The aim of this volume is the construction of a metabiographical discourse on the structure, functions, uses and historicity of scientific biography. Originating in a two-day meeting in 2002 outside Copenhagen, The History and Poetics of Scientific Biography features chapters by fifteen authors, a preface by David M. Knight and an introduction by editor Thomas Söderqvist. The contributors have engaged with the problem of writing biographies of natural philosophers, scientists and medical doctors, and their biographical subjects range over the period from Greek antiquity to the turn of the present century. Some of the authors also offer biographical details on their subjects that may be novel to some readers, including remarks by David Aubin and Charlotte Bigg on Jules Janssen and Norman Lockyer, Christopher A. J. Chilvers on Boris Hessen, and Vassiliki Betty Smocovitis on G. Ledyard Stebbins.
In Knight's preface and in Söderqvist's introduction and concluding chapter, as well as in other chapters (notably by Jacalyn Duffin and Beth Linker), contributors discuss recent difficulties in interesting presses in publishing scientific biographies and scepticism in academic circles about their value. Söderqvist notes the general failure among writers on the historiography of science – with the important exception of Helge Kragh, in his Introduction to the Historiography of Science (Cambridge, 1987) – to mention biography. Some of the contributors, for instance Aubin and Bigg, argue that the programme of social constructivism has been ‘carried out at the expense of the individual’ (p. 55). There is general agreement here that practitioners of social history and cultural history of science have judged the value of biography to lie primarily in its role as contextual history, embodied social history, social biography or microhistory. Yet the authors also recall earlier, preconstructivism decades when many of the founding members of the profession of history of science, among them George Sarton, Henry Guerlac and Herbert Butterfield, associated biography with what Butterfield scorned as ‘rather a defective kind of antiquarianism’ (p. 251). In the 1960s and early 1970s the editorial board of the Dictionary of Scientific Biography encouraged biographical writing, but emphasized to its authors that personal biography was to be kept to the minimum in favour of the narration of scientific accomplishments and careers.
The writing of ‘lives’ (bioi) of scientists dates back to antiquity, when its general aim, as described by Liba Taub, was an account or celebration of the achievements of heroic philosophers whose ‘lives’ were meant to serve as guides to how to live ethically, how to benefit from philosophy and how to participate in the divine. By the seventeenth century, as shown in chapters by Stephen Gaukroger on Bacon and Descartes and by Kragh on Tycho Brahe, autobiographical or biographical accounts self-consciously defined a genre or type of new natural philosopher, with Pierre Gassendi's 1654 biography becoming an exemplar for three hundred years for Tychonic biographies, just as David Brewster's 1855 biography of Isaac Newton framed most biographers' questions about Newton for the next century.
Gassendi's portrait of Tycho had to harmonize with scientific values of the mid-seventeenth century, picturing Tycho as an untiring empirical scientist and masterful instrument-builder. By the nineteenth century the Romantic conception of inspired ‘genius’ amalgamated with the notion of the virtuous natural philosopher to inform the long-standing tradition of hagiography. Aristotelian poetics of tragedy could fit into the narrative of the hero, as in Jørgen Wichfeld's 1865 biography of Niels Stensen (Steno), discussed by Signe Lindskov Hansen, and in the Stalin-era life of Boris Hessen described by Chilvers. Chapters by Aubin and Bigg, Patricia Fara, Rena Selya and Bernadette Bensaude-Vincent discuss the commemorative uses made of scientific lives in the construction of scientific disciplines and patriotic national traditions. Commemorative medals, portraits, monuments and rituals achieve this end, along with biographies, whose contemporary authors must grapple with the myths that previously have transfigured their biographical subjects.
Breaking with tradition, the French physicist Jean-Baptiste Biot in 1832 produced evidence of Newton's 1692–3 mental breakdown. Augustus De Morgan's 1846 biography of Newton concluded that Newton was an anti-Trinitarian and that he had manipulated the Royal Society's decision in the priority dispute between Newton and Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz. De Morgan characterized Newton as a hard worker rather than as a seer or prophet. Alarmed, the Oxford astronomer S. P. Rigaud wrote to William Whewell that ‘if Newton's character is lowered, the character of England is lowered and the cause of religion is injured’ (p. 163), to which De Morgan replied that ‘the theory of gravitation would not be altered in value, or in opinion of value, though its author were proved to have committed murder and robbery’ (p. 165). As noted by Rebekah Higgitt, De Morgan was a critic of the belief that intellect and morality coincide, and he rejected the long-standing trope that the bios should conform to the standard of the idealized and exemplary natural philosopher. In the mid-twentieth century De Morgan's approach remained anathema to Sarton, who decried ‘that loathsome fashion of our time, which is called “debunking”’ and ‘the dragging down of great men to the level of their meretricious biographers’ (p. 249).
Perhaps more so than in other fields of biography, scientific biography often makes what Thomas L. Hankins calls ‘the dubious distinction between a “career” and a “life”’ (p. 93). Drawing upon recent scholarship, Aubin and Bigg discuss notions of the ‘persona’ and the ‘self’ at the centre of a career and a life, quoting historian Joan Scott's comment that people ‘are not unified autonomous individuals exercising free will, but rather subjects whose agency is created through situations and statuses conferred on them’ (p. 65). In biography as ‘contextual history’ or ‘embodied social history’, the biographical subject becomes a persona who is an intermediary between an individual life and an institutional or cultural life, a notion developed in the work of Lorraine Daston and Otto Sibum (p. 60).
Söderqvist himself expresses fatigue in the face of analyses of scientific biographies within the polarized terms of ‘hagiography’ and ‘context’, encouraging greater attention to choices in genres of biography and less emphasis on standards for what currently constitutes good history of science. This is a thought-provoking volume, which calls to mind a rethinking of the singularity of the individual and the conceptualization of human agency.
