One of the enduring problems facing historians of political theatre is understanding exactly how audiences are changed by what they experience. In particular, what is the role of technique and technology in such experiences? And if technique and technology play a role—and they must—then how is the process of change itself changed by emergent technologies and the new techniques they afford? In Viral Performance: Contagious Theaters from Modernism to the Digital Age, Miriam Felton-Dansky addresses these problems by way of the concept of “viral performance.” Broadly speaking, what makes something “viral” is that it is both contagious and proliferative. A virus can be digital, biological, or artistic, but it “nearly always function[s] as disruptions in the fabric of daily life,” a fact that is all too apparent in an era of global pandemic, state-sponsored computer-network sabotage, and meme culture (4). Although the author positions the viral as a creature of modernism and the digital era, it is less a technique or technology than a quality of “projects that draw on theater's contagious possibilities to engage with audiences and to spread ideas, gestures, and images in live and mediated form” (4). Does this suggest a transhistorical character to the viral? Plato worried about theatre's contagious properties (as the author notes), and Zeami found new power in the wood and cloth of bunraku puppets. But Felton-Dansky insists viral performance is a relatively recent phenomenon, a claim to which I'll return below.
The author explores four “viral dramaturgies” (4) that fall in roughly chronological order from the early 1960s to the present. Each dramaturgy concerns a distinct aspect of the theatre: actor, audience, story, and company. Each describes a distinct “politics of spectatorship” by “dismantling easy equations between participation and political efficacy, and between contagious dissemination and the loss of individual identity and choice” (4). This is a key quality of the viral: it is a technique that has no essential ideological valence. While the artists Felton-Dansky examines deploy viral performance for progressive purposes, those same techniques are deployed by and originate from capital and the military–industrial complex. Indeed, the viral dramaturgies developed by these artists are often responses to their use by unjust powers.
Chapter 1 explores the viral dramaturgy that circulated between Antonin Artaud (among the first to conceptualize theatre as a viral contagion) and the Living Theatre. Here, Felton-Dansky focuses on the performer; in particular, the performer's ability to generate contagious forms of affect. Aligning with their anarchist ideology, the Living Theatre developed acting techniques that generated intense forms of affect that were “neither structured narratively nor organized in response to . . . interpretations of situations,” to quote affect theorist Sianne Ngai (60).
The viral dramaturgy of audience is the subject of the second chapter. Marc Estrin, Augusto Boal, and the conceptual art collective General Idea were “infected” by the Living Theatre's techniques (47), but also by emergent “ideas about circulation and transmission permeating performance cultures of the early 1970s” (71). The idea here is “technological circulation” (97); specifically, how new communications technologies infiltrate everyday life and cultural practices. Estrin and Boal's invisible performances and General Idea's deconstruction of cultural events such as beauty pageants were designed to reconfigure the relationship of spectator and spectacle by enabling a gap or communication jam that would enable critical consciousness to proliferate.
As discussed in Chapter 3, the 1990s witnessed a “seismic shift in the cultural and political significance of the viral” (109) and “new tactics for infiltrating public space and consciousness” (110). These were driven by neoliberal capital, digital media, the AIDS epidemic, and, crucially, the blurring of the boundary between truth and fiction driven by technologies of simulation (110). The third viral dramaturgy exploited these via a dramaturgy of “publicly performed fiction—spectacular stories unbounded by theatrical stages” (113). Critical Art Ensemble, Eva and Franco Mattes, and Christoph Schlingensief developed strategies of representational “sabotage” (112) that, in diverse ways, “borrow[ed] and reshap[ed] the actions and images of other artists or of the institutions under critique” (113).
The fourth chapter of the book focuses on three recent events: The Lysistrata Project, Caryl Churchill's Seven Jewish Children, and Suzan-Lori Parks's 365 Days/365 Plays. The viral dramaturgy here differs from the others because not only were these performances “designed to ‘go viral’” but “were, conceptually, viral from the start, representing their creators’ desires to make performances that were reiterated and reproduced many times over, available to potentially limitless numbers of artists and spectators” (150). These instances of viral dramaturgy concern the creative community that staged the performances; already existing “avenues of communication” were transformed (151), indeed brought into being, through the ramifying transmission of activist texts.
In the Conclusion to this wide-ranging, meticulously researched book, Felton-Dansky writes, “[T]he concept of the viral is fundamentally linked to communication and new modes of communication; to shared presence, and the pressures artist put on that shared presence, and to the aesthetics of rupture in all of its forms” (200). This claim leads to two criticisms. First, I'd argue that the millennia-old history of theatre is, in part, the history of artists “harness[ing] the properties of emerging media forms in order to depict, but also create, fundamental shifts in the transmission of action” (4). Notwithstanding the newness of the viral as concept and practice, it is also old wine in new bottles. Second, I'd ask, “Whose modernism?” and “Whose digital age?” Notwithstanding the presence of Augusto Boal and Suzan-Lori Parks, the argument would be enriched and complicated if put in conversation with Afro-futurist conceptions of the viral like those mapped in Ishmael Reed's Mumbo Jumbo or, notwithstanding the brief mention of ACT UP, queer viral dramaturgies. And one cannot help but wonder what the author might say about performance during the COVID pandemic. But I offer these criticisms as invitations. The historiographical and theoretical work Felton-Dansky accomplishes here is as smart, useful, and incisive as one could desire.
