are reconciliation and the restoration of social harmony, but there may be some degree of punishment depending on the severity of the crime. What becomes clear in Alie's discussion of the Kpaa Mende mechanisms is the strong, progressive approach to justice. The ultimate aim is reconciliation, and there is a belief that what is done is done, as reflected in the saying “when a gun is fired, it is fired”. Despite the erosion of the foundations of the Kpaa Mende belief system during the civil war, and the fact that traditional justice mechanisms were never suitable for dealing with severe crimes such as war crimes and crimes against humanity, Alie argues that these mechanisms have a role to play in transitional justice in Sierra Leone. He points out that traditional mechanisms have proved very useful for the reintegration of child soldiers, for example.
In chapter 6, Assumpta Naniwe-Kaburahe discusses the bashingantahe in Burundi. The bashingantahe is an institution of wise and respectable men that has existed in Burundi as a check and balance to power since the early 17th century, with responsibility for settling conflict through mediation, conciliation and arbitration. In order to become an umushingantahe [member of the bashingantahe], candidates must show that they possess outstanding moral fibre. The author describes how the institution was severely weakened by judicial reforms during the colonial period and was abused for political gain during the early post-colonial period. However, she argues that the bashingantahe has retained its authority and is still considered an important symbol of justice in Burundi. After the widespread ethnic massacres in 1993, umushingantahe were hailed as heroes. During the conflict they protected persecuted individuals and arrested killers and looters in order to retain a semblance of justice. After the crisis, they took the lead in reconciliation and forgiveness. The institution was modernized and incorporated into the transitional justice framework of Burundi after 1996. This revival was strongly supported by international donors and NGOs. The author argues that, despite various challenges, the bashingantahe can play a significant role in the establishment of the rule of law and reconciliation and reconstruction in Burundi.
In chapter 7, Huyse uses the case studies in earlier chapters to draw conclusions and make recommendations. He identifies two main limitations. First, traditional mechanisms have a “limited range of action”. Their effect differs greatly along lines of ethnicity, religion, age and gender. Secondly, there are “difficult process conditions”. Traditional mechanisms were not designed to deal with war crimes and crimes against humanity, and the case studies suggest that they may only ever be useful as a complement to criminal justice. The traditional foundations of these mechanisms have been eroded by violent conflict. Due to widespread poverty in the countries discussed in the book, there are insufficient resources for many of the rituals and ceremonies to be conducted properly. In addition, due to mass migration and refugee flows, the environments of refugee camps and urban shack dwellings are often not compatible with traditional mechanisms. Huyse distils core strengths from the case studies with regard to the objectives of transitional justice: accountability; reconciliation; truth telling; and restoration of community relations. He argues that traditional justice mechanisms can be a good alternative to trials, due to the proximity and visibility of justice they provide to survivors. Because these mechanisms are still firmly rooted in local values, traditional justice may create a collective and open atmosphere, which may stimulate telling the truth. With regard to reconciliation, Huyse argues that there is some evidence that traditional justice mechanisms can restore community ties, but that it is mostly too soon to tell whether these mechanisms have deterred further violence. The book cautiously concludes that traditional justice mechanisms can be partially effective and partially legitimate, that traditional justice and conflict resolution tools have an added value in times of transition, and that they can effectively complement formal criminal justice. Finally, Huyse makes various policy recommendations to enhance the effectiveness of tradition-based practices.
A striking similarity between the traditional mechanisms discussed in the book is the exclusion of women.Footnote 5 Though most of the contributions note that this exclusion is problematic, only the case study on Burundi discusses this issue in detail. The policy recommendations in the book's conclusion include: that female war survivors be offered complementary opportunities for voice and agency in post-conflict policy-making; and that this gender bias must be addressed. The lack of further engagement with this issue is disappointing. In a book that seeks to assess the value of traditional mechanisms in post-conflict societies, the systematic exclusion of half of a given community warrants further consideration. Another potential weakness in the book is the tendency of some contributors to make sweeping and essentialist statements. In the case study on Sierra Leone for example, the author argues that Sierra Leoneans possess a unique capacity for forgiveness. Such generalizations made by a European or North American academic would be considered problematic. Is such a statement legitimate when made by an African scholar?
In his introduction, Huyse acknowledges that some readers may find that “balance and neutrality have suffered” as a consequence of the choice of African scholars as contributors to this book, but argues that this approach injects “clarity into the debate on transitional justice policy choices”. Overall, one is tempted to agree with this statement. The book does make a clear and valuable contribution to research in the field of transitional justice. It shows effectively how the field would benefit from a complementary approach to different mechanisms, and how dichotomies such as retributive / restorative or peace / justice may be bridged. The case studies employ sound methodology, leading to clear and convincing conclusions. This book is therefore a valuable resource for students, academics and policy makers in the field of transitional justice.
