Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-fvjsw Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-17T06:41:20.802Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

The water entry of multi-droplet streams and jets

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  16 April 2018

Nathan B. Speirs
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering, Utah State University, Logan, UT 84322, USA
Zhao Pan
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering, Utah State University, Logan, UT 84322, USA
Jesse Belden
Affiliation:
Naval Undersea Warfare Center Division Newport, 1176 Howell Street, Newport, RI 02841, USA
Tadd T. Truscott*
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering, Utah State University, Logan, UT 84322, USA
*
†Email address for correspondence: taddtruscott@gmail.com

Abstract

Water entry has been studied for over a century, but few studies have focused on multiple droplets impacting on a liquid bath sequentially. We connect multi-droplet streams, jets and solid objects with physical-based scaling arguments that emphasize the intrinsically similar cavities. In particular, the cavities created by the initial impact of both droplet streams and jets on an initially quiescent liquid pool exhibit the same types of cavity seal as hydrophobic spheres at low Bond number, some of which were previously unseen for jets and droplet streams. Low-frequency droplet streams exhibit an additional three new cavity seal types unseen for jets or solid spheres that can be predicted with a new non-dimensional frequency. The cavity depth and cavity velocity for both droplet and jet impact are rationalized by an energy scaling analysis and the Bernoulli equation.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© Cambridge University Press 2018. This is a work of the U.S. Government and is not subject to copyright protection in the United States. 
Figure 0

Figure 1.Images of several cavity shapes created by various impacting bodies. (a) The maximum cavity size from a single droplet impacting a pool of water ($d=3.39~\text{mm}$, $U=2.14~\text{m}~\text{s}^{-1}$). (b–d) Cavity shape just prior to pinch-off for cavities created by: (b) a multi-droplet stream ($d=1.53~\text{mm}$, $f=2500~\text{Hz}$, $U_{s}=6.17~\text{m}~\text{s}^{-1}$); (c) a jet ($d=1.17~\text{mm}$, $U_{s}=6.07~\text{m}~\text{s}^{-1}$); and (d) a hydrophobic sphere ($d=9.53~\text{mm}$, $U=2.43~\text{m}~\text{s}^{-1}$). Scale bar applies to all images.

Figure 1

Table 1.Experimental parameter ranges for each jet diameter $d_{j}$ (figure 2a).

Figure 2

Figure 2.(a) Schematic of the experimental set-up, with the inset indicating the mechanism for producing multi-droplet streams via jet breakup. The velocity of droplets $U_{s}$ has been observed experimentally to be largely constant over the fall height, and is equal to the jet velocity. (b) The diameter of droplets ($d_{d}$) in the multi-droplet streams is controlled by the nozzle diameter ($d_{j}$), stream velocity ($U_{s}$) and shaker frequency ($f$) (2.1). For a given nozzle diameter, the droplet diameter increases with decreasing $f$ and increasing $U_{s}$.

Figure 3

Figure 3.(a) An idealized cavity created by a multi-droplet stream consists of several sub-cavities. (b) A single-droplet impact causes the cavity to expand at velocity $U_{c}$. The time of maximum cavity size ($T_{max}$) corresponds to $U_{c}=0$; for $t>T_{max}$ the cavity is collapsing. (c) The matryoshka number ($Mt$) is defined by the timing of the impact of the second droplet with respect to the maximum cavity size of the first. For example, for $Mt=1$ the second droplet impacts the cavity at $T_{max}$. (d) The dimensionless frequency $\tilde{f}=fd_{d}/U_{s}$ defines the ratio of droplet diameter to spacing between droplets.

Figure 4

Table 2.List of variables and their description.

Figure 5

Figure 4.(a) Four images from the impact of a multi-droplet water stream onto a pool of water. The pinch-off frame is shown at $t=32~\text{ms}$, with $h_{p}$ indicating the depth of the pinch-off point and $h_{b}$ indicating the depth of the cavity at this time. At $t=42~\text{ms}$ all of the droplets from the multi-droplet stream have impacted the cavity base, creating a depth of $h_{c}$. At $t=63~\text{ms}$ all of the droplets from the downward jet created at pinch-off have impacted the cavity. (b) The maximum cavity diameter over time is measured at discrete depths, yielding $d_{c_{max}}(z)$. The average of these maximum diameters over all depths defines $d_{c}$ (red dotted line).

Figure 6

Figure 5.Normalizing cavity diameter ($d_{c}$) by jet diameter ($d_{j}$) collapses the jet data onto a line that is a function of impact velocity ($U_{s}$). A line with different slope and intercept is found for multi-droplet cases. We define a modified droplet diameter $d_{d}^{\ast }=d_{d}/1.75$, which collapses the normalized cavity diameter data onto a single line for multi-droplet and jet streams (inset).

Figure 7

Figure 6.(a) Multi-droplet streams produce six cavity seal types, three of which – shallow seal, deep seal and surface seal – are common to jet streams and rigid-sphere impact. Scale bars at the bottom of each image are 3 mm. (b) The six cavity seal types for multi-droplet streams can be separated by an $Mt$–$We^{\ast }$ regime diagram. The horizontal dashed line represents the lowest $We$ found by Franz (1959) for which dome-over occurs for a single droplet (line also shown in panel (c); note that $We$ from Franz (1959) has been modified using $d_{d}^{\ast }$). Sub-cavity 1 collapse occurs only for $Mt<1$, while sub-cavity 2 collapse occurs only between $1. Sub-cavity dome-over occurs for $We^{\ast }\gtrsim 350$ and $Mt<4$; the horizontal dotted line is to guide the eye. (c) Shallow seal, deep seal and surface seal are better sorted on a $Bo^{\ast }$–$We^{\ast }$ plot. The solid line is found by equating the dimensionless pinch-off times for deep and shallow seal (3.1). Using the modified diameter $d_{d}^{\ast }$ causes the cavity seal regime boundaries to align for multi-droplet and jet streams. Data from previous studies are plotted and match the expected cavity seal regimes: [a] Bick et al. (2010), [b] Bouwhuis et al. (2016), [c] Qu et al. (2013), [d] Zhu et al. (2000), [e] Soh et al. (2005), [f] Kersten et al. (2003) and [g] Oguz et al. (1992). Symbols and data are the same for all figures throughout the paper.

Figure 8

Figure 7.Two types of sub-cavity collapse: (a) sub-cavity 1 collapse and (b) sub-cavity 2 collapse. (a) For $Mt<1$, the second droplet impacts the cavity at $t=14.7~\text{ms}$ after sub-cavity 1 has begun to collapse ($f=80~\text{Hz}$, $U_{s}=1.77~\text{m}~\text{s}^{-1}$, $d_{d}=3.08~\text{mm}$, $We^{\ast }=77$, $Bo^{\ast }=0.4$, $Mt=0.88$ and $\tilde{f}=0.14$). The dashed line indicates the location of the bottom of sub-cavity 1 at its maximum depth. (b) For $1, the second droplet impacts the first sub-cavity at $t=4.0~\text{ms}$, the third droplet impacts at $t=10.0~\text{ms}$ and so on. The overall cavity is still expanding when each successive droplet impacts the cavity, thus enabling the cavity to grow larger in the vertical direction ($f=300~\text{Hz}$, $U_{s}=1.80~\text{m}~\text{s}^{-1}$, $d_{d}=2.18~\text{mm}$, $We^{\ast }=56$, $Bo^{\ast }=0.21$, $Mt=1.55$ and $\tilde{f}=0.36$). The cavity collapse occurs just below the bottom of sub-cavity 1 but above the bottom of sub-cavity 2. Dashed lines indicate the bottoms of sub-cavities 1 and 2 just prior to impact by the subsequent droplet. Numbers at the bottom of each frame indicate the time after initial impact in milliseconds. Corresponding positions in the regime diagrams can be seen in figure 6(b). Movies for (a) and (b) are shown in supplementary movies 3 and 4, respectively.

Figure 9

Figure 8.Two cases of sub-cavity dome-over. When $Mt<4$ and $We^{\ast }\gtrsim 350$ splash crowns form at the base of each sub-cavity and sometimes dome over. (a) When $Mt$ is at the lower end of this range, the cavity fully pinches off at the dome-over positions detaining further droplets from entering into the lower portion of the cavity ($f=100~\text{Hz}$, $U_{s}=4.41~\text{m}~\text{s}^{-1}$, $d_{d}=3.42~\text{mm}$, $We^{\ast }=527$, $Bo^{\ast }=0.52$, $Mt=1.84$ and $\tilde{f}=0.08$). (b) As $Mt\rightarrow 4$, droplets break through the sub-cavity dome-overs, reopening the cavity and preventing a full pinch-off ($f=200~\text{Hz}$, $U_{s}=5.45~\text{m}~\text{s}^{-1}$, $d_{d}=3.76~\text{mm}$, $We^{\ast }=886$, $Bo^{\ast }=0.63$, $Mt=3.27$ and $\tilde{f}=0.14$). Numbers at the bottom of each frame indicate the time after impact in milliseconds. The first image in each sequence shows a zoomed-out view of the cavity and each following image shows a zoomed-in view of the cavity of the area indicated by the dashed box. Corresponding positions in the regime diagrams can be seen in figure 6(b). Movies for (a) and (b) are shown in supplementary movies 5 and 6, respectively.

Figure 10

Figure 9.Shallow seal shown for two stream types. A capillary wave forms near the surface and travels downwards until pinch-off occurs at a depth of the order of the capillary length. (a) A cavity created by a multi-droplet stream pinches off with a shallow seal for small $Bo^{\ast }$ ($f=6000~\text{Hz}$, $U_{s}=6.39~\text{m}~\text{s}^{-1}$, $d_{d}=0.39~\text{mm}$, $We^{\ast }=128$, $Bo^{\ast }=0.0069$, $Mt=39.7$ and $\tilde{f}=0.37$). (b) A cavity created by a jet experiences first shallow and then deep seal ($U_{s}=5.78~\text{m}~\text{s}^{-1}$, $d_{j}=0.41~\text{mm}$, $We^{\ast }=190$ and $Bo^{\ast }=0.023$). After shallow seal pinch-off, the jet is perturbed and begins to break up into a droplet stream from the Rayleigh–Plateau instability ($t\geqslant 14.8~\text{ms}$). Numbers at the bottom of each frame indicate the time after impact in milliseconds. Corresponding positions in the regime diagrams can be seen in figure 6(b,c). Movies for (a) and (b) are shown in supplementary movies 7 and 8, respectively.

Figure 11

Figure 10.Deep seal shown for two stream types. Pinch-off occurs approximately halfway between the free surface and cavity bottom. (a) A cavity formed by a multi-droplet stream with higher $Bo^{\ast }$ and $We^{\ast }$ pinches off in a deep seal ($f=1500~\text{Hz}$, $U_{s}=6.59~\text{m}~\text{s}^{-1}$, $d_{d}=2.17~\text{mm}$, $We^{\ast }=748$, $Bo^{\ast }=0.21$, $Mt=16.9$ and $\tilde{f}=0.49$). (b) A cavity formed by a jet at a moderate $Bo^{\ast }$ pinches off in a deep seal ($U_{s}=7.09~\text{m}~\text{s}^{-1}$, $d_{j}=0.71~\text{mm}$, $We^{\ast }=527$ and $Bo^{\ast }=0.068$). Because $Bo^{\ast }$ is relatively small for this jet impact, we still observe the downward-moving capillary wave near the surface seen for shallow seal. Numbers at the bottom of each frame indicate the time after impact in milliseconds. Corresponding positions in the regime diagrams can be seen in figure 6(b,c). Movies for (a) and (b) are shown in supplementary movies 1 and 2, respectively.

Figure 12

Figure 11.Dimensionless pinch-off time for (a) shallow seal and (b) deep seal. The slopes of the respective fits are used in (3.1) to compute the boundary between shallow and deep seal shown on figure 6(c). Symbols are outlined in the legend of figure 6(a).

Figure 13

Figure 12.Surface seal for two types of stream impacts. (a) The splash crown of a cavity created by a multi-droplet stream domes over at $t=12.0~\text{ms}$, resulting in surface seal ($f=2500~\text{Hz}$, $U_{s}=7.51~\text{m}~\text{s}^{-1}$, $d_{d}=2.06~\text{mm}$, $We^{\ast }=923$, $Bo^{\ast }=0.19$, $Mt=28$ and $\tilde{f}=0.69$). (b) The same phenomenon is observed for a cavity created by a jet with dome-over occurring at $t=8.3~\text{ms}$ ($U_{s}=9.69~\text{m}~\text{s}^{-1}$ and $d_{j}=0.71~\text{mm}$, $We^{\ast }=921$ and $Bo^{\ast }=0.068$). Numbers at the bottom of each frame indicate the time after impact in milliseconds. Corresponding positions in the regime diagrams can be seen in figure 6(b,c). Movies for (a) and (b) are shown in supplementary movies 9 and 10, respectively.

Figure 14

Figure 13.Downward cavity velocity of multi-droplet streams and jets. (a) Depth of the cavity in time for four values of $Mt$. The black line represents a multi-droplet stream with $\tilde{f}=0.14$ and for a case with sub-cavity 1 collapse. The blue curve represents a multi-droplet stream with sub-cavity 2 collapse and $\tilde{f}=0.26$. A linear fit is applied to estimate the average cavity velocity (red dashed line). The magenta line represents a multi-droplet stream with $\tilde{f}=0.27$, which displays shallow seal behaviour. Note that, as $Mt$ increases, the oscillations in the cavity velocity become less pronounced. A jet (green line) also forms a shallow seal cavity with velocity nearly identical to the $Mt=16.5$ multi-droplet case. (b) The average downward cavity velocity ($U_{c}$) normalized by the stream velocity ($U_{s}$) as a function of $\tilde{f}$. The black dashed line represents (4.4) and the red dotted line represents the theoretical velocity ratio for a jet. The mean velocity ratio for all 65 jet cases is marked by the grey dot and a standard box-and-whisker plot ($\tilde{f}=1$). (c) The amplitude of oscillation ($U_{a}$) normalized by the average cavity velocity ($U_{c}$) as a function of $Mt$. The vertical dotted lines indicate transitional $Mt$ numbers of 1 and 4. The large circles in (b,c) outline data points represented by the corresponding colours of the lines in panel (a).

Figure 15

Figure 14.Pinch-off depth of multi-droplet streams. (a) Non-dimensional pinch-off depth for all multi-droplet streams as a function of $Mt$. Pinch-off depth is normalized by the non-modified droplet diameter $d_{d}$. (b) Pinch-off depth as a function of cavity depth for the deep seal regime only for multi-droplet streams and jets. The upper bound for the theoretical range is $h_{p}=h_{c}/2$, as predicted in § 5.3. The lower bound predicted for droplets is set by the line $h_{p}=h_{c}/3$, which is also the theoretically predicted pinch-off depth for jets. The least-squares fit to the droplet data has a slope of 0.319 and the fit to the jet data 0.277. Symbols and data are the same as in figure 6.

Figure 16

Figure 15.The non-dimensional cavity size for both jets and multi-droplet streams is collapsed by a function of $Bo$ and $Fr$ computed from an energy balance. The theoretical predictions of (5.8) and (5.9) are shown by the dotted line, as both equations collapse to a single curve. Note that the droplet diameter used in this analysis is $d_{d}$, the non-modified droplet diameter. Symbols and data are the same as in figure 6.

Figure 17

Figure 16.(a) The length of the jet that impacts the cavity bottom equals the depth of the cavity that it creates. (b) An equivalent expression for multi-droplet streams works to predict the depth of the cavity, $h_{c}$. The dashed lines in (a) and (b) represent (5.11) and (5.12), respectively. In (b) the mean $h_{c}/L_{j}$ for all the jet cases is marked by the grey dot and a standard box-and-whisker plot ($\tilde{f}=1$); where $L_{s}$ represents the length of either the multi-droplet stream or jet stream. Symbols and data are the same as in figure 6.

Figure 18

Figure 17.A comparison of the two methods for predicting cavity depth $h_{c}$ is shown. The $y$-axis is the measured value of the cavity depth $h_{c}$, while the $x$-axis is the predicted value of $h_{c}$ based on two different approaches. The first term on the $x$-axis comes from the energy-based method ($h_{c}=\unicode[STIX]{x1D6FA}_{s}d_{s}^{2}/d_{c}$, (5.8) and (5.9) rearranged), while the second term is from the Bernoulli-based method ($h_{c}=l_{s}\sqrt{\tilde{f}}$, (5.11) and (5.12) rearranged) as marked in the legend. An exact prediction is represented by the dashed line.

Figure 19

Figure 18.Prediction of $d_{c}$ and $t_{p}$ with a modified Weber number, $We_{m}=\unicode[STIX]{x1D70C}U_{c}^{2}d_{d}/\unicode[STIX]{x1D70E}$, as discussed by Bouwhuis et al. (2016). (a) The non-dimensional cavity diameter is said to scale as $d_{c}/d_{d}=0.1625We_{m}$, shown by the dashed line. (b) The pinch-off time non-dimensionalized by a capillary time scale is said to scale with $We_{m}^{3/2}$, with the dashed line showing $t_{p}\sqrt{8\unicode[STIX]{x1D70E}/\unicode[STIX]{x1D70C}d_{d}^{3}}=0.1We_{m}^{3/2}$. Symbols are outlined in the legend of figure 6(a).

Speirs et al. supplementary movie 1

Supplemental movie for Fig. 10a – deep seal for droplets A cavity formed by a multi-droplet stream with higher Bo and We pinches off in a deep seal (f = 1500 Hz, Us = 6.59 m s-1, dd = 2.17 mm, We* = 1,309, Bo* = 0.64, and Mt = 16.9). Pinch-off occurs approximately halfway between the free-surface and cavity bottom. Movie played back at 1/200 of real speed.

Download Speirs et al. supplementary movie 1(Video)
Video 3.4 MB

Speirs et al. supplementary movie 2

Supplemental movie for Fig. 10b – deep seal for jets A cavity formed by a jet at a moderate Bo pinches off in a deep seal (Us = 7.09 m s-1, dj = 0.71 mm, We = 527, and Bo = 0.068). Because Bo is relatively small for this jet impact, we still observe the downward moving capillary wave near the surface seen for shallow seal. Pinch-off occurs approximately halfway between the free-surface and cavity bottom. Movie played back at 1/200 of real speed.

Download Speirs et al. supplementary movie 2(Video)
Video 1.3 MB

Speirs et al. supplementary movie 3

Supplemental movie for Fig. 7a – sub-cavity 1 collapse Sub-cavity 1 collapse. For Mt < 1, the second droplet impacts the cavity after sub-cavity 1 has begun to collapse. Sub-cavity 1 continues to collapse after impact separating sub-cavity 2 from the surface. Parameters of the impact event are as follows: f = 80 Hz, Us = 1.77 m s-1, dd =3.08 mm, We* = 77, Bo* = 0.4, and Mt = 0.88. Movie played back at 1/200 of real speed.

Download Speirs et al. supplementary movie 3(Video)
Video 404.9 KB

Speirs et al. supplementary movie 4

Supplemental movie for Fig. 7b – sub-cavity 2 collapse Sub-cavity 2 collapse. For 1 <Mt<4, the cavity is still expanding when each successive droplet impacts thus, enabling the cavity to grow larger in the vertical direction (f = 300 Hz, Us = 1.80 m s-1, dd = 2.18 mm, We* = 56, Bo* = 0.21, and Mt = 1.55). The cavity collapse occurs between the bottom of sub-cavity 1 and the bottom of sub-cavity 2. Movie played back at 1/200 of real speed.

Download Speirs et al. supplementary movie 4(Video)
Video 952.3 KB

Speirs et al. supplementary movie 5

Supplemental movie for Fig. 8a – sub-cavity dome over Sub-cavity dome over at low Mt. When Mt<4 and We* ≲ 350 splash crowns form at the base of each sub-cavity and sometimes dome over. When Mt is at the lower end of this range the cavity fully pinches off at the dome over position detaining further droplets from entering into the lower portion of the cavity (f = 100 Hz, Us = 4.41 m/s, dd = 3.42 mm, We* = 527, Bo* = 0.52, and Mt = 1.84). Movie played back at 1/200 of real speed.

Download Speirs et al. supplementary movie 5(Video)
Video 3.1 MB

Speirs et al. supplementary movie 6

Supplemental movie for Fig. 8b – sub-cavity dome over at higher Mt Sub-cavity dome over at higher Mt. As Mt →4 droplets break through the sub-cavity dome overs reopening the cavity and preventing a full pinch-off (f = 200 Hz, Us = 5.45 m/s, dd = 3.76 mm, We* = 886, Bo* = 0.63, and Mt = 3.27). Movie played back at 1/200 of real speed.

Download Speirs et al. supplementary movie 6(Video)
Video 4.5 MB

Speirs et al. supplementary movie 7

Supplemental movie for Fig. 9a – shallow seal for droplets A cavity created by a multi-droplet stream pinches off with a shallow seal for small Bo* (f = 6000 Hz, Us = 6.39 m/s, dd = 0.39 mm, We* = 223, Bo* = 0.021, and Mt = 39.7). Movie played back at 1/200 of real speed.

Download Speirs et al. supplementary movie 7(Video)
Video 247.8 KB

Speirs et al. supplementary movie 8

Supplemental movie for Fig. 9b – shallow seal for jets A cavity created by a jet experiences first shallow and then deep seal (Us = 5.78 m s-1, dj = 0.41 mm, We = 190, and Bo = 0.023). After shallow seal pinch-off, the jet is perturbed and begins to break up into a droplet stream from the Rayleigh-Plateau instability. Movie played back at 1/200 of real speed.

Download Speirs et al. supplementary movie 8(Video)
Video 676.4 KB

Speirs et al. supplementary movie 9

Supplemental movie for Fig. 12a – surface seal for droplets The splash crown (not shown) of a cavity created by a multi-droplet stream domes over resulting in surface seal which is followed by deep seal (f = 2500 Hz, Us = 7.51 m s-1, dd = 2.06 mm, We* = 1,616, Bo* = 0.5796, and Mt = 28). Movie played back at 1/200 of real speed.

Download Speirs et al. supplementary movie 9(Video)
Video 4.1 MB

Speirs et al. supplementary movie 10

Supplemental movie for Fig. 12b – surface seal for jets The splash crown (not shown) of a cavity created by a jet domes over resulting in surface seal which is followed by deep seal (Us = 9.69 m s-1, dj = 0.71 mm, We = 921, and Bo = 0.068). Movie played back at 1/200 of real speed.

Download Speirs et al. supplementary movie 10(Video)
Video 802.3 KB