Unauthorized copies of content, whether we choose to call them pirated, counterfeited, or bootlegged, have been around far longer than any formal concept of intellectual property. Ptolemy III Euergetes, who ruled Egypt during the second century BCE, ordered all books entering the port of Alexandria be copied. The famous library of Alexandria kept the originals, and the pilfered ships were given imperfect, handmade copies. From the point of view of a ship's captain or an owner of a prized scroll, such an act was piracy, a violation that devalued a commodity. But for the historian of culture, Ptolemy's policy furthered learning by ensuring that Alexandria's library housed the most important documents of its day, even those that might otherwise have languished in a private collection, unread and unknown.
Alex Sayf Cummings's book Democracy of Sound: Music Piracy and the Remaking of American Copyright in the Twentieth Century demonstrates that the piracy of sound recordings has entailed similarly mixed consequences for artists, consumers, and stakeholders in the music industry. Piracy in its various manifestations, from sporadic copying of a few gem commodities to mass distribution of thousands of popular-music albums, has enabled a democratization of content unthinkable before the nineteenth century, even as it has also ensured that many musicians never see proceeds from the art. Cummings's book presents an ambitious history of piracy of sound recordings and reproductions in the United States, drawing from court decisions and settlements, popular and trade journalism, interviews, and pop culture ephemera. Copyright protection for sound changed from virtually nonexistent to robust and, arguably, stifling by the end of the twentieth century. In demonstrating this evolution, Cummings takes the reader on a fascinating survey of the strange history of intellectual property, strange because strange bedfellows and stranger enemies were made during the century of music's metamorphosis from textual to acoustic inscription. Player pianos and “talking machines” pitted composers against the very musicians who performed their works. The 1909 Copyright Act, which benefited composers whose work was recorded even as it ignored the record companies that produced recordings, instituted a counterintuitive divide between the composition and the sound recording, one that grew increasingly contentious with the rise of rock ‘n’ roll in mid-century. Bootleggers of obscure or out-of-print recordings weirdly ensured that content remained accessible; bootleggers of 1960s-era counterculture pop oddly furthered the cause of the radical left. Rightly or wrongly, musicians who practiced collage techniques like hip-hop sampling have often suffered through comparisons with tape pirates and Napster denizens alike. Intellectual-property wars are never tidy, as authors like Lawrence Lessig, Kembrew McLeod, and Siva Vaidyanathan have shown. Cummings's book confidently takes its place among this company as another central contribution to our understanding of the relationships between content, law, and culture.
The one lingering doubt that Democracy of Sound leaves is how we should define piracy, and whether it should be considered equivalent to other more or less straightforward acts of copying like bootlegging and counterfeiting, as well as acts of creativity like digital or turntable-based sampling. But this is not a weakness of the book; rather, Cummings rightly points out the ambiguity between a copy meant for a handful of listeners and one intended for mass sharing, or between a copy of a brief snatch of a recording and one of an entire song or album. Many on the so-called copy-left have valorized creative acts of copying even if they condemn or remain neutral on the ethics of piracy, but Cummings notes that a “mixtape or pirate record may reveal the unique touch of the person who chose the track sequence, picked a title, and designed a cover, without necessarily transforming the sounds contained on the CD, LP, or tape to a great extent” (205–6). The heady days of Dangermouse's Grey Album and the Bridgeport appeals court decision, which effectively criminalized all unauthorized sampling, prompted scholars and fans alike to rally behind recontextualized art. But Cummings's careful historicization reminds us that categories fail us when we try to make hard and fast distinctions between the pirate and the artist.
