In The Rise of the American Conservation Movement: Power, Privilege, and Environmental Protection, environmental sociologist Dorceta E. Taylor accomplishes a transformative feat of scholarship. In a rhetorically understated fashion, she documents the women and people of color present at the making of conservationism; places conservationism within the context of settler colonialism, racism, and patriarchy; and synthesizes revisionist narratives of gender, race, and class history, which typically exist separate from one another. In so doing, she has authored a book that challenges the dominant interpretive frameworks of the field of environmental history and deserves a central place in introductory and intermediate environmental courses. Just as importantly, she illuminates the overlapping historical roots of our present environmental predicament.
Taylor takes a thematic approach to her central contention that the conservation movement in the United States developed as an outgrowth of wealthy people's (what she terms “power elites”) ambivalent and conflicted relationship to urban spaces. Opening with the observation that “the conservation movement arose against a backdrop of racism, sexism, class conflicts and nativism that shaped the nation in profound ways” (9), the book begins with a concise introduction to key concepts informing early conservation thought: race relations, colonialism, and nativism, gender relations, environmental ideologies, power elites, and the creation of an environmental identity. This conceptual exposition sets the stage well for Taylor's three-part exploration of the emergence of conservationism as a social movement in the late nineteenth century.
In Part Two, “Manliness, Womanhood, Wealth and Sport,” Taylor explores the interconnections of race, wealth, gender, and recreation during the nineteenth century. Anglo male elites in the early nineteenth century increasingly embraced sport hunting and wilderness trekking. Taylor documents how for many, including John James Audubon, recreation time was made possible by slave labor. For others, recreation and exploration were pursued at the expense of wives and families. John Muir, for example, left his pregnant wife at home to adventure in Alaska, returning after the birth of his daughter. As the nineteenth century progressed, “genteel urban men” found the frontier increasingly exciting as a location through which to realize their masculinity: “in the post-Civil War era, it became increasingly common for men to demonstrate their masculinity, wealth and upper-class status by undertaking conquest-oriented outdoor activities such as hunting big game in the West” (67). Such trips promised the additional frisson of possible armed encounters with Native Americans, and as such, these frontier trips were often “quasi-military operations” (67).
In Part Three, “Wildlife Protection,” Taylor interprets sport hunting, bird preservation, and wildlife regulation campaigns through the lenses of sexism, nativism, classism and racism. She shows the class conflicts endemic to sport hunting practices; how bird protection campaigns led by the American Ornithological Union and the Audubon Society framed wealthy women as superficial creatures intent on murdering birds to satisfy fashion trends; how Italian, Black, and Native American subsistence hunters were blamed for destroying wildlife; and how some conservation organizations allied with gun rights groups to create permanent game refuges.
Part Four, “Gender, Wealth, and Forest Conservation” delves into the deeply gendered rural beautification campaigns that preceded the establishment of national parks. Taylor re-reads iconic moments in conservation history, Hetch Hetchy and Yosemite among them, through participants’ use of these debates to advance ideas of nationhood, wilderness, and racial purity. Sierra Club founder John Muir features prominently in this section. Muir, integral to the fight to preserve Yosemite, was deeply disturbed by and opposed to the presence of Native Americans within the “American” wilderness. Of his accidental encounter with a group of Mono Indians in the Sierras, Muir wrote that, “a drove of gray hairy beings came in sight, lumbering toward me with a kind of boneless, wallowing motion like bears … Somehow they seemed to have no right place in the landscape, and I was glad to see them fading out of sight down the pass” (361). Taylor allows his words to speak for themselves, transitioning from that deplorable quotation into a broader discussion about Muir's obsession with reassuring white Americans that the Native Americans were a relic of the past, and the significance of “empty” landscapes to the conservationist imaginary.
Throughout the book, Taylor skillfully renders the centrality of slave labor, patriarchy, class hierarchy. and/or settler colonialism in the making of conservationism. Neither damning nor excusing, she describes the structural conditions of life of those who are typically considered the “great men” of conservation. Not only does she illustrate how conservationism developed within a time of imperialism, expansionism, and segregation, but she details how many of its key participants supported racist and imperialist policies. Alongside this reframing of the great men, she shows the preponderance of women and people of color within the environments targeted for conservation. The effect of these intersecting analyses is the successful demonstration of precisely how conservation—and its subsequent historical narration—were shaped by and participant in the consolidation of the United States as a deeply hierarchical settler colony. Although many of her subjects—Native Americans within national parks, the Civilian Conservation Corps, John Muir, the Audubon Society—have been critically analyzed by other scholars, Taylor's feat is to put all of these subjects, and many more, into a dynamic conversation with one another. This conversation forces readers to ask why it is that conservation has not been read in such a way before.
Taylor's writing style is dry by comparison to the genre of historical scholarship, environmental history, to which her book is most directly addressed. Yet its power lies in her ability to lay bare the connections between the conservation movement and broader forms of exploitation and hierarchy. Observations such as, “The wealthy moved in order to distance themselves from the things and people of the city that made them uncomfortable or threatened their lifestyle” (43) and “manliness was a frontier virtue that was asserted when deemed necessary” (56) sparkle with a dry wit, and resonate all too well with our present environmental crises. The Rise of the American Conservation Movement promises to be a useful text for teaching, as well as a critical synthetic rereading of the field of environmental history.
