Practical Authority focuses on the process of creating and sustaining institutions in a particularly difficult policy context – the governance of river basin systems in the multi-level Brazilian polity. It is theoretically ambitious but very successful in supporting this ambition with a 13-year research process that involved teams of researchers in the field and scores of documents, interview respondents and focus groups. The detailed research appendix unpacks the meticulous process the authors engaged in during this period of time, an endeavour that was known in Brazil as the Projeto Marca d'Agua (Watermark Project). The main argument and the chief theoretical contribution of the work is to detail the institutional strategies that explained the creation and maintenance of river basin governance systems over the study period. The authors outline the influence of ‘practical authority’ – the capacity of policy-makers to solve problems through experimentation, rescaling operations, recognising institutional limitations but engineering new connections and networking, and adjusting participation to produce distinct policy outcomes. The empirical work encompasses comparisons of 13 river basin committees. The authors use their precise empirical measures to show how policy-makers' strategies, and not structural or institutional characteristics at the point at which institutions were created, explain the evolution of these institutions. The context-specific nature of institution-building produces an analytical framework that is interested in showing why policies that are sanctioned in law have distinct performances across space and time. The authors embrace the non-linear, sometimes contradictory, and hard-to-foresee elements of politics and policy-making, making their theoretical framework of practical authority applicable across a wide range of cases in developing countries.
Practical Authority has several core strengths. First, the theoretical and explanatory frameworks are compelling and extremely useful across a broad range of cases. This is a work that will be heavily used by scholars wishing to understand the role of policy-makers in the process of institutional change in many other policy areas. In the context of environmental policy, Abers and Keck show that Elinor Ostrom's well-cited and prize-winning work depends on too many contingencies to make it useful for understanding practical authority. Instead, the authors demonstrate that policy-makers' experience and capacity for networking are so central to the disposition of river basin governance over time that attempting to find structural or institutional logics to explain the cases based on categorical conditions is clearly not useful. Specifically, the central finding is that the hard work of organisation-building is central to institutions, so much so that without it new institutions are more prone to becoming captured by political interests with little regard for policy-making.
A second considerable strength of Practical Authority is the awesome scope and scale of the empirical work that Abers and Keck have assembled. In a very detailed research appendix, the authors explain the sustained nature of their work over a long period of time, and most notably, the twists and turns it took as the researchers learned more about their subject in the field. Such in-depth fieldwork, sustained over a long period of time (over a decade), is most unusual in the social sciences. I would not be completely surprised to see comparisons between this work and Robert Putnam's Making Democracy Work in the years to come. Most interesting is the role played by improvisation in the authors' implementation of the larger research design. Due to the fact that much time passes during the study period, the assumptions that they made at the outset become untenable later as institutions function differently over time given distinct leaders and strategic choices made by these policy-makers.
Some scholars will be somewhat frustrated by the lack of a parsimonious explanatory framework. Since the authors are interested in studying the ‘entanglement’ of agencies, jurisdictions and levels of government in a complex, multi-tiered polity (Brazil), some of their explanations will appear too voluntarist for some. But distinct patterns based on strategies do emerge and diverge from the predicted outcomes based on structures and the original preferences of the actors involved in policy-making and institution-building. Most notably, governance systems in which participation becomes an important dynamic do not necessarily lead to more representative decisions from the point of view of stakeholders. These sorts of counter-intuitive outcomes must be understood with a closer assessment of process and not through long-standing assumptions about political agents and institutions. Again, this will discomfit some scholars and be seen as less useful as an understanding of formal institutions. The authors might have developed a more fine-grained theoretical critique based on their empirical work, but they decide to be more modest and perhaps theoretically more understated, allowing scholars to debate the broader implications in the future.
Beyond the obvious applicability of the explanatory framework to future scholarship, Practical Authority offers usable insights for the governance of natural resources that can easily be applied to a host of other major policy areas such as poverty alleviation, health care, education and the management of transport systems. This kind of applicability based on political science scholarship is uncommon given the range and depth of the observations contained in the book. Practical Authority is simply an outstanding and tremendously important work. It can be expected to quickly become the basis for a great deal more research in environmental policy and natural resource management, and I expect it will also become the foundation for new fieldwork in a variety of areas in political science and political economy.
