Wherever we go, whatever we do, the Greeks will always be with us—whether in terms of medieval manuscripts, or archaeological sites, or the contemporary practices and theories we continue to project upon them. There are palpable tensions between antiquity and modernity, with a cornucopia of questions about continuity, change, and reform that mark the experience of tragedy and comedy.
Gary Day's The Story of Drama: Tragedy, Comedy and Sacrifice from the Greeks to the Present, a survey broad in its scope and aspirations, is rooted in similarities between the Aristotelian notion of tragic kátharsis and more contemporary concepts such as psychoanalysis and confession. For all their differences, Day argues that it is the similarity in their goals and effects that remains more striking. Chapter 1, “Sacrifice,” traces the intellectual traditions surrounding ritual sacrifice and various theories of its function, from the early work of anthropologists like Edward Burnett Tylor and classicists like Walter Burkert to literary critics such as George Steiner—with the obligatory digression into Freudian territory. (Victor Turner and Richard Schechner, so influential in American circles, merit only passing allusions and are not otherwise to be found here—even in the bibliography.)
Day subsequently argues for the roots of tragedy and comedy in ritual sacrifice—a common enough thesis, dating back to the Sorbonne of the early 1800s. But he also cautions against the overinterpretations of the cultural Darwinist school, noting that the ritual/religious–drama/secular dialectic is mitigated by factors such as medieval religious drama and the explicit moral and ethical teachings that lie at the heart of so many dramas, ancient and modern. He sees the relationship between ritual and drama as more symbiotic than parental (or parasitic), and devotes this book to the proposition that “despite the development of drama over the centuries and the decline of tragedy this kinship is still evident” (21).
What is fascinating about this study is the way in which Day repositions familiar plays, using them as evidence of radical changes in our concepts of sacrifice and in the process casting new light on their well-worn pages. His treatment of Everyman, for example, points to a paradigm shift from sacrifice for the gods and/or society to sacrifice for the self. In both the ancient and medieval worlds, one was expected to sacrifice one's own personal riches; but whereas the health of Thebes or appeasement of the gods was paramount back in Sophocles’ day, the purpose of sacrifice becomes intensely personal by the Middle Ages—a lone individual's spiritual salvation.
There is also the question of why one stages plays in the first place. By the Renaissance, as Day points out, “People put on plays for money, not because they led to moral improvement” (78). Once the profit motive impinges on the page and stage, the question of sacrifice seems to undergo another transformation—because sacrifice is no longer the drama's motivating factor, let alone theatre as a public good. This lack of a meaningful sense of sacrifice, already evident in Shakespeare's day, helps to explain the odd denouement of Wycherley's The Country Wife, in which “there is no cleansing, only further corruption” (117).
Day points out that nineteenth-century melodrama restores some of the ritualistic aspects of ancient drama by providing a space where we can witness the expulsion of evil—the spectacle of evil's expungement, moreover, ensuring a more cathartic, emotional response. What is fascinating about this period, as Day describes it, is that the same profit motive that influenced the Renaissance drama is now being thoroughly critiqued—even in plays staged explicitly for purpose of profit. His analysis of Douglas Jerrold's Black-Ey'd Susan points to ways in which melodrama, even in the 1820s, anticipates Marx's condemnation of the monetization of social relations.
Perhaps the strongest section of Day's study comes with plays closer to our own time, as he addresses the question of “whether the sacrificial mindset is hard-wired into the human brain” (139). For all the changes in our relationship to ritual and religion, and for all the changes in the ways we stage each other's behavior, the need for sacrifice endures. Day's analysis of Waiting for Godot features an especially interesting account of the ritualistic aspects of Lucky's dance, aspects that in turn demonstrate how “Beckett shows us the exhaustion of the traditions he evokes but, at the same time, he cannot quite relinquish them” (145). In stark contrast, Day follows up with Sarah Kane's full-throated revival of mythic Greek violence in Blasted. The extremities of violence and depravity, however senseless they appear to be, beg for resolution among the characters themselves and the audience. Although he is reticent about Kane's ultimate point here, Day points out “we find the same questions about the nature of humans in Blasted as we do in Greek and Renaissance tragedy” (149).
With his concluding chapter, Day turns to other media—film, television, the novel—to find traces of ritual and sacrifice richly in evidence as well. Even the crime novel (Thomas Harris's The Silence of the Lambs enters at this point), by creating a careful, rational account of murder, lends a ritual aspect to death that, although disturbing, at least tries to place it in a context we can comprehend.
The only passages that raised my hackles were those in which Day insisted on retrojecting the sexual perversities of fin-de-siècle Vienna onto the Greeks, Shakespeare, and so forth. “But Freud” rings as hollow to me as “But her emails”: to my mind the only dramas that truly merit a Freudian analysis are those written after the publication of Freud's theories (which Day notes well). Given the breadth of scholarship evident in Day's study, however, this is a minor issue in an otherwise solid work that should be especially useful in courses on script analysis, as well as in those that attempt to link the history of great dramas to the cultural contexts from which they emerge.
