Globalisation has fallen on hard times. The very idea has taken on ominous connotations with the recent crisis in the world economy. Its supporters and boosters find that their arguments on the virtues of the unfettered global economy, the latter a self-serving myth given the intertwining public policies and private interests compelling it, have lost much of their lustre as the world lurches towards an economic catastrophe not seen in decades. In light of recent events, a book warning about globalisation's dark side might seem almost superfluous. Yet Aviva Chomsky's admirable study sheds light on processes that not even the belated scrutiny and contrite public debates of recent months have considered. Examining globalisation from the point of view of labour history, Chomsky demonstrates both its long lineage and the ‘links’ at work in distant and seemingly unrelated sites. Transnational approaches often fail to make persuasive arguments for such linkages, but Chomsky's book convinces the reader that globalisation, when examined from the experiences of working people, has had real and tragic consequences and, moreover, has been around for a long time.
Chomsky's study considers a series of case studies, each interesting and informative in its own right but also connected over time, following one another sequentially as patterns emerge in the dynamics of capital and labour. She begins her book examining the history of the New England textile industry, the cradle of US industrialisation, focusing on its years of decline and crisis. Early in the twentieth century, New England textile firms encouraged and benefited from international labour migrations, in these years from Europe, at the same time that they were publicly active in anti-immigrant politics. As labour costs there rose, in part due to union organisation and worker gains, Yankee industrialists cast their eyes south to the low-wage and weak union tradition of the US southern states. Industrialists first attempted to coerce workers in their New England plants into accepting reduced wages and increased work rhythms, using the threat of plant closures as an excuse for concessions from their labour forces. Chomsky documents the craven nature of some unions in the face of management's onslaught but also examples of some vigorous union opposition. The history of the American Federation of Labor (AFL) here was generally one of nativism, red-baiting and capitulation to management, but there were other examples of anarchist- and communist-led strikes, especially among newer immigrant groups in the New England textile towns. Faced with a real union opposition and mobilised workers, management had no compunctions in moving production elsewhere. The exodus of the industry to the southern US provided textile workers in South Carolina and other southern states with only a temporary boon. In the constant search for lower labour costs and weak unions, the industry continued its southern migration, to Puerto Rico and elsewhere in Latin America, while coercing wage and benefit concessions back home with the perennial threat of shutting down and moving even more factories.
The book's most interesting, albeit most depressing, pages deal with the Colombian connection. US investment in Colombia, Chomsky argues, went hand in hand with US support for repressive regimes there, a militarisation of its politics, and escalating levels of violence. Such arguments will come as no surprise to those familiar with US policy in Latin America but it may enlighten the general reading public, who represent a potential market for this book beyond the academy, given its straightforward, jargon-free narrative. One of the bitter ironies of Chomsky's story deals with the influx of Colombian immigrants in the 1960s, 1970s and 1990s – driven there partly by escalating violence in their own country abetted by US policies – to work in the now down-and-out New England textile towns as a surplus and poorly paid immigrant labour force, resuming the role that Italian and other immigrants had played in the industry early in the twentieth century. These same Colombian workers were highly valued because of their familiarity with the technology of the textile industry – an industry that had been steadily migrating south, eventually reaching their own country as management sought to export production sites to other, seemingly less problematic places. In the final sections of the book, Chomsky moves away, perhaps too abruptly, from the story of the textile industry that has been her subject for most of the book to examine the appalling implications of US government and corporate policies in other parts of Colombia – specifically in the country's northern banana and mining zones – documenting scenes not only of worker exploitation but of horrific massacres and human rights abuses of all sorts.
Intended as more than just a scholarly monograph, Chomsky's book is an indictment of the role played by the US labour movement in failing to support workers' rights internationally and indeed participating actively in their suppression through its unwavering support for Cold War anti-communism. The author does introduce a glimmer of hope in this sad story by noting some of the remarkable changes that have taken place within the US labour movement over the last quarter-century. Deep soul-searching and a critical self-examination of past policies have given the US labour movement a more internationalist perspective at any time since the heyday of the First World War in the first decades of the twentieth century. Once victims of US labour's indifference, workers in Colombia and elsewhere in Latin America are now finding a real ally in their struggles through such groups as the New Voices movement within the AFL and the AFL-CIO Solidarity Center. Chomsky's book is thus intended as both an exposé of past sins and a call to continue such labour solidarity, both out of principle and in self-interest, since globalisation has made workers' struggles irreducible to merely national contexts. Linked Labor Histories is a book with a story that scholars can certainly learn from, but it has an even more important message to concerned citizens and labour activists about the necessity of building a movement that confronts globalisation with global strategies.
