Since 11 September 2001, a steady stream of books and articles has been published on the topic of international democracy assistance, especially in the Arab world. Yet the debate about democracy assistance is often strangely divorced from the actual substance of democracy assistance—what kinds of programs it supports, where it takes place, and who is involved. This is a major omission. Understanding this substance is essential to accurately assessing the effects of democracy assistance and to developing plans for how to design its efforts optimally.
Sheila Carapico's new book on democracy assistance in the Arab world therefore makes a major contribution to our understanding of what democracy assistance is and does. As she explains in the introduction, “The [book's] main research question is not whether political aid ‘worked,’ but rather how it worked, in actual practice” (p. 3, emphases in the original). To understand how democracy promotion works, Carapico focuses on the thousands of foreign assistance projects funded with the explicit goal of advancing democracy over the past two decades. These projects are supported by international donors and implemented locally by professionals working for a variety of governmental, intergovernmental, quasigovernmental, and nongovernmental institutions.
Carapico focuses on four domains of democracy assistance: rule of law, elections, women's empowerment, and civil society. Using a mix of evidence drawn from participant observation, field-based interviews, and English-language writings by and for practitioners, Carapico documents the paradoxes that characterize each subfield of democracy promotion. For example, in a chapter aptly titled “Patronizing Women,” Carapico discusses the cultural assumptions and stereotypes that pervade the field of international support for women's empowerment while at the same time documenting the vital resources that are afforded to—and then sometimes manipulated by—local civil society organizations via international donors.
In each category of democracy assistance, Carapico convincingly shows how the overseas development field has specialized. This specialization may give the impression of neutrality and depoliticization, but Carapico challenges the assumption that professionals are not political. Though professionals may be political in this book, they are not, however, treated as merely extensions of the governments that fund their organizations. Indeed, Carapico's “insist[ence] on distinguishing professional programs from White House rhetoric” is valuable; other students of democracy promotion should take heed (p. 111). Future scholars might push Carapico's arguments about the breakages between official government rhetoric and the design of specific democracy assistance projects even further by analyzing the rich, comprehensive project-level data on foreign assistance that has recently become publicly available by the AidData initiative.
In the end, Political Aid and Arab Activism eschews advancing a parsimonious theory in favor of complicating our understanding of democracy promotion. On the one hand, Carapico identifies ways that political aid in the Arab world has diffused democratic norms via professional know-how. On the other hand, she shows that political aid can be a tool used by the United States and other Western governments to assert their power over developing countries. Yet the organizations that receive democracy assistance are not entirely powerless according to Carapico's characterization; local civil society organizations, for example, can use political aid as a resource for their own ends. This may not lend itself to clear policy prescriptions, but providing policy advice is not Carapico's goal (p. 7). Instead, she seeks to provide readers with a better understanding of how democracy promotion actually works, which others can then use to design more effective democracy assistance programs. In that goal, she has resoundingly succeeded. I recommend the book to scholars and students interested in democracy promotion and international norms in the Middle East and beyond, as well as practitioners working in the field of democracy and governance assistance.
