In this beautifully written book, Lisa Szefel, an assistant professor of modern American history at Pacific University in Oregon, examines the renaissance of American poetry between 1910 and 1920. Led by poets, literary critics, and institutional support, this prolific high point marked a transition from the flowery, romantic poetry of the Victorian era and “provided a foundation for a modern literary tradition to prosper” (2). With the emergence of magazines such as Poetry: A Magazine of Verse, best-selling anthologies, and short-lived magazines such as The Masses and Seven Arts, American poets and editors created forums for their work and in the process shaped the publishing practice for poetry, removing it from the solitary confines of the garret to contemporary marketing. Although this in itself would make Szefel's book worthy of a read, The Gospel of Beauty in the Progressive Era is not only about the transformation of publishing and poetry, it is also about the transformative experience of verse and its role in helping Americans negotiate the changes brought by urbanization, immigration, industrialization, and the unbridled capitalism of the era.
Szefel seeks to restore the importance of poetry and these poetic communities to the historiography of the Progressive Era. She laments, rightfully so, that historians of this era have overlooked the significance and impact of this poetic revolution and have relegated it to a footnote. Modern poetic communities grew in tandem with reform movements and played an important role in the progressive impulse that “linked creativity to a moral obligation—one sensitized to the blight and suffering inherent in modern life” (3). Poetry provided a sense of spiritual beauty and a place of refuge unsullied by the machinations of modern life, even as some of the poetry left behind the romance of the genteel verse of Victorian writing and incorporated the plight of industrialization. The poetic community, as well as religious and political communities concerned with reform, believed that “modern American life had to be about more than money and materialism, industry and individualism, and that poetic beauty could play a dramatic role in developing subjectivity and improving society” (4).
As in any work on the literary world in the Progressive Era, the major players appear in the pages of The Gospel of Beauty. Szefel includes Max Eastman, John Reed, Mabel Dodge, Floyd Dell, and many of the famous figures of turn-of-the-century New York whose lives and loves Christine Stansell meticulously chronicled in American Moderns. Footnote 1 But Szefel also includes writers whose work was perhaps not as overtly political, although one could argue there was nothing subtle about Edwin Markham's “The Man with the Hoe,” which Szefel concludes was a turning point in poetry as a social and political force.
Szefel divides her book into six chapters, five of which focus largely on individuals. While all were poets in their own right, some of their influence on poetry was not through their verse but in their contribution to the poetic community as editors (Monroe, the founding editor of Poetry) or for their business savvy (Amy Lowell). However, these chapters, for the most part, are not discrete. Even when a figure is central to the story, Szefel skillfully weaves a continuative narrative that incorporates her larger arguments.
One area of particular strength is Szefel's analysis of gender. While it would be easy to fall into the trap of providing a superficial discussion of gender that focuses on Amy Lowell's lesbianism or George Sylvester Viereck's effeminacy, Szefel sidesteps (but briefly mentions) these obvious points of departure to tackle larger gender issues. She is especially adept in her discussion of poetry and masculinity, offering a cogent analysis that situates the reform impulses to contextualize poetry in the hyper-masculinity of the era. Szefel compares attempts to write and promote more “virile” poetry with the popularity of Muscular Christianity. Just as with religion, poetry needed to be removed from the feminizing influences of the Victorian and into the vigorous new century. The trick was in writing and promoting poetry that retained some of the remnants of the romantic beauty of the Victorian era but incorporated the vigor of the modern era. It is in this analysis that Szefel makes apparent the ways in which poetry helped smooth for many the transition from Victorianism to modernism.
Unfortunately, Szefel is not as successful with her racial analysis. Although she spends a great deal of time discussing the career and influence of William Stanley Braithwaite, noting his difficulties as an African American poet and anthologist, her discussion of the larger implications of race are not as satisfactory as is her discussion of gender, even though she does provide a good analysis of black masculinity. Given the literary and cultural impact of the Harlem Renaissance, Sfezel spends too little time on black poets, and she does not include them in her larger argument in a meaningful way. Her discussion of race seems too confined to one individual and not sufficiently woven enough into the larger argument. The conflation of race and gender in one chapter is the exception to her flowing narrative.
Despite this shortcoming, The Gospel of Beauty in the Progressive Era is a significant contribution to Progressive Era and intellectual historiography. It provides an excellent addition to works such as T.J. Jackson Lear's No Place of Grace but also raises the importance of the poetic community as a subjective response to the dislocations of modernity.Footnote 2
