As the first contemporary ethnographic study of Zoroastrians in Iran, Reclaiming the Farahavar is a sophisticatedly eclectic and highly motivating analysis of a religious minority. Two main questions guide Navid Fozi throughout the book: How can Zoroastrians’ distinctiveness as a religious community be explained? And what strategies have contributed to their survival despite a history of persecution? In response, Fozi employs performance theory with unstated influences from affect theory, to argue that the construction of a historical past and its performance are the key to the community's identity and resilience.
Based on extensive ethnographic fieldwork among the Zoroastrian community in Iran, Fozi provides a valuable contribution to ethnographies on Iran as well as the anthropology of religion. The basis of the book's ethnographic evidence comes from Zoroastrian rituals and ceremonies. Fozi manages to transform these classical anthropological themes into a critical contemporary discussion by balancing ethnographic reflexivity with theoretical strength. Throughout the book, he weaves the analysis of Zoroastrian rituals within a succinct discussion of reflexivity. From his discussion of native anthropology (especially illuminating given the intricacies of his own identity as a Baha'i Iranian living in the Unites States) to the major shifts in his project, he narrates a secondary story of performativity with regards to anthropology as a discipline and the anthropologist as researcher. In the process, the notion of fieldwork and the person of the anthropologist emerge as processes themselves.
Perhaps more importantly, Fozi incorporates classical anthropological themes within contemporary literature through a deconstruction of the concept of religion. While he is, no doubt, well versed in the theological, doctrinaire aspects of Zoroastrianism, the important questions for him are how the members of the Zoroastrian community make sense of, historicize, and conceptualize their religion to survive within an authoritarian regime, and adapt to the changing circumstances of a modern age. In that sense, Fozi presents a conversation between religion as doctrine and religion as practice, thereby situating Reclaiming the Faravahar within recent trends in the anthropology of religion, but also within larger social science debates about the dialogic analysis of institutions and social groups. Like the anthropologist and the fieldwork, religion, more specifically Zoroastrianism, is portrayed as a process in Fozi's analysis, thus deconstructing static notions of authenticity.
This process constitutes the skeleton of the book, which Fozi defines as an ethnography of historical consciousness. He starts by asking how the Zoroastrian past is configured and performed by believers in the context of Shiʿi Iran. Consequently, his discussion focuses on the processes via which selves are made in those performative instances of religiosity. Fozi is elaborate in his presentation of religious structures, which he then articulates within a story of agency. He argues that the performance of Zoroastrianism by the believers is articulated within a set of social imaginaries that conceptualize Iranian history in three distinct periods: a romanticized pre-Islamic period as the bastion of Persian distinctiveness, post-Islamic Arab “invasion,” and the period of Zoroastrian revival with the secular nationalism of the Pahlavi dynasty. The post-1979 context emerges as a hybridization of aspects of these three periods. Hence, Zoroastrian performances of reclaiming the past rely on a duality; while distinctiveness requires distancing themselves from the Shiʿi majority, survival compels the community to articulate themselves within Iranian culture at large.
One of the most important claims of the book is that Iran's distinctness is premised upon the now-disguised legacy of the pre-Islamic Zoroastrian past. Feeding from previous literature on Iran and interpreting his ethnographic data, Fozi reiterates the argument that Shiʿi Iran is a hybrid product of Islam and Zoroastrianism. While this claim of Persian uniqueness with a prelude of Zoroastrian distinctness seems to require some more in-depth discussion in the book, it is stimulating from a theoretical perspective, as it recalls the discussion on “Frenchness” provoked by Robert Darnton's work on French cultural history. Fozi revisits the fertile fields of historical anthropology and cultural history to pave the way for an interesting discussion on nationalism in Iran. Moreover, it is within this realm of a distinct Persian character that the duality of Zoroastrian subjectivity makes sense. While Zoroastrian historical consciousness is premised upon the Zoroastrians’ persecution by the Shiʿa in post-Islamic Iran, at times the threat of the Arab other gains currency over that of the Shiʿi Iranian. Fozi argues that at such moments members of the Zoroastrian community associate their own exclusivity with Shiʿi Iranians’ historical consciousness as a persecuted community themselves. This alliance with the larger Shiʿi culture creates a legitimate space for them to articulate Zoroastrianism as the cultural legacy of Iran's distinctness, thereby creating mechanisms for their community to align with and exist within the state apparatus. The representation of Zoroastrianism as the original culture of Iran and the emphasis on a shared history of persecution thus proffer legitimacy to the community. Fozi argues that the increasing visibility of Zoroastrian culture in the public sphere in recent years as well as the adoption of certain aspects of Zoroastrianism within Iranian official discourse are proof of the success of Zoroastrian efforts of survival and reclamation.
One theme that Fozi refers to, but does not adequately analyze is the incursion of power into such spaces of reconfigured resistance. What happens when the cultural idioms of a community are appropriated by the state? What are the politics of representation in such performances? After all, it is not only citizens that perform; states often emulate, hijack, and reclaim the cultural idioms of subaltern groups, while in the process new spaces of criminalization are created. One example that fits the bill in this context is the adoption of Nowruz by the Turkish state as an official holiday. For decades Nowruz celebrations were an important performative space of resistance for Turkey's Kurdish population. In the last decade the Turkish state defined Nowruz as an official Turkish holiday, forming links to the Central Asian past, thereby defining Nowruz as a Turkish (not Kurdish) tradition and enclosing a performance of resistance within a discourse of power. The creation of a state-sanctioned performative space has made it easier to delegitimize and criminalize alternative Kurdish celebrations. Considered in light of Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan's use of Zoroastrian as an ethnoreligious slur in the run up to the June 2015 elections, the dubious nature of cultural visibility becomes more apparent. While Erdoğan has often resorted to defining the Kurdish, left-leaning, progressive People's Democratic Party as a political party of Marxist-Leninist atheists, this time he chose to explain their distance from Islam by calling them out as Zoroastrians. This is only one example of how symbols, rituals, and cultural traditions are stripped of their meaning and become tools of oppression once they are adopted by institutions. If the Turkish state can create its own legal space for a Zoroastrian ritual, but still use Zoroastrian as an ethnoreligious form of discrimination, the cultural visibility of Zoroastrianism in Iran and the incursion of Zoroastrianism into official discourse beg more questions about the dialogics of performance.
This question will, no doubt, be read as proof of the strength of Fozi's work as one that encourages conversation and thoughtful debate. As such, the book speaks to an audience far more diverse than area experts or anthropologists of religion; anyone interested in theories of the state, the role of minorities, and cultural and social imaginaries as they relate to subject formation will learn from and enjoy reading this book.
