The starting point of Norris's analysis of the Irish welfare state is the observation that reliance on Esping-Andersen's typology of welfare states based on social security expenditure routinely leads to Ireland being assigned to “liberal welfare regime”. However, Norris argues it is not enough to think of the Irish case as simply involving “weak” welfare state development; instead it is necessary to recognise that there is a distinctive Irish story. First, Norris draws on detailed historical analysis to support the argument that from the late nineteenth century Ireland's welfare regime was focused on property redistribution; with the redistribution of income and the provision of services being relegated to a secondary role. In addition, rather than the purpose of welfare policy being to operationalise the “grand bargain” between capital and labour it was intended to support a familist order.
Norris’ general explanatory framework is based on the role of power, moral and political legitimacy and efficiency considerations. This focus is employed in relation to a number of different phases of the property welfare regime encompassing establishment, construction, saturation, retrenchment and marketization.
Norris’ traces the role of government action in the late nineteenth and early twentieth century in redistributing capital assets on an unparalleled scale, primarily by transferring ownership of farms to tenants and providing social housing for farm labourers. While the expansion of mainstream services were driven by British developments, the emergence of the Irish property based welfare system and its overwhelmingly rural focus was predominantly influenced by local factors. These included the numerical strength and unparalleled mobilising ability of the tenant farmer lobby and the national consensus relating to the legitimacy of their claims. Norris argues that these policies constituted a “critical juncture” and influenced long-term trajectories. Thus while the period between the 1920s and the 1940s saw only a modest expansion of the mainstream welfare system, it was characterised by a radical growth in the number of ownership supports, including the conversion of social housing in rural areas into a stepping stone to home ownership.
Norris emphasises that while not defined as “social policies” property redistribution initiatives shared key characteristics with mainstream welfare state expenditures in promoting a familistic social order by insulating low-income families from market forces and thus enabling a decommodification of labour. These developments were driven not only by political and ideological factors but by the fact that efficiency and affordability concerns were less salient in this area because borrowing was not categorised as part of the national debt.
During the 1950s the scale of housing expenditure presented increasing challenges for government in the context of declining revenues, the increased visibility of associated debt and increasing opportunity costs. However, the significant political power enjoyed by small farmers, the desire to attract urban voters and the increasing influences of the construction industry continued to drive the consistent expansion of all categories of property-based welfare expansion throughout the 1950s and 1960s. However, between the late 1960s and the 1980s the system came under increasing pressure and an unambiguous and radical policy redirection emerged in the late 1980s involving both the abolition of most homeowner subsidies and the system of borrowing to fund social housing. In the context of unprecedented levels of national debt, these developments reflected both significant socio-economic change and a shift in the ideological landscape which provided increasing support both for focusing mainstream welfare services and productive investment and for free-market solutions.
Norris documents the manner in which in the 1990s and 2000s the traditional state instruments were replaced by radically increased reliance on commercial lenders accompanied by liberalization of regulation. This approach she notes had much in common with the asset price Keynesian model identified in the US. It involved, Norris stresses, not a “rolling back” of the state but a rolling out of the state into new spheres of activities and ways of operating aimed to support the market. The increases in tax revenue associated with these policies enabled Irish politicians to satisfy competing political agendas simultaneously. However, the housebuilding boom significantly increased the pace of economic growth during the early 2000s and accentuated the economic bust which commenced in 2007–08 and contributed to the collapse of the Irish Banking system and Ireland's entry into the EU and IMF sponsored emergency stabilisation programme in 2010. It also produced a less progressive distribution of capital assets associated with a significant reduction in levels of homeownership.
Norris provides an innovative, insightful and clearly documented account of the distinctive character of the Irish welfare state. However, given that issues relating to housing and homelessness figure so prominently in current political debate, the reader may find it disappointing that she does not seek to use her efforts as a basis for an informed assessment of the policy choices faced by politicians and policy makers in relation to housing provision and the operation of the housing market and the implications for socio-economic inequalities and intergenerational justice.
