The best way to review this book is to explain clearly what it is and what it is not. Frontline Books, is an imprint of Pen & Sword, so this is primarily a military history written for those who want descriptions of battles supported by details of weapons, military formations, etc. The book, which is magnificently illustrated and includes excellent maps, describes the major battles fought by the Portuguese in different parts of Africa from the fifteenth to the eighteenth centuries – the attacks on the Swahili cities, the battles in Ethiopia in the 1540s, Barreto's invasion of East Africa, the battle of al-Kasr al-Kabir, the Dutch attacks on Mozambique and Luanda, and the seventeenth-century wars in Angola and Zambesia – all of them well known military events for which good accounts already exist in English. The author has brought these accounts together in a style reminiscent of Elaine Sanceau's narratives of Portuguese history, into a single manageable and readable volume, which will assuredly be welcomed by aficionados of military history. The book is also commendably careful to give detailed accounts of the African societies with which the Portuguese came into contact, providing an essential context for the battles and preventing the narrative becoming too Eurocentric.
What the book is not is a comprehensive account of Portuguese activity and influence in Africa during this period. Military history inevitably focuses on isolated and dramatic confrontations and not on the periods of cultural and economic interaction, which are usually of greater importance in understanding long term historical developments. So this is not a book that has much to say about the gradual incorporation of West African societies into the wider Atlantic economy, the growth of creole ‘broker’ communities, the arrival of American foodstuffs, the expansion of commerce and the commercial classes in African society, and the emergence of syncretic cultures and creole identities (though a lengthy description of the role of the Chikunda clients of the Portuguese, based on Allen Isaacman's work, is a welcome exception). The Cape Verde Islands and their influence do not get a mention and São Tomé features only for its impact on the Kongo region. As an example of the way this focus on purely military events can lead to distortion, we are told that ‘Portuguese soldiers … regarded all Muslims … as the bitter hereditary enemies of the Cross. As such, Mouros could expect nothing from them [the Portuguese] other than suffering and death’ (p. 5). As a generalisation about Morocco, let alone West and East Africa, this will not do. Where do the Mouros do Paz who lived for many decades under Portuguese rule fit in, or the many Muslim communities who traded with the Portuguese as allies in Eastern Africa? Mozambique Island itself had a large Muslim population whose houses occupied half the island and who lived peacefully alongside the Portuguese until the end of colonial rule.
The author, in seeking to write readable prose, drifts into exaggeration and cliché, which in the end does not help his cause. Houses are ‘stashed with ivory, carpets, sandalwood’ (p. 61); smoke is ‘acrid’ (p. 65); victories are ‘swingeing’ (p. 67)’ the African interior is described as the ‘bowels of Africa’ (p. 112); and, the pirate Mir Ali Bey goes on a ‘merry privateering spree’, his ships ‘laden to gunwales’ with plunder (p. 114). This is all embellishment on what the sources actually say. Moreover the annotation is on the thin side. This is no doubt due to the requirements of the publisher but with so much detail in the text the reader is often left wondering what the sources are for many of the facts advanced. This is especially the case for figures that are given for the size of military forces or the numbers of slaves exported.
The book is based on secondary works in English supplemented by first person accounts available in English translation. The reading is wide but in the case of East Africa does not include the books of Axelson or Mudenge (the most authoritative writer on the Mutapa state) and no use has been made of the nine volumes of translated documents on sixteenth-century Mozambique. For Angola the sources available in English are few, so the absence of the translation of Duarte Lopes account of the Kongo kingdom is significant. The focus on English editions means that no use has been made of Padre António Brásio's vast documentary collection or, more significantly, Cadornega's História geral das guerras angolanas. As a result the reader is deprived of the extraordinary account of the battle fought between the Portuguese and the followers of Pangi a Ndona in the marshes of the Dande.
