On the one hand, the title of Peter Gardella's book tells you everything you need to know about it. It suggests that the reader will encounter descriptions of those things that Americans hold sacred. And that is exactly what the reader will find. There is no sustained argument about the existence of American civil religion. It is assumed that it exists. There also is very little in regard to arguing for or even clarifying the concept of the sacred – a contentious term that has been debated for generations. On the other hand, the title is hardly sufficient in describing the amazing, almost encyclopedic, resource that Gardella provides us.
While not a sustained argument, the opening chapter of the book does provide a number of key theses and definitions. Gardella notes that the “monuments, texts, and images [of American civil religion], along with the behaviors and values associated with them, amount to a real religion” (2). Furthermore, these monuments, texts, and images tell a story that is “unified by four values – personal freedom (often called liberty), political democracy, world peace, and cultural (including religious, racial, ethnic, and gender) tolerance” (3). It is a story that spans seven phases of American history – from colonial times (the origins of the religion) to the current multicultural era (4).
Gardella defines religion as “a system of nonrational commitments that holds life together” (5). His point in regard to American civil religion is that as citizens encounter the monuments, texts, and images that he identifies, “the emotions they feel do not arise from a rational conclusion” (6). The emotions both generate and express the “nonrational commitments” that hold together the lives of Americans. Much of the focus of the book is on objects and spaces. For example, the many monuments and memorials on the National Mall in Washington, DC figure prominently in American civil religion. Indeed, Gardella argues that the nation's capital is a “sacred landscape” (149), and that the National Mall “is the most sacred space” (323). But American civil religion is much more than just objects and spaces. Just as with any religion, it includes beliefs and rituals.
In regard to beliefs, Gardella points us to key sentences in the Declaration of Independence (“We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness”) (98). He also describes sections of the Constitution and the “holiness” in which that document is held (117). He concludes that the Constitution is “the primary document defining the values of personal freedom and political democracy that American civil religion holds sacred” (131).
Gardella identifies several rituals that are central to American Civil Religion – from the prescribed and proscribed actions that involve the flag (81) to the behavior of those who visit the Vietnam Veterans Memorial (the placing of wreaths, candles, pictures, gifts, and other objects at the foot of the wall) (321). These rituals both express the awe of the participants when confronted with the sacred object or space, and at the same time are part of what imputes sacrality to those objects and spaces.
Of the thirty-four chapters, thirty-two are on specific elements of American civil religion. There are numerous illustrations and photographs that enrich the chapters. Each chapter can stand alone, and in this sense the book would be a great collection on which to draw for a course looking at American civil religion. Teachers and students could pick and choose what chapters would be of most interest without somehow missing out on critical aspects of a larger argument. While the book can be read as a celebration of American civil religion, Gardella nevertheless confronts many of the issues or problems intrinsic to that tradition. For example, for whom is the American civil religion designed? Whom does it serve? While we can understand the celebration of all things good about the United States, there clearly are many populations within the country that have had mixed experiences (to say the least). Where do African Americans fit in American civil religion? Where do American Indians fit? Gardella is sensitive and astute in grappling with such questions. For example, he describes the various controversies with American Indians surrounding the carving of the mountain that became Mount Rushmore (232–45). He also never neglects the tragic history of slavery and Jim Crow, and recognizes the important contributions that African Americans have made in the history of the country. Indeed, he even identifies Martin Luther King Jr. as the saint of American civil religion. Gardella writes that King may have done “more than anyone to turn the values of freedom and democracy into realities” (302). In a compelling chapter on King's speeches, Gardella argues that
King was using the most basic sacred text of American civil religion [the Declaration of Independence] to challenge the actual practices of the United States. In this, he was following the tradition of the Hebrew prophets, who constantly used the terms of the original covenant with God to challenge the practices of Israel and Judah in their days. (306)
While many of the difficult issues that Gardella examines are internal (e.g. how disparate groups can come together under a single civil religion), he also looks outward. In particular, he writes about the propensity of American civil religion to advocate for its core values, even sometimes imposing those values on other cultures and nations. He notes that for many decades the United States has been spreading the “gospel of liberty” (293), and that doing so has led to both glorious and tragic consequences. He also notes that to the extent that the values of American civil religion overlap closely with the values of the United Nations (including the Universal Declaration of Human Rights), the American civil religion merges “with a civil religion of the world” (268).
The thoroughness of Gardella's work certainly is impressive, but it is not without its gaps when thinking about American civil religion. For example, sport is only mentioned tangentially in the text, even though it clearly plays a significant role in American civil religion. Gardella notes that two million people each year visit the Civil War battlefields at Gettysburg and three million people visit the Liberty Bell. But nearly four million people attended a baseball game at Dodger Stadium in Los Angeles, and it is only open for eighty-one days out of the year. And while Gardella does focus on music in certain chapters, those chapters are limited to traditional patriotic and folk songs. What about Elvis, Springsteen, Buddy Guy, and Miles Davis? In short, Gardella's work neglects much of American popular culture that is critical to American civil religion. To be fair, however, inclusion of all those other materials would have extended the book by another several hundred pages. Other gaps in Gardella's work are minor. Certain key concepts or ideas could have been explained more fully, such as sacrifice and immortality (231). In addition, the chapter on Disney parks deserved more substantive conclusions (289). Finally, scholars, teachers, and students would have benefited from an index to the book.
In conclusion, readers will find Gardella's volume to be quite remarkable, particularly given the depth of the research. While some of the details do not seem very relevant (for example, population trends in Washington, DC), the cumulative effect of the information certainly is powerful and convinces the reader that not only does American civil religion exist, but also it has certain distinct contours. While I would like to have seen more of a theoretical defense of American civil religion as Gardella sees it, its absence does not detract from the value of his work. Indeed, interested readers might like to consult parts or all of Martha Nussbaum's recent book Political Emotions: Why Love Matters for Justice (2013). Her work complements well the work of Gardella, providing the kind of theoretical account of civil religion not found in American Civil Religion. In fact, the two books together could form the basis of a wonderful course on American civil religion.
At the end of his book, Gardella writes that he sought to provide “an outline and guide to American civil religion, including its sacred places and symbolic dimensions as well as its texts and values” (367). In this regard, his work is a great success.
